• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

NAS Advice

Associate
Joined
1 Aug 2003
Posts
868
I'm considering getting a Nas after many many years of thinking about one and not being able to get it due to finances.. And now here I am considering one again in probably about the worst time to get one given the storage insanity. But I do need one to be able to perform proper data backup and I can afford one now.

Anyway, I can't make my mind up between getting a 2 bay or 4 bay one. Everyone says get a 4 bay so there's headroom, which I can understand. However given the current global situation I think it changes the situation somewhat. Being a little pessimistic I'm not sure when/if we're going to see HDDs go down to an acceptable price point. Hence having a 4 bay Nas when there's little likelihood of actually being able to fill the slots, is redundant.

Currently I have a brand new 8tb 3.5inch hdd I can put in a nas. And I'm faced with using another + the nas which does drive up the overall cost. 8tb drives are just over the £300 currently. Given the price difference between 2 and 4 bay nas, I could make a fair saving going with just a 2 bay.

Anyway, does anyone here have any advice regarding making a nas choice now in todays climate?
 
If you go the diy route, you don't need the latest and greatest CPU as long as you are not expecting to use transcoding.

I built one using TrueNAS Scale 2 Years ago.

CPU - AMD Ryzen 3 3200G with Vaga GFX
RAM – 32GB 2400MHz (2*16GB)
MB - Gigabyte A520I AC
5xSeagate IronWolf 10 TB NAS Internal Hard Drive HDD
Network - Intel X540-T1 RJ45
Power supply - Be quiet 300W
Case Jonsbo n2

Obviously you do not need 32GiB of memory, 8GiB would probably do.

I think I spent about £450 for it all without the memory, HDD's, and the 10Gbps NIC is optional so that would save you an extra £50.

If you want prebuild then Asustor is a good brand.
 
Honestly, with drive prices where they are I'd still lean 4 bay, but not for the "fill it up" reason. The enclosure is a one-off cost and the drives are where the money goes, so paying a bit extra now for empty slots is the cheap part. A 2 bay locks you in: when you outgrow it you're buying a whole new NAS plus migrating everything, at whatever the drive market looks like then.


That said, if you only ever plan to run two drives, a 2 bay is fine. Just decide up front whether the second drive is for mirroring (RAID 1) or extra space, because with 2 bays that choice is all you get.


Also agree with sastusbulbas that a NAS isn't a backup on its own. Even with a mirror, keep a copy of the important stuff somewhere else, like an external drive you plug in occasionally, or cloud for the irreplaceable bits. Your existing 8TB could do that job if you end up buying something else for the NAS itself.
 
Back
Top Bottom