Needle in a haystack

I always assumed it referred to the hay needles used to bind bales together before they used bailing machines. I imagine that loosing one would be quite a common occurrence and that they would be difficult to find...

/Salsa
 
It's just a very old proverbial phrase. The older version is "a needle in a bottle [i.e. bundle] of hay". Sir Thomas More used a variant of it in 1532: "to go look for a needle in a meadow".
 
See, I dont think it would be that difficult to find a needle in a hay stack.

Youve got two options:

1. Go arms flailing until you get *****ed
2. Just keep shaking the hay and moving from A to B. Eventually it'll fall it. Its heavier.

20minutes. Tops.

Actually, third option and 5 minutes tops.

Burn the hay stack.
 
Finding a particular needle of hay would be harder.

Really?

I think it would be harder to specify a particular strand of hay in the first place, let alone find it.

Seems I'm not the only person that thought it was a sewing needle but continue thinking it's the made up phrase that you originally thought it was :)
 
I always assumed it was a sewing needle, and funnily enough there was an episode of Brainiac last week or the week before asking what the easiest way to find said needle was

1. Setting the whole lot on fire
2. Putting the hay in water and finding it that way
3. Sifting through the hay and passing from one pile to another.

I believe the setting fire to it option worked out the fastest :)
 
I always assumed it was a sewing needle, and funnily enough there was an episode of Brainiac last week or the week before asking what the easiest way to find said needle was

1. Setting the whole lot on fire
2. Putting the hay in water and finding it that way
3. Sifting through the hay and passing from one pile to another.

I believe the setting fire to it option worked out the fastest :)

Mythbusters done it first I believe.
 
What is it's an aluminum needle?

I'm currently fashioning a sign that reads 'No non-magnetic needles to be lost in this haystack' that we can display by the haystack. I appreciate that I could have extended this to include all forms of needle, but then we'd have an MRI machine sitting around going unused.
 
Mythbusters done it first I believe.
Weird, they seem like intelligent people on that show.

I'd understand if it was Brainiac thats a kids show but I could tell you burning a haystack would be the quickest way...without attempting it. Its just obvious.
 
Weird, they seem like intelligent people on that show.

I'd understand if it was Brainiac thats a kids show but I could tell you burning a haystack would be the quickest way...without attempting it. Its just obvious.

But how would you prove it? Its more fun fdoing that just saying 'meh, its obvious'.
 
Back
Top Bottom