Recommend me a case please!

Associate
Joined
1 Nov 2005
Posts
262
Location
Essex, UK
Hi,

I've more or less picked all the other components, I just need some advice on what metal box to put it all in...

I'm not a big fan of doors on cases, but if you think the perfect case for my needs has a door then it's no biggie.

I've got 4 HD's and a 7800gtx, and I'll be buying a Tuniq Tower 120, so I need a fair bit of space. At the moment I have an Antec P150 and the 7800 is far too tight up against one of my hard drives.

So basically I need a roomy, quiet case that preferably doesn't weigh a ton because I go to LAN parties quite regularly.

I've been reading through posts for a few days now and still nothing is jumping out at me as the obvious choice. Antec 900? Akasa Eclipse 62? Argh!

Any help would be very much appreciated.
 
if you were up to bungee mounting a hard drive then i would go for the lian li A05B, its small, and lian li, so well built, no front door. has space for 3 HDDs, hence the need to bungee your fourth in one of the DVD/CD bays.

thats my 2pence

that or lian li PC7

link:

do a search in google, someone has done a mini review, raikiri also posted it on this forum somewhere, it definitely looks good, and im planning to use it for a C2D setup sometime later this year.

edit: in fact i think you can ignore my bungee suggestion, just mount the 4th HDD in the floppy bay.
 
Akasa eclipse great case to work in :)

The antec 900 has a lot of case fans but because it is made of steel it wont match the cooling of the eclipse ;)
 
Hamoodii said:
Akasa eclipse great case to work in :)

The antec 900 has a lot of case fans but because it is made of steel it wont match the cooling of the eclipse ;)

thats not true any more theres a review showing that aluminium and steel cases are no different its all about fans
 
The more and more I look into this, the more I think I'll go for a Lian Li, the finish just looks so great.

My only real concern is being able to comfortably fit my 4 hard disks and the 7800gtx. Anyone seen any photos anywhere of such a set up?

Even a similar set up in an Eclipse would do, I'm not 100% sold on a Lian Li, just about 99%... ;)
 
jaykay said:
thats not true any more theres a review showing that aluminium and steel cases are no different its all about fans

ok fair enough, but the antec 900 has about 4 case fans, the eclipse will match the cooling capability of the 900 with only two fans ;)
 
Gray said:
The more and more I look into this, the more I think I'll go for a Lian Li, the finish just looks so great.

My only real concern is being able to comfortably fit my 4 hard disks and the 7800gtx. Anyone seen any photos anywhere of such a set up?

Even a similar set up in an Eclipse would do, I'm not 100% sold on a Lian Li, just about 99%... ;)

Originally Posted by claude05
I posted this case review just a little while ago at *********** and I thought you guys would like to see it. Thanks to Ryboto for his helpful and patient answers and thanks to the rest of you who helped me with my decision.

I've been looking for a small, stylish and most importantly quiet case for a while to house my computer. My previous case was a full tower cheming(sp?) case with 4 80mm fans. as far as cooling was concerned it no longer was capable of keeping my components cool without my having to ramp up the speeds on the fans to an intolerable noise level.
After doing some research and talking with the guys at Silent PC review I narrowed my choices down and finally made a decision. I purchased the new Lian Li A05B case. So far I am very impressed and thought you guys would like a small review in case you should be looking for something similar.


The A05B next to my Cheming case


I needed something small since my apartment isn't very big and I need to keep as much real estate as I can. Also I needed the case to be as quiet as possible and I knew 80mm fans wouldn't cut it, so 120mm fans were a must. As far as looks, I wanted something Minimal, low on garrish LED's, and stylish.

http://i39.photobucket.com/albums/e...18/_2180110.jpg
The A05B, like the V1000 series, places the MB upside down, notice the Power supply plug at the bottom, I'll explain this in a bit


The dimensions of the case are W8.26'' x H15'' x D19.3''. Despite its small size it's considered a Midtower case and in fact does hold motherboards up to 12"x9.6" in size with room to spare. It comes equipped with 2x 120mm fans that run at about 1500rpms, but unlike most (I imagine) cases, the airflow is reversed. This means that the hottest parts (especially the CPU) gets the coolest air first.


