In terms of gameplay yes, but when you press Y to accuse them of lying, Phelps goes on a mini rampage, sometimes shouting in their face, then it goes to your notebook and if you haven't got what you need you press B and he just goes "Oh, my mistake" or "Just checking". It just spoils it a little bit for me. It would've made more sense if they'd added the whole I THINK YOU'RE A LYING MURDERER line after you'd chosen the evidence. For me it just broke the immersion a little bit because the majority of the dialogue in this game is excellent in my opinion.