Condemened was also very scary as it was very realistic...like real serial kilers etc..
Funnily I found some levels in Swat 4 kinda scary. Ya didnt know were the criminals were and stuff
ALso oddly I found dead space 1 and 2 not scary at all...They had jump out your seat moment sbut not scary.
For me scary is psychological like real creppy weird spooky stuff, psychological fear.
Dead space was more monsters jump out at you scary, like scary atm but not a whole atmospheric psychological fear such as silent hill.