Rate your 360 games!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Hostile_18
  • Start date Start date

Hostile_18

Hostile_18

Thought this be a good idea to let us rate the games in our collection to see which ones offered us the best experience! Heres my ratings:

Gear Of War - 7/10
A good game in coop but wouldn't like to play it through by myself anytime soon.

PGR3 - 3/10
Realistic racing games just don't do anything for me I'm afraid.

Dead Rising - 6/10
A good game but with a horrible save system. The mall isn't too big either really.

Marvel Ultimate Alliance - 8/10
Really good old school game. If you like the source material you can help love this! Especially good if you liked the old school beat em ups like Streets of Rage and Golden Axe etc.

The Godfather - 8/10
A surprise hit for me this one. Initially the graphics weren't up to the standard of next gen games but look deeper and its a great game with tons of gameplay and things to do. I put off this game on release because I thought nothing could beat "Mafia" for this type of experience, while I wasn't wrong this game came very close! It was only the (seemingly) rushed ending and city graphics that let it down slightly.

Rainbow 6 Vegas - 9/10
The game I bought the console for. Just beats Raven Shield for greatest Rainbow game in my opinion. The only negatives being multiplayer levels don't include anything as good as the franchise classics and enemy's respawn as you explore the level.

Oblivion 7/10
A good game with a lot of detail its just that it doesn't seem as fun as other great RPGs. I think that has a lot to do with the lack of a really compelling story.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Gears of war : 8.5/10

Loved it to bits, just the right lenght and the first game I actually completed in a long time

The Darkness 8/10 : Surprise hit for me, great story so far and looking forward to concloding it this weekend.
 
Oblivion - 9.5/10 Fantastic easy to get into RPG without the need for a degree in potions and magic to get it to work.

PGR3 - 7/10 good fun, good graphics, too short lifespan

FM2 - 9/10 way better than PGR3, graphics are fantastic, gonna be playing this for ages

Gears of War - 5/10 Swapped it out as I really didn't get on with it, ok the graphics are the best ever seen in a game, but it isn't that good of a game.

Rainbow 6 - 8/10 Fantastic game, easy to use the controller with, great atmosphere, great online

I have other games, but can't remember what they are off the top of my head!
 
I'll add a few:

Forza 2: 9/10
GoW: 9/10
PGR3: 8/10 - Would be 9/10 but better games are out now.
R6Vegas: 7/10 - Let down by its single player.
GRAW1: 9/10
GRAW2: 8/10 - Short but oh so sweet.
Oblivion 9/10 - Vast and brilliant.
Crackdown: 9/10 - Highest fun factor ever. So much to do and enjoy.
 
Gears Of War - 10/10
Fight Night Round 3 - 10/10
Rainbowsix Vagas 8/10
Forza 2 - 8/10
PGR 3 - 6/10
Saints Row - 5/10
Burnout Revenge 6/10
 
Last edited:
Dont have one anymore, but these arewhat i used to have:


Gears of War - 4/10 - boring as hell but nice graphics.

PGR3- 7/10 - my first game and not bad

Saints Row - 9/10 - probably my most played 360 game when i had one.

CoD3 - 6/10 - not bad, but no where near as good as cod2.

Oblvion - 10/10 - one of my all time favourites, but got it on PC instead for mods.

GRAW - 7/10 - fun game but single player wasent that great.
 
Forza 2: 5/10
GoW: 9/10
PGR3: 9/10
R6Vegas: 8/10
GRAW1: 7/10
GRAW2: 8/10
Oblivion 8/10
Crackdown: 7/10
Burnout Revenge: 9/10
Smackdown vs Raw 2007: 9/10
The Darkness: 8.5/10
Guitar Hero 2: 7/10
DiRT: 6/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 7.5/10
Kameo: 6.5/10
Pro Evo 6: 6/10
Lost Planet: 6/10
Flatout: 7/10
Need For Speed MW: 5/10
Hitman Blood Money: 8/10
Splinter Cell Double Agent: 8/10
Perfect Dark Zero: 7/10
Top Spin 2: 8/10
Amped 3: 6/10
Dead Rising: 9/10
Call of Duty 3: 6.5/10
 
