Question Hard Disk shock

Associate
Joined
16 Oct 2024
Posts
3
Location
Brazil
If you eject the 2.5" HDD + enclosure case USB3.0 in Windows 10 and then hit the HDD case with your hand, will it damage it and generate bad blocks? Did the shock move the HDD on the table?
0edfcab7-c9ac-4c92-90d7-8373f7a7e8dc.png
 
It depends how quickly you hit the drive after 'ejecting" it from Windows. Most external hard drives take at least a second before spinning down which can also take a couple of seconds - so say 5 seconds to completely spin down after ejecting the drive. If you hit or move the drive hard enough during this time, this could be enough to cause physical damage that could translate into bad blocks.

In summary, don't move the hard drive until you know it's spun down.
 
In my situation i ejected in windows 10 after 6 seconds i pulled USB 3.0 My hand shock HDD case in table moved case
My cases IS Kesu and Orico
My models HDD 2.5" are: WD10JPVX-08JC3T5 and HGST HTS541010A99E662
 
Last edited:
You'll more than likely be fine, but as above if you're using spinny disks then wait a few seconds after ejecting/unplugging before moving it.

Or even better - ditch spinny disks for flash. - then you don't have that problem and can shake it to your hearts content.
 
Back
Top Bottom