Pairing them with which CPU?
Will you be OC'ing the CPU?
Will be OC'ing the GPU's using a custom bios?
Free performance and all
Play it safe. Clean start and better PSU. 6 years is a long time. Especially if it's out of warranty, and the PSU company will then not cover any damages to the rest of the hardware if the worst were to happen.
Another vote for the G2.