Last edited:
Gears of War: 9/10 - Loved every minute of it.
Fight Night Round 3: 9/10 - As a boxing fan this game is just brilliant.
Oblivion: 7/10 - Good game when I've played it, just not dedicated enough time to it, maybe I would rank it higher if I did.
Call of Duty 2: 8/10 - Enjoyed it, but didn't capture me like the first one did.
GRAW: ?/10 - I think I've tried this once, little brother loved it though.
Hitman: 7/10 - When I'm in the mood I love this game, gotta be in the mood though.
Tomb Raider Legend: 8/10 - Got the game on the back of playing the demo. Return to form for Lara.
Madden 07: 5/10 - Dissapointed big time. I prefer NCAA Football now, just hope the 360 version get PAL release.
Condemned: 6/10 - Enjoyed all of it I've played so far, but its been sitting on my must play pile for a while now and I've still not went back to it.
Lost Planet: 9/10 - Suprised how much I really enjoyed this game, loved the online multi-player.
Dead Rising: 8/10 - I love Zombie movies and games and this didn't dissapoint. Still prefer Resident Evil on my Gamecube though.
 
Have only had my 360 a couple of months so not had a chance to explore all my games have to offer yet, but here we go:

Gears of War - 6/10
Only played single player so far and it's far too short. Graphically gorgeous but very linear and samey

Flatout: UC - 8/10
My fav game at the moment. Nice looking smooth graphics and a good variety of gameplay types. Particularly enjoy this one on Live..especially Destruction Derbys. It can sometimes be tricky to find a decent derby though as many hosts allow trucks which totally ruins the balance of fairness.

PGR3 - Unrated
Not even got round to playing this yet. Played the demo and enjoyed it though, and had PGR on the original XBox so I'm sure it won't dissapoint.

Rainbow 6 Vegas - 5/10
I've never been a great fan of stealthy tactical FPSs and unfortunately this one didn't change my views. Graphically there's far too much bloom and I found that made the enemy much harder to spot. I hear the PS3 version fixes this so would be interesting to try it out. At the end of the day though I'd rather go charging in all guns blazing and this just doesn't work with R6 :)

Test Drive Unlimited - 7/10
Not played this one much but what I've seen has been very enjoyable. I love the open environment...being able to challenge other online players to races. I spent a good couple of hours just driving round messing about with others. It's also a very good looking game. The bikes could be easier to control, but I like the way the cars beocme harder to turn the faster you go..very realistic.

Gun - 7/10
The reviewers didn't seem to like this one but I've enjoyed it so far.

Saints Row - 9/10
What a cracking game! I've always been a GTA fan so didn't think it could even come close but it was certainly at least on par. Although the storyline game was far too short, the side missions made up for it. Insurance Fraud was hilarious! It's a lovely looking game as well..if GTA4 looks at least this good then I'll be happy (minus the screen tearing!) :) Unfortunately the Saints Row online experience wasn't such a good one. The game types were fun, but it suffered from bad lag.

Guitar Hero 2 - 8/10
Another cracker. I was an addict of GH1+2 on PS2 so just had to get this on 360. In my opinion GH2 had a weaker song lineup compared to the original but the 360 version adds a few extra songs to the mix to keep you interested. It's a game you can enjoy with friends or on your own and has massive reply value..well worth the money. It's a shame there's no online facility in game though as that would have added a whole new aspect to it

Overall I'm impressed with the 360 so far. There's still plenty of action left in my games collection to keep me going for the next few months while I save to go on holiday! :)

Andy
 
Last edited:
Darkness - Enjoying it, very interesting story - however am stuck and sort of letting it gather dust :o 8/10

Gears Of War - Another that I enjoy SP, however MP is a letdown for me and sours it a bit, as I wanted a good FPS 7/10

Forza 2 - Really enjoying this, more than I thought 9/10

Dead Rising - Love Zombies, seems like I can do endless things, however find it tricky to keep up with the story tasks 9/10
 
Hitman Blood Money: 8/10
Crackdown: 9/10
Oblivion: 8/10
G.R.A.W: 7/10
Saints Row: 8.5/10
Ridge Racer 6: 4.5/10
Call of Duty 2: 7.5/10
Kameo: 8/10
Condemed: 8/10
Perfect Dark Zero: 6/10
PGR 3: 8.5/10
Test Drive Unlimited: 7.5/10
Dead Rising: 5/10 (I've never given it a chance)
Pro Evo 6: 7.5/10
R6: Vegas: 9/10
Gears of War: 9/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 8/10
Splinter Cell Double Agent: 7/10
Tony Hawk's Project 8: 7.5/10
Lost Planet: 7/10
 
forza 2 10/10,
only game i have, and will be for a while,
Absolutely love these games, and is the best of its kind after LFS for the PC.
 
