• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Sorry another "spec me"

BigDannyO

BigDannyO

BigDannyO

Associate
Joined
15 Jul 2006
Posts
1,030
Hi everyone, hope you can help me out.

I've had my Dell for over 2 years now and have decided that the 3ghz P4 just cant cut the mustard anymore. So time to upgrade but I don't know which way to go. I cant spend any more than £200 and will be (hopefully) using all the components i already have:
PCI-E 7600GT
SATA HDD
2 x 256mb DDR2 PC3200 Non ECC
2 x 512mb DDR2 PC4300 Non ECC
Audigy 2
Random generic 350w PSU


I am leaning towards AMD but dont have a clue where to start (Athalon 64 3200 + MOBO?)
Or would i be better off just dropping in a Pentium D?
Or even getting a new LGA775 MOBO and going Pentium Duo?

I really don't know what to go for so any advice you can throw my way would be grately appreciated.

Thanks in advance,
Dan :)
 
thanks for the response

no it's definately ddr2, will this run okay on a 939 MOBO?

I take it then that the athalon 64 would be better ultimately than the pentium D and my current mobo
 
Do you overclock?

AMD wise

AMD Athlon 64 X2 Dual Core 4400+ (Socket 939) - Retail (ADA4400CDBOX) (CP-127-AM) £165 (i believe other competitors are selling this for less)

Intel wise
Intel Core 2 DUO E6300 "LGA775 Allendale" 1.86GHz (1066FSB) - Retail (CP-126-IN) £140

However if u go for that Intel chip you will need to change your RAM...and as you only have £200 you may be better off settling for something like:

Intel Pentium 4 945 Dual Core "LGA775 Presler" 3.4GHz (800FSB) - Retail (CP-132-IN) £130 in this weeks special offers...

Motherboard wise it depends which option from above u go for...either AMD or Intel so would have to buy a corresponding board i.e. depending on the cpu socket..

Also you will need to change that PSU sooner or later....

I hope this helps
 
I probably wont be OC'ing to an extreme level so it's not the most important factor for my decision, just short term bang-for-bucks really!

Looks like it'll be a athalon 64 then, it's what I was originally thinking but didn't want to commit when I could just as easily slot a newer pentium chip in my current board.

Thanks for your help!

xirokx said:
Also you will need to change that PSU sooner or later....
Click to expand...


Yeah what a bag of bolts it is... guess a new PSU wouldn't hurt :)
 
what socket is your current chip?

there is really not that much diff between the AMD X2 4400 and the second intel chip i suggested..

so if you merely wanted to swap CPU's then I dont see why its not poss...at least you wudnt have to change mobos then ;)

Instead of spending £200 you may only spend less then a hundred and be happy :) So would have more cash of PSU as well when the need arose..
 
the current chip is a Prescott p4 530 on socket LGA775.

As far as i'm aware I can put a pentium D on this board, but if i wanted a duo i think i would need a 775x board(?).

The reason I didn't know what chip to go for is cos I know a few years back AMD's were, as a rule, a better chip. Is this not the case any more?

Sorry for the stoopid question but I don't want to get a whole new mobo + chip when i could (as you pointed out) just get a new Intel chip instead!! :)
 
atm with conroe intel are the daddies...

however it makes sense just to swap the chip its purely a case of what option is better for u "bang for buck" wise..

I would say from what I have seen:

Intel Pentium 4 945 Dual Core "LGA775 Presler" 3.4GHz (800FSB) - Retail (CP-132-IN) £130 in this weeks special offers...

Thats what you **** buy, then it will be a simple cpu change...

if you went AMD it means having to change the mobo etc so more expensive for a worse chip then the one suggested above..

For starters that intel chip i suggested has a 2mb L2 cache where as the amd 4400 only has 1mb L2 cache..

So I guess its easy and I would say the intel chip above...however sit tight and see what others think...
 
no worries i would repeat to sit tight and see what others think....just so you can be 100% about ** decision :)
 
ha, guess i should have checked this out first -

just had a look on the Intel motherboard selector and it says with my current mobo (915g chipset) i cant use a pentium duo OR pentium D!!!

guess i'll be getting a new mobo then!!! :D woops...
 
and if u get a conroe u will also need new RAM...

well spotted batman :)

perhaps u **** hold tight for a little while until u get around £500 then u can go conroe, new mobo and new RAM...and yeh then definately new psu...lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom