Yes I have driven both, the 1.9 has more grunt, but it isnt as balanced. Hey its not just me, all 205 experts have said the same for years. 1.9 has 10bhp at the wheels over the 1.6, the 1.6 has 30bhp at the wheels over the XS. If your 1.6's didnt feel much faster than an XS, they must have been pretty tired. Noticing a 10bhp difference more than a 30bhp difference just doesnt add up unless something is awry.
Anyway, got it home, 185 mile drive, Engine is very tired, needs a serious overhaul. Synchro on 3/4 is suspect. Think it was running on 3 cylinders a lot of the time. Not blowing any smoke, cam is rattly, oil is clean. Didnt check compression ofc and with its lack of use the fuel injectors could be gunked up, needs further diagnosis.
Got it for £2k as a result.
Gonna see which is the best way forward engine wise, rebuild or replace.
If I replace, I may go sacriligeous and just stick a BX16v/MI16 engine in.
The chassis is sound and tight, so will just need the brakes uprating, lowering 25-40mm.
The choice is whether I retain standard or go for the out and out performance. Decisions Decisions.
Best thing is the condition of the interior/bodywork/underside is amazing! Sunroof doesnt leak and the vacuum seal still works.
Drivers door lock is shot, and the drivers window rolls itself down.
Clutch is heavy as hell, and I think the new cable is binding, probably a routing issue.