Gears of War - 9/10 : First game that's made me sit down and complete it in one sitting, co-op mode made it so much better. I wont go on about the graphics, it's fair to say I quite like them though...

Test Drive Unlimited - 7/10 : A bit hit or miss with me, I've not been able to play it online so that might be a factor. Times I can be bothered sitting down to play it I like it, it's a good idea for a game really.

Oblivion - 8/10 : I do love this game, bought it on 360 as I didn't have my PC at the time. It's a great game that looks good too, quite like the music aswell, relaxing game.

Dead Rising - 8/10 : I'm scared of zombies, like smashing them with a guitar though.

Amped 3 - 7/10 : Got this game very cheap in the sales, it's worth it for the mental cutscenes alone. I like snowboarding games aswell so it's just added bonus.

PGR3 - 8/10 : Nice graphics, good multiplayer, solid game.

Saints Row - 8/10 : I struggle to play the story on this game as I just like messing about, it's always been that way though. As an inbetween until GTA4 it's worth it. Fun gameplay and comedy physics, online seemed pretty awesome too.

Madden 07 - ?? : I've not had time to play my copy yet! The few games I had at my mates were decent though, looks nice aswell. I expect a decent rating.
 
GoW - 9/10 - Second fave game, again, glitches make it a 9.
PES6 - 9.5/10 - Favourite game, but nothing is perfect hence not giving it 10.
Fuzion Frenzy - 5/10 - Excellent when friends are around.
DiRT - 7/10 - Excellent graphics and quite playable but handling and physics of cars let it down.
Forza 2 - 8/10 - Great fun albeit it gets too repetitive.
NHL 2K7 - 7/10 - Still learning it but seems great so far.
The Darkness - 8.5/10 - Again, quite new to it and FPS games usually bore me but the gameplay of this and the gripping storyline really appeals to me. Loving it.
Cars - 3/10 - Bought for the GF, but I thought I'd give it a go, pretty mediocre but target audience is no doubt kids.
 
Best console i've ever had, so good i bought 2 :D
far too many great games and not enough time

guitar hero 2 - 9/10
forza 2 - 9/10
the darkness - 9/10
Call of duty 3 - 9/10
rainbow six vegas - 9/10
call of duty 2 -8/10
condemned - 8/10
Graw 2 - 8/10
Colin mcrae dirt - 8/10
fight night 3 - 8/10
Oblivion - 8/10
PGR 3 - 8/10
splinter cell - 8/10
Dead rising - 8/10
FEAR - 8/10
Virtua tennis 3 - 8/10
Flatout - 8/10
Prey - 8/10
saints row - 8/10
Brian lara - 7/10
tomb raider legend - 7/10

Not so good...
Crackdown 5/10
lost planet - 5/10
pro evo 6 - 5/10
godfather - 5/10
ridge racer 6 - 5/10
hitman blood money - 5/10
test drive unlimited - 4/10
Gears of War - 3/10
Burnout revenge - 2/10
need for speed wanted- 1/10
just cause - 1/10
 
Forza2 - 5/10 (great graphics, but the game is boring the hell outta me now, nothing on PGR3).
Lego Star Wars - 8/10 - Love it
Viva Pinata - 7/10 - Great game, bit monotonous but surprisingly addictive
Rainbow Six LV - 8/10 - Intense, tactical and great fx. Fantastic multiplayer
Guitar Hero II - 9/10 - Addidtive as hell
Chromehounds - 6/10 - Graphics and sound aren't great but pretty addictive
Crackdown - 7/10 - Plenty to do and see, graphics 'ok'
F.E.A.R. - 7/10 - The 'magic' has gone having played it on the PC years ago, but still a good blast. Multiplayer good too.
Smackdown V Raw 2007 - 1/10 - Slow, hate the graphics, hate the game. (sorry nokkon)
X-Men - 6/10 - Not baaaaaad, bit repetitive, but pretty addictive.
Splinter Cell DA - 9/10 - love it, absolutely love it, but need zero distraction to play
Darkness - 8/10 - Not really got into it yet, but it's growing on me, could be the best one so far.
 
~J~ said:
Smackdown V Raw 2007 - 1/10 - Slow, hate the graphics, hate the game. (sorry nokkon)
Click to expand...
The graphics are awesome... honestly, no accounting for taste there :(. Thought it would be nice for you to try something different.
 
For the record, can I add the following to my list:

Dead Rising - 2/10 - Great graphics, gameplay left me wanting to kill myself. Overrated crap in my opinion.


(waits for attacks)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom