Please help me choose a monitor for eyefinity setup

sportbilly

sportbilly

sportbilly

Associate
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Posts
80
I am struggling to settle on a monitor choice for an eyefinity setup.

I have a racing cockpit with triple screen mount - an Obutto

I will be using the screens for sim racing - iRacing mainly and more "fun" stuff too like Shift 2 & Dirt 3. Plus for flight sims - Rise of Flight, IL2 - Cliffs of Dover.

As well as normal PC use - web - home photos etc.

So a responsive screen with low input lag is probably the most important feature followed by image quality / colours.

I am really tempted by the LG W2363D for 120hz at a great price but the monitor bezel - bottom edge looks unsuitable for triple screens - unless any owners can tell me otherwise.

The Acer GD245HQ looks like a reasonable option after it's recent price drop - Looks more like it will be useable in an eyefinity setup on a triple screen mount and again has 120hz for smoother motion.

I see the Dell U2311H recommended here a lot - nice thin bezels and an IPS screen which obviously has better viewing angles - lowish input lag (around 10ms when measured at tftcentral) - not as responsive as TN panels but will it really matter ?

Finally I have been looking at a cheaper route - the Benq G2420HDBL seems to receive good user reviews and I have found it for around £145 per screen. It looks like it has thin bezels and suitable for eyefinity - a little larger screen than the Dell too. Not found any professional reviews though regarding input lag / responsiveness etc.

I am moving from a NEC 24WMGX3 which is a VA panel but when set to through mode has low input lag - 8ms. I did notice that it was not as responsive as my old 24" OcUK value monitor - the DGM VA panel one - gives the NEC a run for it's money !

For reference I am happy enough with the responsiveness of the NEC as long as input lag us kept in check too.

I have the budget of up to £750 but don't want to spen that if £450 would do fine ie the Benq screens.

So please push me in the right direction.

Cheers
 
Any ideas chaps ?

I realise I'm choosing between 120 hz or not or IPS panel or not etc.

That is why I could do with some guidance as to which monitors would be suitable for that type of gaming in an eyefinity setup.

Some general views about those monitors and how they would be suitable for triple screen setups or not would be great.

Cheers
 
Hey sportbilly :)

I have 2x LG W2363Ds and I love the monitors. I am intending to move up to eyefinity but with them on a desk. I cannot get a tigh fit with them next to each other unless they are almost horizontal. Like this _ _ _ instead of the right and left being slightly diagonal.

I can get a picture uploaded tonight when I get in from work. The reason they can't fit flush is at the bottom(The part you talk about) is a nice bulge on the bottom right and left. As you can see in this picture:
35_7710_2.jpg


The white circle seems to bulge out. If you were to pry it off somehow i'm sure it'd be easier to put them flush.

I did buy the LGs becuase of the 120hz and they are lovely but I am finding problem with transitioning between the 2 in windows causes a lot of stuttering and I am looking into it and someone suggested the 2d GPU clocks aren't high enough to put up with 2x 120hz.


If you have any questions about the W2363D then I will be happy to answer!


Also the Obutto cockpit looks freaking awesome! Is that your full time desk for normal pc use aswell?
 
Thanks for that - as I feared the LG is not ideally suited - the bulge outwards at the bottom would make it difficult to overlap the monitors and the bulge at the side (the white disc) will also make it tricky when side by side. Shame it would be a winner at the current price for a 120hz screen.

I have also read some difficulties in multi-monitor 120hz setups too regarding obtaining and keeping a 120hz output across 3 screens.

Maybe a little ambitious thinking 3x120hz screens at this time - plus it will be really pushing my system to output over 60FPS across 3 screens in most games - although iRacing should be okay.

I haven't set the Obutto up yet but Yes it will be my desk too - has a keyboard / mouse tray that rotates across your lap for FPS shooters and keyboard use.

Any other recommendations for a nice monitor for triple screen setup - thin bezels, low input lag and decent responsiveness ?

