Speed issues, please check my line stats, etc.

GSDog

GSDog

GSDog

Soldato
Joined
12 Jun 2004
Posts
5,477
Location
Exeter
Hi all,

I have been with BT MaxDSL for about 8 months now. It has been connected at roughly 7-8MB, but the actual download speeds rarely goes over 350kbps, and after doing speed tests I have never seen the connection speed go over 3.5MB.

Here are my line stat's:
linestatstc0.jpg


What do you think could be causing this? I know some speed will be lost from the exchange, but surely not over 50% of the connection speed?
 
seems very strange as those stats look great. Are you running wireless? Where are you downloading from?

(edit: oops. apart from snr)
 
Last edited:
your downstream margin is very low, have been getting a stable connection or has it been dropping and reconnecting lots ?.

have you run a bt speed test to check what it says your IP Profile is ? www.speedtester.bt.com
 
This computer is on wireless, but the other PC is wired. I used these speed tests:
http://www.speedtest.net/
http://www.thinkbroadband.com/speedtest.html

The connection has been stable, I think it has only dropped once, which was actually last week, but it reconnected after about an hour.


The BT speed test link does not seem to be working for me...?

I have been on this for about 8 months and it has never gone over 350-400kbps when downloading - even when it is connected at the full 8MB.

I just ran another speed test and it never went over 2MB!
 
Last edited:
You SNR (Downstream margin) seems low it should be 6db or higher, this could mean the router is dropping the line every now and then, are you sure its only done it once? Might be an idea to look in the Log

If not fair enough, the download limit could either be at the exchange end or on the ISP's system so might be an idea to call your ISP

Also one other thing to note, do you online game much? Just asking at interleaving is on which isnt bad as it stabilises your line however adds to you latency (20-40ms) and so games can seem jumpy more

the bt speedtest hasnt work properly for me for the last 3 months!
 
ste_bla said:
You SNR (Downstream margin) seems low it should be 6db or higher, this could mean the router is dropping the line every now and then, are you sure its only done it once? Might be an idea to look in the Log

If not fair enough, the download limit could either be at the exchange end or on the ISP's system so might be an idea to call your ISP

Also one other thing to note, do you online game much? Just asking at interleaving is on which isnt bad as it stabilises your line however adds to you latency (20-40ms) and so games can seem jumpy more

the bt speedtest hasnt work properly for me for the last 3 months!
Click to expand...

Thanks for the reply.

It's strange because the SNR is usually around 6-8, not sure why it was 2 last night, but right now it is back up to 7db...

I did try calling my ISP once about this, but they are absolutely hopeless - they said everyone with 8MB MaxDSL will not actually get 8MB - I said I knew that, but I was connected at 8MB, so should get at least 5-6MB+, surely?

I do quite a bit of online gaming and I know Interleaving does effect my pings (they are around 40ms) but I don't notice any lag. I will ask them to turn it off tho.

My router is not plugged into the master socket because we still have one computer on a wired network upstair's - do you think it would make a different moving the router to the master socket?
I think the master socket is very old and I remember thinking about using a different faceplate.

I guess I might as well try phoning BT later on. :(

P.S) Even though the SNR is back up to 8 now, the download speeds are still not going over 3.5MB.
 
BT wont do nowt unless thats your ISP

Have you tried the BT speed tester again? I ask as this will tell you your IP/BRAS Profile (ie 3500kb) and so will tell you if the exchange is limiting your speed, other that that phone your ISP ask for your IP/BRAS Profile as it could have got stuck!

Moving your router might mean you get slightly better figures but it wouldn't affect the lack of bandwidth
 
ste_bla said:
BT wont do nowt unless thats your ISP

Have you tried the BT speed tester again? I ask as this will tell you your IP/BRAS Profile (ie 3500kb) and so will tell you if the exchange is limiting your speed, other that that phone your ISP ask for your IP/BRAS Profile as it could have got stuck!

Moving your router might mean you get slightly better figures but it wouldn't affect the lack of bandwidth
Click to expand...

I have tried that BT speed tester link on all 3 computers, it isn't working and just times out.

My ISP is BT, so they should be able to tell me.

I have just used this speed test: http://www.btopenworld.com/speedtest and downloaded the large file. On my computer it downloaded between 400-430kbps, which is MUCH better than last night, when it was barely hitting 200kbps.
However, I just tried this on the other two computers, the family PC (which is wired) is always between 600-700kbps!!! and my brothers PC (which is wireless) was hitting 750kbps!!!!

