• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Plex Server Advice

Associate
Joined
4 Aug 2022
Posts
275
Location
Bristol
I am looking to upgrade my Plex server, but finding it a bit of maze!

Currently I'm running a Lockerstor AS6510T, which is a 10 bay NAS, I have 2 2TB Samsung 870 Pro SATA SSDs for the boot drive (mirrored), 2 1TB 980 NVMe M2 Pros as cache drives, 5 16TB Exos SATA drives in Raid-5 as the main storage drive (for 48TB) and an old 3TB SATA drive as my TV recording drive.

The NAS runs fine as a storage device, plus backup from from my PCs and also a Git Server, but it doesn't support hardware transcoding, which wasn't a problem at the time but is now more of an issue as I'm wanting to stream out of the house more, and also seem to be having annoying issues with buffering of TV recordings.

Basically I would like to try and replicate the functionality, but with the addition of decent hardware transcoding (say at least 3 4K streams).

Reading up on it, it seems like I shouldn't need anything super powerful, possibly even an Intel i5 chip with integrated graphics should be up to the task of transcoding, is that right?

Other things that are important are RAID and ideally 10GBps network, plus plenty of space and slots for drives.

I was looking at an Intel Core i5 14500 as the CPU as that seems to have a decent enough GPU built in for transcoding

The motherboard becomes an issue though, generally not finding ones with 10GBps network and a decent number of SATA connections and RAID support, possibly either the network or RAID could be handled by an additional card? Though a little wary of compatibility\driver issues or other problems? Does anyone have any suggestions?

OS wise, I'm not hugely familiar with Linux, but that seems like it might be the best option, possibly UnRAID, which maybe solves the RAID issue? I'm more familiar with Windows, but don't know how well that compares?

Also, are there issues with hardware support and things, I've seen the occasional mention of different OS's maybe not supporting hardware transcoding, or driver issues with Linux?

I'm hoping to reuse the drives I have, so that would be the 2 SATA SSDs mirrored for the OS drive, the 5 regular SATA drives in RAID-5 as the main storage and then the single 3TB drive as recorded TV storage. Possibly could make use of the 1TB M.2 cache drives though, guess they'd actually be large enough to work as the OS drive (in a mirrored pair) and probably faster than the SSDs, then the 2TB SSDs could maybe be the TV recorder, or other storage of some kind.
 
I have the same cpu - 14500 - Intels uhd770 and quicksync is more than enough to transcode a few simultaneous videos (honestly more than a few) - just make sure it's enabled whichever os you go with (I personally went with truenas, a friend of mine went down the unraid and jellyfin route - just a quick one on this truenas can also use raid - I have raid-z1 setup atm so I wouldn't eliminate it off the bat, unraid seems like a solid option, I think when it comes to the os just watch a few how to videos for what you are going to be doing and see what os you like the look of better)

Motherboard I think I can help less with, I went with an Asus board to have an ipmi card/ functionality - been worth it for myself already, I think you may want to look into pcie cards for that network bandwidth and the same for extra sata ports if need be.

As for the linus support I think the main issue is to not have bleeding edge hardware, I think the issues can come with new components and maybe a delay in linux support, but I'm still relatively new to linux as a whole myself and my hardware has always been abit behind the times

Hope this helps
 
16TB drives in RAID5?! That’s …. an interesting choice. Have you looked at the probability of a failed rebuild at all? I would suggest you might want to. Presumably you have a PlexPass already for hardware transcoding? If not, ouch, you missed the boat on lifetime pricing, may be a decent discount for Black Friday. Probably better to look at JellyFin at this point, which does it for free and handles live TV and IPTV quite well.

First point would be that you could put a uSFF PC in front of the current NAS and let it run Plex and other services, literally anything with newer than HD630 iGPU is a safe bet for content that isn’t AV1, and that will be 8th gen onwards, so a little N100 or similar can do multiple 4K transcodes, but you tend to get better value from one of the more traditional HP/Lenovo options. This will be a hell of a lot cheaper than any other option.

If you want to go self build, it really depends on your priorities are, if it’s IOPS, ZFS tends to be the better bet, if it’s power efficiency with media storage and you can live within your cache drive for fast writes and single drive read performance (and only spinning up a single drive to read media) then UnRAID is the obvious choice, and it can also do ZFS.

Hardware wise, IPMI is a non negotiable for me, it can be added to standard boards, but it’s easier if it’s built in. I tend to need less compute, but value hardware transcoding, and other than moving data between servers, 10Gb is rarely used, so made peace with 2.5Gb USB NIC’s. In today’s market, it can take a little lateral thinking, memory prices are horrific, so either something Supermicro X10 (DDR3) or X11 (DDR4) based may be better options. Drive connection wise, an HBA in IT mode is the preferred option for scale with either TN or UR.

Also, please use a UPS, the number of times people spend a lot of money on redundant storage but refuse to protect it against the most likely and obvious of threats is staggering.
 
Last edited:
As above, just leave the NAS to do NAS things, and add a mini pc to deal with the transcoding. Pointless trying to reinvent the wheel if you already have the storage side sorted.
 
Back
Top Bottom