Cheers
 
I haven't dealt a lot with eyefinity but those Dells look perfect tbh.

The bezels don't bother me all too much but the dells look extremely thin and its a monitor held in high regard. Until I get my 3rd LG I can't comment on them fully or how they look with 3 monitors.

Please tell me how the obutto is with FPS shooters when you get it setup :)
 
Ayup sport!
Here be some pictures for you!

Here's a picture showing the bulged preventing them from going flush.
IMG_20110531_182305.jpg

Here's what it'd look like with the bulges:
IMG_20110531_182253.jpg


I attempted to remove the white bulges and VOILA they come off! With absolutely no force what so ever, just pop on and off. And they fit almost snug together now!
IMG_20110531_182452.jpg
 
Thanks that's interesting - that allows side by side positioning more easily - for racing games though I would want to angle the outside screens in at least 30 degrees - Is that still possilbe with the rounded bottom bezel - file it down ?

I would also ideally like to overlap the screens a little too in order to reduce the perceived bezel width - Is it possible to remove the bottom part of the bezel - where the lighting thing is ?

Back at the drawing board - just thinking if the new 27" Asus screens would be too big in triple screen - will try to find some reviews. The Asus 24" model looks like a potential candidate too - will have to do some research .....

If not think I'm tending towards the Dell U2311H unless anyone gives a strong vote for the Benq G2420HDBL - looks nice and should be suited to triple screen and usefully around £70 per screen cheaper than Dell.

Cheers
 
Last edited:
You can most likely pop the front panel of the LG but I will not try :p

With some simple and smooth filing and sanding to curve out the bottom corners you could get a nice flush finish. depends on what you are willing to do.
Want me to get some more pictures up tomorrow night? I'll try take some better ones for you
 
ewarwoowar said:
You can most likely pop the front panel of the LG but I will not try :p

With some simple and smooth filing and sanding to curve out the bottom corners you could get a nice flush finish. depends on what you are willing to do.
Want me to get some more pictures up tomorrow night? I'll try take some better ones for you
Click to expand...

If you don't mind as I haven't ruled out the LG - particularly as it's even cheaper this week. If I can get around the bezel issue it seems to be a winner for the money - 120hz screen for standard TN 60hz price.

.Max. said:
This looks like it would work nicely? Very thin Bezels :D

http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=MO-025-AS&groupid=17&catid=1425&subcat=#
Click to expand...

Not sure about that one whilst the side bezels are thin it looks a little clumsy at the bottom edge - may not matter when they are lined up side by side but doesn't look like it will be as neat as the Dell, Benq or the Asus I linked.

cmndr_andi said:
Unfortunately, this monitor doesn't use RTC/overdrive like the Dell U2311H IPS, so it will show much more ghosting in fast-paced games than the Dell.

This review shows how another non-RTC E-IPS monitor (the ViewSonic VP2365wb) compares to the U2311H in terms of response time/ghosting.
Click to expand...

Yep - keep coming back to the Dell - would prefer a slightly bigger screen for when I'm only using the one screen - console use or non-eyefinity stuff. As long as it's responsive enough the input lag seem low enough and the better viewing angles will help with setting up on a triple screen stand.

Only problem is they either seem to be out of stock or going up in price.

Cheers
 
dell U2311H...Is ideal for multiple reasons:
1) Brilliant pic quality (whats the point of having three equally crap screens...thats just more crap to see :P)
2) The inpt lag nonsense is a pointless worry, I play BFBC2 and BLOPS on mine all the time and no worries, if there is lag, ghosting I don't see it.
3)This monitor has a display port, you can't do eye-finity without one.
4)slim bezel so sits together well.
5)brilliant stands (look good and very sturdy)

cost is an issue, in which case maybe check out the vp2365wb for the two side ones and a nec EA232WMi for the centre one (has a display port) but tbh I think the dell is the way to go!
 
TBH didnt really see the lg comments until you mention it, just the talk of tn :P but I stand by my point ips over tn anyday, costs more yes, but its worth it! :D
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom