Poll: Poll: Are the BF2 remake maps better than the BF3 ones?

[OpenToSuggestions]

Hey all,
Whilst I very much feel the BF2 maps that were recently released for BF3 are missing Mashtuur City, I feel that these maps are still much better than the BF3 maps.
I feel some of the BF3 maps (I haven't learnt all the names yet) are complete stalemate where the middle of the map becomes an enormous grenade/rpg/sniper fest.

Are the maps from the Karkand expansion map better than the regular BF3 ones?
Yes - The BF2 remake maps are better
No - The BF3 ones are better
They are equally as good
Pancake

Could a mod turn this into a Poll please .

 

[setter]

I think theyre worse than the bf2 ones. On the whole the game is worse than bf2, and bfbc2 for that matter.

 

[Kosmiche]

Oman and Wake - No

Sharqi and Karkand - Yes

...I'm completely split, you need a "Maybe" option.

 

[McGray]

I think theyre worse than the bf2 ones. On the whole the game is worse than bf2, and bfbc2 for that matter.

This.

 

[Kosmiche]

I think theyre worse than the bf2 ones. On the whole the game is worse than bf2, and bfbc2 for that matter.

Yes agree 100%

 

[RedDanDoc]

They're good fun to play on but don't seem to be as big as the BF2 ones. Especially The Gulf of Oman.

 

[OpenToSuggestions]

Oman and Wake - No

Sharqi and Karkand - Yes

...I'm completely split, you need a "Maybe" option.

I agree. I am talking about the Karkand maps as all four together as a whole .
I do see what you mean though!

 

[steve45]

i'll be honest, i find myself having more fun on the original BF3 maps, i like the BF2 remakes though, well all except for wake island.
i never really got into BF2, which is probably why i dont have any particular draw to them, or nostalgic pangs.

 

[badcompany]

I think theyre worse than the bf2 ones. On the whole the game is worse than bf2 .

 

[OpenToSuggestions]

Why is the game worse than BF2?
It is different to BF2 and I don't have the same love for it, but then with BF2 I had just got broadband and it was the whole 'wow' factor (I did have 1942 but I was a retard and bought it thinking it would be like Allied Assault!). I even upgraded my ram to 2GB so I could enjoy 64 player maps without the PC crapping itself!

I tried BF2 again after playing BC2 and the short draw distance and terrible dated feel of it put me off .

 

[setter]

Its a console port, plagued with bugs, cheats. No voip, no commo rose, the menus are poorly layed out, and it plays very poorly compared to bf2 or bfbc2. Ill still play it, but i just dont get as much enjoyment from it as the other two games ive mentioned. Pre btk it was fine, but typical dice, they go and screw things up with updates.

 

[OpenToSuggestions]

Its a console port, plagued with bugs, cheats. No voip, no commo rose, the menus are poorly layed out, and it plays very poorly compared to bf2 or bfbc2. Ill still play it, but i just dont get as much enjoyment from it as the other two games ive mentioned. Pre btk it was fine, but typical dice, they go and screw things up with updates.

My only real gripes about BF3 are that the menu system is crap, the graphics (yes it is very good but the textures are not that high and the way buildings are destroyed doesn't meet the hype) and that I wanted 40 v 40 maps as BF2 achieved 32 v 32 in 2005.

These are all just small things though and whilst BF3 is really far from perfect I couldn't go back to an older BF game now as it would just feel old.

I like the new versions of the BF2 maps but they are very different now as buildings that were previously not enter-able now are. It should concern EA that people think their maps from 2005 beat their new ones!

 

[OpenToSuggestions]

Nubby double post.

 

[Evoss]

All of the maps in BF3 feel sort of the same, bit of a disappointment really.

 

[Angst]

Bored of this game after only 30hours and gone back to bfbc2.

 

[TOL247]

still lovin the game but the helli's spoil it now..too hard to shoot down.

 

[_lecro_]

still lovin the game but the helli's spoil it now..too hard to shoot down.

Really ! I find them incredibly easy to shoot down even on softcore

As for the maps i think the BF2 remake maps are rubbish,
it was a major disappointment after waiting for so long for some of my favourite BF2 maps

If they made some new maps for BC2 then id give up on BF3 TBH !

 

[Qdos]

I filter out the B2K maps when I'm looking for a game now as I really don't like them. It's a shame, as I loved them the first time round - they just don't seem to work with BF3 for some reason.

 

[James J]

still lovin the game but the helli's spoil it now..too hard to shoot down.

I actually agree with this as I've put no less than 6 stinger missiles into 1 helicopter and it was still in the air :S

I HATE wake island remake though as it doesnt suit the new pace of BF3 at all. BF1942 was pretty damn slow paced so that sort of level suited it nicely but on BF3 its the complete opposite. Karkland is superb though, seriously love that map.

 

[Witcher1979]

I only play on the BF2 maps, they are by far the best in BF3