The Airflow is from Back to Front!

Another unusual thing about the case is its placement of the Power Supply. The PSU is placed in the front of the case with what would normally face the back facing the front, in doing this the PSU is now also used as a front exhaust!

http://i39.photobucket.com/albums/e...18/_2180119.jpg
The A05B with the front cover removed.

The front cover easily pops off to reveal the Drive bezels, power buttons, front 120mm exhaust fan and the oddly placed Power supply. The case comes with a 90 degree plug that connects to the PSU and goes from the front of the case to the back socket where the normal Power supply plug is then attached. The Power supply is held in place by a face plate attached to the front by 4 thumbscrews for easy removal and is held up in the case by an "L" bracket that holds it about an half inch from the case floor.


PSU face plate with thumbscrews

The case holds 2 DVD/cd drives and a Floppy drive. The Harddrive cage can hold 3 Harddrives. It uses rubber gromits that attach to rails, this keeps vibrations down and holds the drives securely. My drives are virtually silent now and that is a big improvement! Due to the size of my 8800GTS and the placement of its power plug it makes it difficult to place a drive on the top-most rail, those of you with smaller video cards will have no problem populating all three rails should you want to.

http://i39.photobucket.com/albums/e...18/_2180125.jpg
The Harddrive cage. If you look at the top of the cage you can see the rail system

The panels on both sides of the case are held with thumbscrews and come of easily. Despite being made of thin aluminum, the panels feel sturdy and have some weight to them. They fit perfectly and tightly so there is no worry about them resonating.

http://i39.photobucket.com/albums/e...18/_2180123.jpg

http://i39.photobucket.com/albums/e...18/_2180127.jpg
Both side panels off. The second image shows my quickie cable routing job.

The case gives you enough space to route and hide cables. I tried to keep the cables organized and once I have more time I will do a better job but so far, with minimal effort, it's much better than what was possible with my old case.

The top of the case sports hidden USB/FireWire/Audio ports. This is great for someone (like me) who likes to keep their case on the floor.


Stealth Ports ***!

For this to be an objective review I have to give you some of the bad along with the good. The Airflow, while interesting, could be problematic with some configurations. I imagine it would be somewhat impeded if the entire Harddrive cage was populated. However I have to point out that quite a large volume of air can be felt coming out of the front so perhaps my speculations are incorrect.

My CPU runs very, very cool (remember it's getting the coolest air first) but, at idle, my 8800GTS is running about 3C to 5C hotter. Warm air pools at the top-back and keeps the area noticebly warmer than the rest of the case, despite all the perforations meant to let hot air seep out.I run everything at stock, so my heat output is much less than some of you on this site who are overclocking your components. I will add that I am happy with the temps in contrast to the noise levels. With this in mind, however, I would hesitate to recommend it for overclockers without considering modding the case to add a top or side fan for further ventilation or using it for a watercooled rig.

As it stands with its two 120mm case fans, my Zalman 7000alcu, single 120mm fan PSU, and the surprisingly quiet 8800GTS, the case is fairly quiet. It's not silent, but it is very quiet, especially when under my desk. I will be changing the fans someday soon to Yate Loons, and perhaps changing some other components to make it even more silent (this quiet stuff is addictive...)

One more thing, if you are looking for an HTPC case I think this would be perfect with one caveat: you need to be able to control the speed of the DVD drive. Since the A05B is so light, at 16x the drive spins fast enough to shake the case and this makes quite a bit of noise. I'm currently using Nero Drive speed to control the spinning of the drive. I set it to a minimum, about 4x when watching movies, and it's almost silent.


So far I am very happy with this purchase. The case is everything I wanted. I couldn't be more pleased. I hope this review helps you if you are looking for something similar. Thanks for your time and attention.
 
post above shows the A05B with 2 of the 3 HDD bays filled, you could fill the first, as well, and just slot another in the floppy space, theres a 120mm fan up front, sucking hot air out, so it should keep them reasonable cool, the only thing i could suggest with this case is possibly buying a PCI exhaust >CLICKY< to remove hot air at the back top of the case, by the gfx card

but the cooling SHOULD be enough at stock, and its a lian li, so the quality will be sweet. hope that helped, sorry about the pics as links but im in a rush and cba to do it properly :p
 
Last edited:
Hamoodii said:
ok fair enough, but the antec 900 has about 4 case fans, the eclipse will match the cooling capability of the 900 with only two fans ;)

you had both?.....obviously not:)
 
I like the idea of the separate compartment for the hdds of the Lian-Li 1000. At least that way I know they won't be in the way of my graphics card, and I'll be able to fit all 4 of them in there no problem.

