Funnily enough 443 was the max stable fsb I could get my x38 board. 1 fsb greater and prime would fall over. I played around with voltages on everything and even silly voltages before I discovered that with a quad 443 was the max FSB I was ever going to get on my motherboard and then bought the p45 board.
Funnily enough that seems to be the case for my P45 board as well. It's currently sitting at 441fsb 3748.5Mhz stable but getting that extra 50mhz/6fsb has been impossible. Not even with silly volt through nb/vtt (1.4V+).
To be fair the board you had the Giga P45 UD3P is known to achieve the highest fsb with a 45nm quad and that's why you had such success. With the ASUS P5Qs however it seems to be hit and miss.