Still not seeing it, there is no obvious movement to indicate contact and that camera angle isn't helping as the hand appears behind the ball with no depth to give perspective, could just be a reaction your seeing thinking he might catch it as that's what he was trying to do, the whole thing was accidental, not intentional.
Six Nations Rugby 2018
- Thread starter Destination
- Start date
Still not seeing it, there is no obvious movement to indicate contact and that camera angle isn't helping as the hand appears behind the ball with no depth to give perspective, could just be a reaction your seeing thinking he might catch it as that's what he was trying to do, the whole thing was accidental, not intentional.
So many daft refereeing decisions in that game, I don't see it being a decider (even though it was correct in my view).
The incident where an extended period of England attacking pressure gets up the 5-metre line and then Nowell goes in to secure a ruck and gets pinged for going off feet, which was absolute nonsense. Meanwhile England and Wales are throwing themselves superman style off feet at rucks the rest of the game, not forgetting both sides straying well offside. Just terrible, inconsistent officiating.
Looking forward to the next game, I'm English first and foremost but family is half Scottish, my annoyance at the grand slam being off the cards would be totally offset by happiness for the Scots to get a huge win
The incident where an extended period of England attacking pressure gets up the 5-metre line and then Nowell goes in to secure a ruck and gets pinged for going off feet, which was absolute nonsense. Meanwhile England and Wales are throwing themselves superman style off feet at rucks the rest of the game, not forgetting both sides straying well offside. Just terrible, inconsistent officiating.
Looking forward to the next game, I'm English first and foremost but family is half Scottish, my annoyance at the grand slam being off the cards would be totally offset by happiness for the Scots to get a huge win
Caporegime
Come on, you can see his finger bend back from the ball hitting it and then a split second later the ball changes direction when it then hits the knee. Either way, we were lucky. They didn't seem to be looking at that in the TMO and based on what they were looking at they got it wrong.
Looks like World Rugby have admitted the Wales try should have stood, I'm glad because the TMO should take longer with these decisions, they ultimately affect the game and the tournament as a whole and they need to get it right.
I don't see that at all, there is some movement but it could have just been a reflex as the ball hit his knee, rugby balls are quite heavy so you would expect to see more movement than that, plus the angle is a little deceiving anyway.
I don't see that at all, there is some movement but it could have just been a reflex as the ball hit his knee, rugby balls are quite heavy so you would expect to see more movement than that, plus the angle is a little deceiving anyway.
Caporegime
Not sure what you mean by "a reflex". In that slow motion video you can clearly see the moment it hits his ring finger knocking it back. It hits his little finger a split second later and then you can see the ripple the ball makes in his skin as it his hit knee. As to a rugby ball being quite heavy so it would move the fingers more; the finger gets smacked out of the way as the ball hits it and then the ball hits the next thing in the way after that which is the knee which doesn't give way.
Man of Honour
World Rugby confirmed yesterday that the TMO got it wrong and that it should have been a try so presumably they've had the chance to review all the available angles in a much more leisurely manner than the TMO and come to the conclusion that there was no knock-on or other impediments to awarding the try. http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/rugby-union/43046791. I'm not a big fan of Eddie Jones generally but I think he's got a bit of a point here that for the governing body to review and say it was the wrong decision might somewhat undermine the referee - then again I'm not so sure he wouldn't use it as vindication if the situation was reversed.
Soldato
- Joined
- 13 May 2003
- Posts
- 8,939
I think it is a mistake to undermine the TMO, Referre or Assistants after the fact. Better to say the decision stands and leave it at that.
How can you not see the ball moving his finger?
Why don't you try and independently extend the finger next to your pinky and see how possible it is without something hitting it..
Also, from memory, it looks like the English player touches the ball at the same time as the Welsh player. It didn't look like it at first glance but the English player's hand speeds up but it's very difficult to see, I missed it the first few times.
Why don't you try and independently extend the finger next to your pinky and see how possible it is without something hitting it..
Also, from memory, it looks like the English player touches the ball at the same time as the Welsh player. It didn't look like it at first glance but the English player's hand speeds up but it's very difficult to see, I missed it the first few times.
Last edited:
Yeah, that's a clear knock on then. Right decision for the wrong reason. Regardless, it was a very exciting game for such a low scoring affair.
In the end though, I'm just glad Scotland achieved some sort of redemption after ******** the bed in Cardiff.
In the end though, I'm just glad Scotland achieved some sort of redemption after ******** the bed in Cardiff.
Soldato
Really exciting weekend of rugby ahead of us. Really looking forward to Scotland V England for the Calcutta cup and of course Ireland V Wales...2 big clashes.
This is doing the rounds on FB and made me titter...
TBF some would get it...some are a six pinter or more...
This is doing the rounds on FB and made me titter...
TBF some would get it...some are a six pinter or more...
Soldato
excellent game from Ireland, great comeback from Wales.
Bring on the Calcutta Cup.
Bring on the Calcutta Cup.
Caporegime
We're getting wrecked 
Soldato
Congrats Ireland on winning the 6 nations.
Soldato
- Joined
- 13 May 2003
- Posts
- 8,939
Scotland deservedly leading. England a long way off good enough. Last few weeks has flattered them I think.
Don
Scotland have been riding their luck so far this half. Almost at the point of changing over and watching Take Me Out!
1st half won it. Thought England didnt seem up for it till the 2nd half and for once Scotland defence held when england kept coming at them. No nails left