Now, do I go for black or silver? I have a Fatality X-fi with the break-out box in black. Would this look ok in a silver case, or should I opt for black?

Decisions decisions!
 
Gray said:
I like the idea of the separate compartment for the hdds of the Lian-Li 1000. At least that way I know they won't be in the way of my graphics card, and I'll be able to fit all 4 of them in there no problem.

Now, do I go for black or silver? I have a Fatality X-fi with the break-out box in black. Would this look ok in a silver case, or should I opt for black?

Decisions decisions!

black is pretty much always>silver ;)
 
Gray said:
I like the idea of the separate compartment for the hdds of the Lian-Li 1000. At least that way I know they won't be in the way of my graphics card, and I'll be able to fit all 4 of them in there no problem.

Now, do I go for black or silver? I have a Fatality X-fi with the break-out box in black. Would this look ok in a silver case, or should I opt for black?

Decisions decisions!
But you need to take one the the harddrive cages out of the v1000 to be able to fit in some PSU's...

So this would then mean you have space for 3 harddrives in the bottom compartment and any other harddrives will have to go into the 5.25" bays..
 
Last edited:
chaparral said:
But you need to take one the the harddrive cages out of the v1000 to be able to fit in some PSU's...

So this would then mean you have space for 3 harddrives in the bottom compartment and any other harddrives will have to go into the 5.25" bays..

Ah, thats interesting. Is it easy to fit a HD in the 5.25" bay, do I just bungee them or will I need to buy some kind of 5.25" to 3.5" bay converter thingie?

Any idea if my Hyper 580W psu will fit in without removing a cage?
 
Gray said:
Ah, thats interesting. Is it easy to fit a HD in the 5.25" bay, do I just bungee them or will I need to buy some kind of 5.25" to 3.5" bay converter thingie?

Any idea if my Hyper 580W psu will fit in without removing a cage?
Must the power supply not fitting problems without removing one the hardrive cages are with the Modular PSU's...


You can use a cheap 3.5" to 5.25" converter like this

drive_rails.jpg


or pay more and get something like this one http://www.lian-li.com/product/product04.php?cl_index=2&sc_index=5&ss_index=12

EX-33-b.jpg
 
Last edited:
Damn! I need the floppy bay because every now and then when fixing friends old PCs etc it's just handy having stuff on a floppy. Not only that, I can't find anywhere in the UK that stocks the EX33B.

Looks like I'll have to go with the brackets. OCuk don't do them, any idea where I can get my hands on some cheaply?

Having said all this, OCuk are out of stock of the black V1000 anyway.

Pah!
 
Do a yahoo search for " Internal Hard Drive Rails "

Gray said:
Damn! I need the floppy bay because every now and then when fixing friends old PCs etc it's just handy having stuff on a floppy
Get a USB pen flashdrive....much better and more useful then a floppy drive
Gray said:
Having said all this, OCuk are out of stock of the black V1000 anyway.
Am just waiting for my Silverstone TJ07 i ordered last monday...It's on backorder now :mad: (not ordered from OCuk)

tj07w.jpg
 
Last edited:
Got lots of usb pen drives, not all old PC like booting from them though, do they? ;)

That's a nice looking case you're waiting on.

In your opinion, better than the V1000, and if so why?
 
Hamoodii said:
Akasa eclipse great case to work in :)

The antec 900 has a lot of case fans but because it is made of steel it wont match the cooling of the eclipse ;)


Having had both cases theres no way an Eclipse can match the cooling remotely compared to an Antec 900 :)

Theres a 200mm fan on the top for christ sake :D

Eclipse 62 is an awesome case but atm im happy with my Antec 900 for now, its a much better case perhaps not in terms of space/ease of installation but the features/cooling outdo the Eclipse 62.
 
Back
Top Bottom