• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Mobo & E3400 holding back RAM speed

Associate
Joined
26 Jan 2012
Posts
4
Decided to upgrade my folks' PC, from a 10 year old Socket-A system (Athlon 1300 & 512MiB PC-100) to the following spec :

Asus P5G41T-M LX mobo
Celeron E3400 CPU
2 x 2GiB of Kingston PC3-8500 (DDR3 1066)

CPU is clocked at 13 x 200MHz, making the FSB clocked at 200MHz, quad-pumped to 800MT/s

Memory is locked at 800MT/s, same as the FSB, so is effectively performing as PC3-6400.

My theory goes like this :

Unlike AMD CPUs, the memory controller is off-die, on the northbridge. Therefore; memory bandwidth cannot exceed FSB bandwidth; which is limited to 800MT/s. The only way I can get the RAM to perform as DDR3-1066, is to run the FSB at 266MHz, ideally under stock conditions, with a CPU that is designed to run at 266MHz / 1066MT/s.

What's your thoughts here ? Does the memory run at 8 x 133, or 4 x 266 ?

My main system, is a quad core (Intel Q6600) system, with DDR-2 RAM (PC2-8500). There; the RAM and FSB essentially run at the same speed - 1066MT/sec.

I've not built a system in a while, and therfore have been out of the game for a while. This DDR-3 lark has thrown me :-/

Advice welcome

Justin
 
There's usually an option in the BIOS to adjust the FBS:MEMORY ratio.. your Q6600 will be running 1:1, but you can usually change it to 1:1.25 etc etc..

If you download and open CPU-Z, click on the memory tab and you will see what it is running at under FSB:DRAM.
 
With it being a G41 motherbord then probably not as options are usually very limited! I wouldn't worry too much about the speed of the RAM though, it's not really going to make a noticable difference on a system like that.
 
But can some kind soul explain DDR-3 to me, in terms of FSB clock, and MT/s.

Wikipedia doesn't explain it very well - at least; it doesn't make sense to me.

In my case; a 200MHz FSB, quad-pumped to 800MT/s; how is the DDR-3 running at 800MT/s ?
Is it 8 x 100MHz (half the FSB clock); or 4 x 200Mhz (FSB clock) ?

If my assumption, that the memory controller lives in the Northbridge, is correct; how is the memory bandwidth able to exceed FSB bandwidth ? FSB is the link between the CPU and NB. I don't know how "wide" the FSB is; but the RAM is dual-channel - 2 x 64bit = 128bit, or 16 bytes.

Would just like to understand the concepts
 
Front-side-bus is 64-bits wide, it would seem. So, at 200MHz (800 MT/sec); the maximum theoretical bandwidth is 6400MiB/sec. One stick of DDR3-800 could monopolise that by itself; never mind two sticks in a dual-channel configuration. And that's another thing; how do you squeeze 128-bits down a 64-bit bus !?

I think there's a lot of marketing b0ll0x going on here.

With a E3400 CPU; my FSB, and consequently my RAM (by virtue of the memory controller being on the North-bridge), is limited to an absolute maximum of 6400MiB /second.

Even if you ran a 333MHz FSB clock, giving 1333MT/sec and a theoretical maximum bandwidth of 10666MiB/second; there would be no advantage to running anything better than DDR3-1333 RAM. FSB bandwidth is the limiting factor

Now; can somebody tell me how DDR-3 RAM is clocked/pumped ?
 
Back
Top Bottom