Sanding wood floor

Soldato
Joined
22 Oct 2005
Posts
2,802
Location
Moving...
We had some wood flooring put down a smidge over 5 years ago. It's held up pretty well, but the oil is starting to wear thin in a couple of heavy traffic areas, and there's a few minor scuffs/scrapes, so I'd like to sand it down and give it a fresh coat of oil.

I was thinking of hiring a floor sander such as this one. Are they fairly simple to use? My only concern is that it only needs a light sanding to take the oil off, so is this a bit OTT? It's only engineered wood with a few mm of wear layer, so I don't want the floor sander to tear through all of it!

The area is only ~35 sqm, so I could potentially do it with my orbital sander. Would take a lot longer and burn through a fair few sheets, but perhaps I'd have a bit more control.
 
Soldato
Joined
9 Mar 2010
Posts
2,838
Remember to get an edge sander as well, unless you’re removing the skirting.

The speed at which it will obliterate your wood will depend on the grit of the sandpaper.

Your finish depends on all the same reason that effect normal sanding, so you’re willingness to go up through the grits to go from removing material to creating a smooth surface. I couldn’t imagine doing it without the correct tools - but I hate sanding in general anyway :D

“Oils” tend to penetrate the wood as well, so not 100% sure what you mean other than you might just want to give it a light pass to tidy up the reapply finish… in which case yeah, have at it by hand.
 
Soldato
Joined
31 Jan 2022
Posts
2,647
Location
UK
The problem with a large belt sander like that is that it can do a huge amount of damage in seconds. You need to experiment with different grit belts and they are very expensive. The advantage of them, is, of course, is that belt sanders sand with the grain, but honestly, I am really not sure you want to "learn" with your expensive floor. If all you need is light sand then you would probably do better with a random orbital sander. If you want a disc that lasts a while then seek out a real ceramic disks. They are very expensive, but they last much longer.
 
Soldato
Joined
25 Jul 2010
Posts
4,077
Location
Worcestershire
If you do go for the big sander, make 100x sure that you have nothing protruding from the surface, and you'll want to seal off the room as best you can. Even with the dust bag on, you'll get dust everywhere.
 
Associate
Joined
17 Nov 2015
Posts
349
Location
Northants
Surely you only need to key the surface them re-appy the oil? When I redo our worktops, you dont take it all the way back to bare wood, you just scuff the top up, to remove the sheen, take any marks out locally, then re-apply the oil.
 
Last edited:
Soldato
OP
Joined
22 Oct 2005
Posts
2,802
Location
Moving...
Thanks for the replies guys. I have just got a new orbital sander for the worktops. I'll time how long it takes to get through them, then work out how long it would take to do the flooring. It sounds like the safest option, so as long as it won't take crazy long, that might be the way forward.
 
Associate
Joined
17 Nov 2015
Posts
349
Location
Northants
We hired one of the HSS drum ones, but only the first time we did them, during the removation, and they were 100 years old, and covered in paint and muddy builders footprints! For the nursery i just used a palm sander as they were fairly clean anyway.

 
Soldato
Joined
13 Aug 2004
Posts
8,332
Location
England
Thanks for the replies guys. I have just got a new orbital sander for the worktops. I'll time how long it takes to get through them, then work out how long it would take to do the flooring. It sounds like the safest option, so as long as it won't take crazy long, that might be the way forward.

For a refresh of oil on the floors that sounds like a good option. When I re-oil my worktops I just go over them with some wire wool, it really doesn't take a lot.
 
Soldato
Joined
13 Aug 2004
Posts
8,332
Location
England
We hired one of the HSS drum ones, but only the first time we did them, during the removation, and they were 100 years old, and covered in paint and muddy builders footprints! For the nursery i just used a palm sander as they were fairly clean anyway.


HSS should have given you a much newer drum sander than that.
 
Soldato
Joined
25 Sep 2006
Posts
14,358
Beltsander and 120 grit sounds like your best bet.

Floorsander really is for stripping back and levelling boards, not just keying or skimming the surface in a specific area.

Used one on my O/H's 1920's, you'd be done in about 5 minutes flat based on what you need to do.
 
Soldato
Joined
21 Jan 2010
Posts
22,247
Is it proper wood? Even full plank can only afford to lose a fraction. Just use a handheld for the worst bits, don't take off material you don't need to.
 
Associate
Joined
16 Mar 2004
Posts
600
Location
Surrey
Lagler Trio will be enough to clean up for a re-oil
I think a mate of mine used that for a floor that needed a fairly light touch (it might have been solid wood though) - are they the ones that are basically a super sized random orbit sander with 3 discs?
 
Soldato
OP
Joined
22 Oct 2005
Posts
2,802
Location
Moving...
Thanks for all the feedback all. I played it safe and went with the orbital sander in the end. It was pretty slow going and quite uncomfortable being hunched over for hours on end, but I'm pleased with the end result.

I went right back to the wood and made sure to get all the oil off, so went 40 grit initially, then 80 grit and finished with 120. With hindsight, I probably should've done it sooner then I wouldn't have had to sand quite so much as I'd let it get quite patchy.

It's the first time I used the sander too (Bosch GEX 125-1 AE). Very impressed. I was lucky that the hoover nozzle fitted perfectly, so there was literally no mess to tidy up afterwards. I didn't get through too many pads either.

A few mins after starting to sand:
PXL-20240203-153517916.jpg


Half of the room re-oiled:

PXL-20240205-115115813.jpg
 
Soldato
Joined
21 Jan 2010
Posts
22,247
Looks great. I think for a novice/non-pro, safer and slower is worth oodles more than the potential of getting it wrong with a beastly thing. Saved a packet too on hiring someone!
 
Back
Top Bottom