Meh, How to deal with this?

Soldato
Joined
19 Oct 2002
Posts
9,974
Location
Jupiter
Before you guys say, this is more motors related than General Discussion.

Having some trouble with my Brother, another follow up from the crash thread, his attitude towards me stinks.

He blames me for the accident, and the upsetting thing is that my mum actually agrees with him. Being a house with no dad (left when i was 3yrs old) i'm sort of looked at as the older, more mature one.

Recently he has become more and more focussed on the accident being my fault.

Sunday just gone, we went to Festival Park (people in the S-O-T area will know of it) and he jumped in with me, and when i said we were going home and he wanted to stay, i said tough, my car, we're going. To which he replied "you need to have a think about who has no licence for the next 2 years, and who's fault this is."

I took this quite hard, as although it was me who asked him to drive the car to pick me up, it wasn['t me behind the wheel.

Tonight, another prime example, one of his mates lives on the inside of town. I drove past and he obviously saw me, and he text saying if your out and about come pick me up.

I was on my way to the pub at the time, however i did text back and say ill give you a lift home if you like, to which he replied "no thanks, ill remember this."

I come home tonight and he said "you need to take some responsibilities, i have nothing except for my bike and my feet, and i couldn't get a lift home"

So, even though i offered a lift home, he cut his nose off to spite his face. He asks for lifts daily, and i always feel pressured into giving him one to stop him kicking off, however i don't feel in any way responsible for what happened in his accident, after all, i wasn't driving.

My question is, whats the best way to have a good balance between not getting him to kick off, but also me not being a pushover and a taxi for him, as you will know, driving short distances in a 2.0 16v just drinks the fuel, i simply can't afford to taxi him about!

Advice appreciated,

Phil
 
How can you be responsible for someone elses accident when you wasn't driving? Seems a bit weird... People cant really advise you until we know the prerequisites.
 
Adam said:
How can you be responsible for someone elses accident when you wasn't driving? Seems a bit weird...

Thats just the way he see's it, i asked him to pick me up, then he had the accident, therefore he see's it as my fault that the accident happened.

Can understand he wants someone to blame, but when your own mum agreee's....

:(
 
No way its your fault, one of my mates rolled his pride and joy when coming to pick me up for something after i asked him as favour - did he ever mention it again, no, and i would have been seriously ****** off with him if he ever had done.

I would explain your feelings to your brother, and that you in no way am going to take responsibility for it, or be made to feel bad about it in any way. Its his driving that got him into trouble and he should deal with it himself.
 
If your playing taxi, ask him to chip in on petrol. Especially if its on a daily basis.

Hes driving = his fault. Dont see how he blames you if you werent in the car, what were you doing, using the force or something :p
 
Phil W said:
Original post

Whatever you do you'll be treating the symptoms and not the cause.

If you ask me, there's a lot of weird family / sibling / emotional baggage going on here that manifests itself as arguments over lifts, licences etc etc.
 
If he lost his license for 2 years the accident was clearly a result of his poor driving, not because you asked for a lift. Don't ever let him or anybody pressure you into doing something you don't want to as a result of it - stick to your principles, they make you who you are.
 
Phil W said:
Sunday just gone, we went to Festival Park and he jumped in with me, and when i said we were going home and he wanted to stay, i said tough, my car, we're going. To which he replied "you need to have a think about who has no licence for the next 2 years, and who's fault this is."

how come he has no license

did you ask him to drive without insurance or whilst drunk or something ?
 
So he crashed the car on the way to pick you up, and that means its your fault?

Right.....

So if I crash on the way to work, does that make it my works fault? I mean if didn't have to drive to work I wouldn't be on that road at that time.

Your brother is just looking to shirk his responsibility. He crashed it, it's his fault and thats life. Deal with it and move on.
 
Jez said:
No way its your fault, one of my mates rolled his pride and joy when coming to pick me up for something after i asked him as favour - did he ever mention it again, no, and i would have been seriously ****** off with him if he ever had done.
Agreed. I'm the "cause" of both of a friends accidents - one where he was dropping me off home and oversteered in to a ditch, and the other when drunk after I was egging him on to drive his cousins Impreza to a local "public drag strip", where he proceeded to hit 150 in a 30 and end us up in a ditch. I deep down feel responsible for both, and have once said that to him. He laughed at the thought, saying they were both all his fault.

I can imagine this may be different with him being your brother and all... but seriously, it's not your fault. At all. The quicker he grows up, realises the consequences of HIS actions the better.
 
andi said:
I think you need to have it out with him, it'll probably turn into a row and you'll both feel bad about it, but him blaming you isn't on, you weren't driving he was. He had the accident, thats not your fault.


I agree, it might be hard, it might be heated. But it really is the best option, both say what you need to and move on(hopefully)..
 
I have no idea what your brother's arguement is for blaming it all on you.

Apart from asking for the lift how were you even remotely responsible?

Burnsy
 
Back
Top Bottom