So it looks like it could actually be my PC :confused:
It's weird because I think I remember this happening last time on my old desktop PC (im now using a laptop), my download speeds in my room never seem to be as fast as the other computers.
What could be the cause of this???
I have tried IE and Firefox, they are both around 400kbps on this PC.
 
HomerJ said:
As the other machines are getting good speeds then it is defiantely going to be a setting on your machine.

What OS is it running ?

You might need to tweak the Rwin value if you run the TCP Analyzer on the following site and post the results will help

http://www.speedguide.net/sg_tools.php
Click to expand...

It's running Windows XP Media Center Edition.

Here are the results from the TCP Analyzer:
« SpeedGuide.net TCP Analyzer Results »
Tested on: 02.20.2007 06:25
IP address: 86.138.xxx.xxx

TCP options string: 020405ac0103030001010402
MSS: 1452
MTU: 1492
TCP Window: 17424 (multiple of MSS)
RWIN Scaling: 0
Unscaled RWIN : 17424
Reccomended RWINs: 63888, 127776, 255552, 511104
BDP limit (200ms): 697kbps (87KBytes/s)
BDP limit (500ms): 279kbps (35KBytes/s)
MTU Discovery: ON
TTL: 108
Timestamps: OFF
SACKs: ON
IP ToS: 00000000 (0)

It does say at the top:
MTU = 1492
MTU is optimized for PPoE DSL broadband. If not, consider raising MTU to 1500 for optimal throughput.
MSS = 1452
MSS is optimized for PPPoE DSL broadband. If not, consider raising your MTU value.

I am using PPPoA, so could this be the problem?
 
Hi

The Rwin value is pretty low and would be a major culprit of the slow speeds.

If you do a Google for DrTCp this is a great little free program to easily change the Rwin value on your machine. If you have multiple netword adapters on your mchine eg wireless and wired make sure you select the correct one in Dr TCP and once you have changed the settings in DRTCP you need to reboot the PC

Or you can use the TCP Ptimer that is on the Speedguide site they have a full help page etc on the tool.

I would suggest changing the Rwin to 255552
 
Thanks.

I have now changed the Rwin to 255552.

I just checked my line stats and my SNR is back down to 2db. I have just downloaded the BT Openworld speed test file again, and all 3 computers are barely getting over 250kbps.

It seems my SNR drops every night - I can almost guarantee that tomorrow morning the SNR will be back up to 7-8 and my speeds will be back to normal.

I guess I will need to wait and see if the Rwin has made a difference tomorrow! :( :mad:
 
We don't have street lights were I live, but I will check tonight when the heating or any lights come on.

Well, just as I guess the SNR is back up to 8db this morning/early afternoon. I will keep an eye on it and see what time it starts to drop.

The good news it, I just tested the BT Openworld speed test again and it dowloaded at 680kbps!!! That is the fastest I have seen it download on this computer, so fingers crossed it looks like it was the Rwin causing the slow speeds on this computer.

Thank you very much HomerJ for sorting that out.
And thank you ste_bla for your help too, hopefully I will find out why the SNR drops so much at night. :eek:
 
being on interleaved will slow your connection right down! and give **** pings

ask your isp to switch you to fast path!

with your line att you should be getting full whack

but the line is a little noisy,try getting your isp to drop/cap your line by 512k increments and then you should hit your sweet spot and your speed will shoot right up

when your browsing sites does your browser seem to hang for about 10-20sec at a time but your modem still shows being connected!
 
Interleaving has no effect on the SNR levels on the line which is the problem he is now having.

Having the line Interleaved does add a 20 - 40ms increase so can have an impact for online gaming but if you are not a gamer you will never notice it.

With BT Max the ISP's have virually no control over what profile you line is set to this is determined by a BTW system called Rambo. The ISP last time I checked can only get BT to place a cap on the line for a 2Mb or lower capped profile.
 
So what is the purpose of interleaving?
I do online game quite a bit at the moment and have noticed my pings have increased, so I will probably phone BT later and ask them to switch it off.
I have noticed today my connection is now syncing at 7232 Kbps instead of 7902 Kbps.
I'm not too bothered because the SNR has now increased to a healthy 10db. Hopefully tonight it wont drop as low as recently.
 
I thought SNR dropped the more congested the lines became in the evening as everyone was using the net in the area? Or am I getting confused...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom