• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

The Ferminator

How can you say ATI's core is more complex though, given that you are unwilling to look at the technical detail of what makes it "complex". If an individual feature (an SP) is less complex than the same feature of a competitors product, how can you say that having more of a less complex feature makes for a more complex die?

Seriously, get a clue.

I'm no ATi nor Nvidia fanboy, for the record, I have both team's hardware in my rig.
 
Because ATI built a core half the size of Nvidia with many times the SP count, jumped to DX11 and shrunk to 40nm

Eh?

ATi built a core half the size of Nvidia's, with an SP length that is considerably shorter.

What you are doing is saying that Ati have baked a cake, and managed to cut it into 8 slices, whereas nvidia have a larger cake and only cut it into 4. This doesn't mean ATi is better because they have twice the number of slices, neither does it mean that the ATi will fill you up more (perform better) because you have more slices to eat. Nvidia's cake is still larger, and still more complex.
 
Last edited:
Charlie tends to take every bad piece of nVidia news and beat, tweak and exaggerate it til it looks 10x as bad... so from that you can pretty much assume they are having some issues but nothing like as bad as hes making out.
 
do people at nvidia have people who leek stuff out, like specs and images etc etc
at what point will some sort of detail on the new cards be revealed ? the day there released or will nvidia provide a spec before ?
 
Nvidia ARE late, regardless of when Nvidia say they intend launching because ATI have a comparable product out now and will have done for over 6months by the time Fermi is released. Even then if the rumours are true that ATI have the 6xxx series ready for an Autumn launch, Nvidia won't recover the performance crown at all this round and will be even further behind by the end of the year.

Fermi is looking increasingly like a lame duck that is best just ignored till ATI and Nvidia have the next gen out and hopefully for Nvidia Fermi's replacement has been developed in separation.
 
Theres always people who talk - even if its non-commital with enough technical info you can read between the lines. Then theres the people working for the other companies involved.
 
Fermi is looking increasingly like a lame duck that is best just ignored till ATI and Nvidia have the next gen out and hopefully for Nvidia Fermi's replacement has been developed in separation.

My inclination is to hold onto my 260 SLI setup until the 32 or 28nm version of the Fermi arch. is released - unless its a massive step forward performance wise.
 
Eh?

ATi built a core half the size of Nvidia's, with an SP length that is considerably shorter.

What you are doing is saying that Ati have baked a cake, and managed to cut it into 8 slices, whereas nvidia have a larger cake and only cut it into 4. This doesn't mean ATi is better because they have twice the number of slices, neither does it mean that the ATi will fill you up more (perform better) because you have more slices to eat. Nvidia's cake is still larger, and still more complex.

ATI have %50 redundancy in 40nm, they could have built a considerably loner pipe line without the need to reduce the SP count.

I'm not saying one option is better than another, I'm saying what ATI done with 5000 cards was to build more than a beefed up 4870 as suggested.
 
Last edited:
I gotta a funny feeling about this "awesome fermi" I feel another FX coming on :( oh dear -.-

I really hope not

but come on they said it should be getting ready to come out now and Nv should be shouting but were are they?
 
I love how people are jumping on the whole, its going to be hot, noisey, another FX/2900XT, its late, nVidia are having massive problems, yada yada... based on flawed interpretation of the data certain parties are banding about.

Not to say it won't be - but the information is ambiguous at best, nothing solid has come from nVidia and they aren't (yet) behind schedule developement wise even if its kinda late with the shifts in the market.
 
The problem is that there hasn't been any good news, so even though the potential for all the bad news being exaggerated is high, there isn't anything to counterbalance this.

The question therefore is, WHY has there been nothing positive?
 
I love how people are jumping on the whole, its going to be hot, noisey, another FX/2900XT, its late, nVidia are having massive problems, yada yada... based on flawed interpretation of the data certain parties are banding about.

Not to say it won't be - but the information is ambiguous at best, nothing solid has come from nVidia and they aren't (yet) behind schedule developement wise even if its kinda late with the shifts in the market.

When it comes to nVidia, no news is generally bad news.

When they've got something good, they want everyone to know how and why it's just so good.

Currently, they've just said "Fermi's great".
 
Couldn't care less now when fermi comes out to be honest i wanted a choice when i was upgrading and there wasn't one i wanted a dx11 card as games would be out for it soon and nvidia completely missed the party. Sorry Rroff i know you keep saying they are not late but come on be honest you truly believe they meant to be six months behind and still not have a card out no one runs a business like that.

By the time fermi is released ati refresh will be ready to go with the 6xxx series rumoured for autumn release, in no way can nvidia have planned to be that far behind their main competitor. They have screwed something up what exactly who knows but they have and constantly saying otherwise is getting less and less convincing as time goes by and the normally highly vocal nvidia are quieter then a nunnery at prayer time.
 
Sorry Rroff i know you keep saying they are not late but come on be honest you truly believe they meant to be six months behind and still not have a card out no one runs a business like that.

gt212 was planned to go up against RV8xx.

By the time fermi is released ati refresh will be ready to go with the 6xxx series rumoured for autumn release, in no way can nvidia have planned to be that far behind their main competitor. They have screwed something up what exactly who knows but they have and constantly saying otherwise is getting less and less convincing as time goes by and the normally highly vocal nvidia are quieter then a nunnery at prayer time.

The GT100 design is actually tech/generation wise level with the ATI 6xxx series - it will come into its own on 28nm.


ATI Stole a march on nVidia by bolting DX11 onto a glorified 4870 - I'm not slighting it it works very well - but at the end of the day thats what it is.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom