Rooney

Soldato
Joined
27 Oct 2010
Posts
3,053
Location
ireland
I think rooney is the most over rated player ever same as ronaldo rooney last year fair play to him scored 34 goals in all but none of them were great goals that would have u up off of ur chair most of his goals were headers or tapins from 8 yards out and the pfa going to rooney was a disgrace droga scored so many great goals got more goals and assists than rooney yet they decide to give it to rooney it's just cos drogba is black and rooney is english. Also i think when Torres is on form he is the best striker in the world, what do u guys think?
 
Did Rooney win the PFA award? Really?

For some reason I've completely forgotten the results, laughable if true, while the OP comes across as.... odd and I don't think Drogba was ignored due to racism, he was signiifcantly better in every single area of his game than Rooney.

Better in midfield, better closing down players, better defending from the front and better defending at corners and things where he's immense. His passing/vision/playmaking put Rooney to shame, who spent the majority of the year finding simple passes quite hard to make. THe finishing goal scoring as said, Drogba scored a lot of great goals, from anywhere in any situation, Rooney did very little throughout games.

Rooney was like RVN, good, got goals but uninvolved for huge parts of games and could realistically be replaced by a dozen similar players, Drogba was Henry at his best, running games, bullying defenders(more with strength than pure speed, but defenders were utterly scared of both), dropping deep, creating chances for everyone, scoring from anywhere, freekicks, anything, just a massive influence on a team that also won the title.

ROnaldo though, not even close to over rated, scored a little less in the league than Messi, but had a big goal scorer ahead of him and a bit of a flop team around him, while Messi is in an established side with quality all around and he was the focal point. In a more established team with better players Ronaldo has moved up pretty significantly since last year.

Rooney, horribly over rated, if he was African/French/South american/anything else most people would have said great but lucky year, absolutely useless this season, never in a million years would he have won a PFA type award, he's never been a world class striker, he's never been a world class forward, he's never been a world class playmaker, nor a world class midfielder.

I've said this a million times before, throughout his career he's played the fox in the box, the winger, the wanna be Scholes midfield playmaker(but does this by dropping WAY too deep which leaves a striker missing upfront), the harrasing forward. But he's still after 5-6 years, yet to specialise in a single role all season long, whenever given a role, he wants a different one. When he was a deep lying forward he wanted to be the man that got goals, when made a lone striker he drops back into midfield, the only position I've seen him comftable in was left wing, he was happy getting the ball and running forward, hard, thats what he does best, its the only time I've seen him influence games consistantly and use the strongest part of his game every game all game long and not spend the entire game trying to be someone else.

Theres potential for him to get back to his best, game dominating self, but he needs a single role, and its not tap in artist for me.
 
Last edited:
I think a lot of English players are over rated, as are many other players that play in the "Best League in the World" :)

It however doesn't make them bad players.

Rooney was playing very well last season, and has just lost all form since the World Cup.
 
So basically, Rooney is crap, Ronaldo is crap and the FA are a bunch of racists?

Yeah, I can agree with that. :D
 
Rooney overrated - correct

I have already stated this many times, he's had 1 good season that's all.

Ronaldo overrated - wrong

He can single handedly win the game for you, free kicks, long shots, dribbling, tricks, pace, strength, he is the complete package. I may not like the guy but he is ranked as either 1st, 2nd or joint 1st in the world. The other player being Messi. These 2 guys are in a league of their own.

Drogba underrated - wrong

he is ranked as being in the top 10 strikers in the world, the only thing that lets him down is his temper/passion, causing outbursts. I personally don't see this as a bad thing, but FA's do.

Ronaldo > Drogba > Rooney
 
Strangely I disagree with most of that, but you do have a case about Drogba last season, and I do think Torres is the best striker in the world when fit, the rest was wrong though
 
Drogba ought to have won player of the year last season, true. However, to say that scoring the number of Rooney's goals doesn't make him a good playing is ridiculous. So what if they're tap ins? They need finishing and, more importantly, need somebody in the right position to finish them. Rooney was exceptional last year at getting in those positions. If it doesn't require a great striker to score 30 plus goals a year, why don't more do it? Man Utd's creative midfield was no better last year than Arsenal's, Spurs', City's, Liverpool's (debatably), and obviously Chelsea, so why did Rooney score more goals than all of the strikers from those teams, except Drogba?
 
ok a lot of people disagree with ronaldo being over rated i will explain why i think he is RONALDO HAS NEVER PLAYED GREAT IN ANY BIG GAME FACT, he always scored 2-3 goals against bolton's and wigans but when it came to big premier league games like liverpool or chelsea how many times did we see him diving complainging to his team mates and not doing anything for his team in europe that stands to oh wait he scored a free header against chelsea in the final so hard to do that. For rooney he even said it himself without valencia he wouldn't have scored half the goals he did for me valencia was united best player last year.
 
Back
Top Bottom