New subfloor with engineered wood floor

eidolon

eidolon

eidolon

Soldato
Joined
31 Oct 2002
Posts
13,892
Location
Newcastle upon Tyne
I've just bought a house which is a bit of a project. The last week has been spent ripping everything apart and during that process I've decided that the original floorboards have definitely seen better days so I would like to replace them before I fit my wood flooring.

I've never done this before so I'm just reading up now however I thought I'd ask the OCUK collective for their opinions.

Is the best solution something like 18mm WDP plywood? I will be fitting engineered wood flooring which is 14mm+3mm so I assume that this combo would be nice and strong? The last thing I want is flex and squeaks.
 
I would pull the old Floorboards up and replace with 22mm Caberfloor. And don't forget the glue....We are mid renovation on an edwardian house. Floor levels all over the place once levelled it was much easier to fit Caberfloor (or similar) and now the floor feels like concrete.
 
mickyflinn said:
Big time.
Click to expand...

Completely opposite to what I've heard... Chipboard is cheap and dirty. Ply is substantially more solid.

Installing 80sqm of it, so I suppose time will tell.

+ Op... Don't think you want soft wood.

You want the external plywood at 24 a sheet.
 
rexehuk said:
Completely opposite to what I've heard... Chipboard is cheap and dirty. Ply is substantially more solid.

Installing 80sqm of it, so I suppose time will tell.

+ Op... Don't think you want soft wood.

You want the external plywood at 24 a sheet.
Click to expand...

Having 22mm WBP ply in the bedroom and nearly 5000sq feet of caberfloor everywhere else. I wont be buying ply for the floor.

The bedroom squeaks like so bad I'm considering ripping it back up. But its going to be a guest bedroom so I keep asking myself am I really that bothered
 
We have chipboard in our loft conversion and while it's flat it makes more noise than the original floor boards everywhere else!
 
mattyg said:
Having 22mm WBP ply in the bedroom and nearly 5000sq feet of caberfloor everywhere else. I wont be buying ply for the floor.

The bedroom squeaks like so bad I'm considering ripping it back up. But its going to be a guest bedroom so I keep asking myself am I really that bothered
Click to expand...

That's pretty interesting. Did you baton it etc?

I'm avoiding tg because if you need access under floor you're stuffed.

In my ideal world I'd tear the floors up and put traditional floorboards!
 
rexehuk said:
I'm avoiding tg because if you need access under floor you're stuffed.
Click to expand...

No more than you are with giant sheets of ply or chipboard it's perfectly possible to pull up a single board from tongue and groove just fun a jig saw down peach side.
 
a1ex2001 said:
No more than you are with giant sheets of ply or chipboard it's perfectly possible to pull up a single board from tongue and groove just fun a jig saw down peach side.
Click to expand...

If I had taken that advice on my current build... I'd have been dead or have a flooded house.

I've got pipes sitting literally 1mm below surface of chipboard right now as well as cabling!

I found a 3 meter breaker bar far more effective and fun! Jump on one end, floor explodes.

It's interesting seeing ways people do things though, I think I'm going to continue on path of straight edge ply, and we'll see in a few months if I'm swearing!
 
Weyroc or caberfloor and poyurethane glue(the stuff that foams)
and screws,lots of screws
glue tops of joists before laying the boards .Do the joints too

You will not have any sqeeking after doing this (BUT you not be able to take up any board without cutting it to pieces in the future
 
The Craig said:
Is there anything significantly wrong with the existing floor? Ie squeeking etc? /made of MDF?
Click to expand...

It's been patched all over the place (with MDF in parts). Has bits missing and is loose so rather than try to patch it some more I thought I'd just start from scratch and replace it all.
 
The idea is to use a circular saw and set depth to bottom of tongue - these days use a multi tool to go across T&G board -- A wrecking bar is OK if you want the lot up.
 
rexehuk said:
That's pretty interesting. Did you baton it etc?

I'm avoiding tg because if you need access under floor you're stuffed.

In my ideal world I'd tear the floors up and put traditional floorboards!
Click to expand...

Access is easy. unless you want proper access. But we've just ripped up the old floorboards and they were T&G

Access via
http://www.screwfix.com/p/erbauer-s...gclsrc=aw.ds&dclid=CMj9jsPLktQCFUZFGwodJAEKEw

and

http://www.screwfix.com/p/erbauer-a...gclsrc=aw.ds&dclid=CNT54dPLktQCFbET0wodmxIMpg
 
I replaced the upstairs floor in my house which was originally 40+year old chipboard with 18mm plywood from Wickes. The existing floor had all swelled from water/disgusting rotten carpet.

We didn't glue it or use any particularly fancy boards. We left spaces of a couple of mm between board joins and ensured that all joins were supported by a joist or a noggin. We put quite a few new noggins in to support it too.

Screw wise, we used these:

http://www.screwfix.com/p/spax-flooring-screws-4-5-x-60mm-300-pack/88716

They are absolutely fantastic. They have a screw thread, then a flat part, then more screw thread. This means that the board does not lift at all when you're screwing it in and also, it prevents squeaks because the board and joist are on separate threads. They use a torx bit too which is unbelievable. The bit never ever slips. I could have impact driven through the joist without it slipping if I wasn't careful. We used a LOT of these. Probably way overboard, like a screw every 8inch. But I didn't want any creaking.

We're now a couple of years in and it still feels absolutely solid with no creaks. We also took up one of the boards to give access to the central heating when installing a new bathroom recently (we wanted a towel rail). The board came up dead easy and went back down perfectly again. No damage to it what-so-ever.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom