Mortgage Rate Rises

Trying to figure out if a 10 year fix at 4.09% is a good deal. Interest rates are going to rise in the short term, but are they likely to come down as quickly.

Fix at 4.09% for 10 years and possibly overpaying a bit, but secure knowing what your payments are going to be for those 10 years.
vs
Fix for shorter at lower (if those still exist) and risk increased payments when you renew again in 2/5 years.

Which would you regret more?

We've just fixed at 4.14% for 5 years, and tbh I'm starting to wish we'd gone for 10, even at that rate!
 
Last edited:
I think selling to rent is foolish in any situation, its essentially gambling. You need house prices to fall otherwise you are in a much worse position.

For us elders, every time there has been a predicted crash someone will be on local news saying "I've sold to rent, it's going to crash" and it never ends well. It might work in liquid markets (a bit like shorting) but you'd need some incredibly lucky timing to make it worth it.
 
For us elders, every time there has been a predicted crash someone will be on local news saying "I've sold to rent, it's going to crash" and it never ends well. It might work in liquid markets (a bit like shorting) but you'd need some incredibly lucky timing to make it worth it.
Selling to rent is such a big gamble, you'd be better off releasing 30% of the equity on your property and taking it to the casino and putting it on black.
 
I just remember fixing a mortgage on my previous property just before the interest rates plummeted. Think it was only a two year fix thankfully so it didn't cost me as much as it could have.

There is no shame in fixing at a rate you can afford and not trying to second guess where rates will go. Just make sure you don't max yourself out. A house is more important!
 
Last edited:
People cheering lower house prices are not doing the maths* it would seem.

£500k @ 2% for 25 years = £2,120/month with a total spend of £635,895 (£135,895 in interest)
£500k @ 4% for 25 years = £2,638/month with a total spend of £791,426 (£291,426 in interest)

Lets keep the 4% and knock off 20% of the house price:
£400k @ 4% for 25 years = £2,110/month with a total spend of £633,140 (£233,140 in interest)

This means essentially NO monthly affordability saving, and paying almost £100k extra in interest of the life of the mortgage for a final total spend of pretty much the same.

Lets get crazy, drop prices by 50% and push interest rates up to 10%:
£250k @ 10% for 25 years = £2,272/month with a total spend of £681,465 (£431,465 in interest)

House prices are never going to drop enough to make the higher interest rates monthly affordability any better.

*calculations done using the MSE mortgage comparison tool, so assume the numbers are correct.
 
I recen
I just remember fixing a mortgage on my previous property just before the interest rates plummeted. Think it was only a two year fix thankfully so it didn't cost me as much as it could have.
We did this 5 yr fix in 2009 @ 6.89% makes me reluctant to take out another 5 yr this time round
 
People cheering lower house prices are not doing the maths* it would seem.

£500k @ 2% for 25 years = £2,120/month with a total spend of £635,895 (£135,895 in interest)
£500k @ 4% for 25 years = £2,638/month with a total spend of £791,426 (£291,426 in interest)

Lets keep the 4% and knock off 20% of the house price:
£400k @ 4% for 25 years = £2,110/month with a total spend of £633,140 (£233,140 in interest)

This means essentially NO monthly affordability saving, and paying almost £100k extra in interest of the life of the mortgage for a final total spend of pretty much the same.

Lets get crazy, drop prices by 50% and push interest rates up to 10%:
£250k @ 10% for 25 years = £2,272/month with a total spend of £681,465 (£431,465 in interest)

House prices are never going to drop enough to make the higher interest rates monthly affordability any better.

*calculations done using the MSE mortgage comparison tool, so assume the numbers are correct.

Your assuming interest won't lower in the future.

So higher outgoings for 5-10 years, but then back to 'normal' interest rates on the lower value will mean a saving over 25 years.
 
People cheering lower house prices are not doing the maths* it would seem.

£500k @ 2% for 25 years = £2,120/month with a total spend of £635,895 (£135,895 in interest)
£500k @ 4% for 25 years = £2,638/month with a total spend of £791,426 (£291,426 in interest)

Lets keep the 4% and knock off 20% of the house price:
£400k @ 4% for 25 years = £2,110/month with a total spend of £633,140 (£233,140 in interest)

This means essentially NO monthly affordability saving, and paying almost £100k extra in interest of the life of the mortgage for a final total spend of pretty much the same.

Lets get crazy, drop prices by 50% and push interest rates up to 10%:
£250k @ 10% for 25 years = £2,272/month with a total spend of £681,465 (£431,465 in interest)

House prices are never going to drop enough to make the higher interest rates monthly affordability any better.

*calculations done using the MSE mortgage comparison tool, so assume the numbers are correct.
I don’t think people that hope for house prices falls think that far ahead. Prices fall for a reason and that means those that couldn’t buy a house before certainly won’t be able to after. You will more likely see more wealthy individuals swoop in and take up anything cheaper as they aren’t likely to be exposed to interest rates or need a job to fund their purchase.
 
People cheering lower house prices are not doing the maths* it would seem.

£500k @ 2% for 25 years = £2,120/month with a total spend of £635,895 (£135,895 in interest)
£500k @ 4% for 25 years = £2,638/month with a total spend of £791,426 (£291,426 in interest)

Lets keep the 4% and knock off 20% of the house price:
£400k @ 4% for 25 years = £2,110/month with a total spend of £633,140 (£233,140 in interest)

This means essentially NO monthly affordability saving, and paying almost £100k extra in interest of the life of the mortgage for a final total spend of pretty much the same.

Lets get crazy, drop prices by 50% and push interest rates up to 10%:
£250k @ 10% for 25 years = £2,272/month with a total spend of £681,465 (£431,465 in interest)

House prices are never going to drop enough to make the higher interest rates monthly affordability any better.

*calculations done using the MSE mortgage comparison tool, so assume the numbers are correct.
Nice illustration.
I agree largely, the fixation on the initial cost of purchase is a perverse one, and the wrong one. The only likely benefit of a lower initial cost of purchase tends to be the gatekeeper for first time buyers who need x% deposit to get a mortgage.

However, it must be said your argument is predicated on the interest rate being the interest rate for the entire duration of the mortgage. It also doesnt take into account inflation, which is the spectre in all of this. £2638 now vs £2638 after 6 years of 10% inflation (smoothed out) are very different numbers.
 
'Very high rates'. I'm guessing you're a bit younger than me.....so maybe you don't know any different. I mean, I was too young to care too much last times rates were that at that level, but I was aware of it.

5%? Normal rates. Rates that keep a lid on house price inflation, and reward savers.

Probably older than you think unfortunately. Late on the housing ladder. Much to my cost.

37 now.

I've only had a house 2 years. Due to poor decision making and generally being indecisive about it.

So I've never seen high rates.

5 pc is high for mortgages now. Especially for recent buyers who (like me really) over stretch to maximum.
The pull to max out is strong. Moving is expensive. You're likely in your first house 5 years at least. It makes choosing a lower option harder.

But end of the day 5pc will cripple many. Hopefully we have enough warning for people to pay ERCs etc and get on long term fixes so by time it is 5-6pc many have dodged it.


Also hoping it doesn't stick around that high too long. For the sake of everyone with new or recent mortgages
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom