If it still has the same issues as the original Droid Razr, I don't think it will be that good.
Tbh my recollection of the issues affecting the original were basically:
1) No ICS - not essential by any means, and an update will be coming
2) Size/shape - Subjective, plus it's a 4.3" screen, and it's very thin - there's isn't really anywhere else to go. Also it seems reviewers prefer the shape of the Maxx

3) Camera - Probably the only downside worth considering, but then, it's a phone not a camera.
4) Battery - Solved in epic style, apart from complaints that it isn't removable - but that didn't exactly stop the iPhone from being a success.
5) Locked bootloader - A fair complaint which by all accounts is laid at the door of Verizon vs Motorola, but if ICS is all it shapes up to be then perhaps this won't be as big an issue as with previous iterations of Android, plus the phat battery should also render many of the 'low-voltage/long battery life' ROMs less relevant.
From most of the Maxx reviews, the biggest issue is calling Motorala a bunch of *ahems* for letting people buy the original then releasing this 3 months after
