Leather is effectively an investment...
Of course it’s dearer, but it’s also going to last much longer, look and feel better, and something that isn’t ever talked about because it isn’t ‘practical’, is that it’s nice to have nice things.
I just bought the Midnight Blue leather icon (haven’t actually got it yet).
In addition to researching comfort, reliability, quality etc, I decided I wanted noble.
Why? Because it’s an aspirational brand. It’s a brand you see all over the place with streamers, people on forums showing off their ‘uLtImAte gaming Roooomz’ etc, and it’s always highly regarded. I don’t mind admitting, I want in on that. I’ve already got a project log thread up for my recent PC build, and I fully intend to update it with ‘look at my super sexy chair of justice’ or similar.
Childish, but fun.
I wanted leather for all of the real benefits of leather over PU, but I also just wanted to ‘have’ a real leather chair. Again, an aspirational thing.
I also went for the blue over the black, despite the black being heavily discounted right now. Why? Because I’m paying a lot of money for a chair and it’s intended to last a long time. For the sake of that extra cash, over the entire lifetime of the chair, I decided I should get what I really wanted not just almost what I wanted for less money.
TLDR, there’s a psychological benefit to getting nice stuff too.
However... I’ve always been skint, I’ve always had to be thrifty, or at least sensible in the past. An expensive leather chair for playing computer games on is not something I would have forked out for previously.
Now I’m 40, I have much more disposable income than in years gone by, and I’m lucky enough to be able to get a swanky leather chair. If stretching to leather can’t be justified for you, or if you really shouldn’t be spending that much, of course don’t do it. The cheaper PU chairs are still great chairs by all accounts.
Ultimately, there are loads of both tangible and intangible benefits to the leather, but it’s loads of money for a chair and only you know if it’s worth it to you.