The Great Decline

Permabanned
Joined
13 Mar 2020
Posts
627
Has anyone wondered just how much the UK as a global power declined in last the 100 years? Are we the new roman empire?

We went from being the world super power to literally at best, in future a slightly worse version of Australia or Canada due to lack of resources and larger population. Destined to be arm wrestled by EU just as Canada is with USA and Australia is with China.

How did we do this to ourselves? Why do brexiteers believe that all of sudden we are on verge of greatness? Would it not be more ‘great’ to gain control of EU from within to suit our agenda? After all, we were the leading member together with France and Germany. Why did we not invest more into taking more leadership and control in matters. We have/had closer ties to USA which we could have used to enforce our position in EU above france and germany if we really put our minds to it. I mean we literally could have been the key deciding member of whole Europe.

I mean even looking at russia, who in past 100 years had revolution, world wars, cold war loss and oligarchy - they still did not fall as much as we did. For right or wrong they are still clawing back to their ‘greatness’ futile or not. Against whole west world and economic system. Trying to warp it to their benefit as outsiders.


France, Germany, USA, Russia even Turkey are all trying to gain ‘power’ on world arena. The big players are making moves after decades of status quo.


We had so many opportunities to project our power and we really just gave it all up. After loss of the empire we still had all the tools to take control of EU and be forefront runner. Germany and France have been relatively weak and we could have utilized strings with US to apply pressure to get our agenda at forefront of the union above their heads.

We already got away with things no one in EU even dreamed of. We were always the ‘privileged ones’ without even trying.

I know this post goes against the whole ‘we love peace and happiness’ but reality is that look at France and even Germany. They are both gearing up for more and more power accumulation. US, China, Russia, Turkey, France, Germany. All these countries are on roads to expand influence. What are we doing? What is our plan? Survive brexit without starving? From a country that pretty much created modern financial system and law as we know it? Not long ago we pretty much were key in running world finances. Not because we are pretty but because its our system, we made it. How on earth do you just give it away. Its literally one of biggest power projections there is.

Its just such a crazy, accelerated internal implosion of power under guise of ‘greatness’ it almost seems like sabotage. Maybe KGB did do its job and just maybe the US will follow the UK footsteps in future.

And finally, again it sounds awful but the idea that France or other EU members can even consider arm twisting us into anything just irks me based on our history and what we could have been post our victory in ww2 and cold war. Its like modern Americans being excited about trade deal with Japan and worried about Canada or Mexico not giving them a good trade deal. It doesnt even cross their mind. The idea that Canada is going to threaten US with trade deal is laughable. This should have been UK with any European country. All I see is ****** away potential to be a global powerhouse when we had all the tools. We live in world that was carved as result of WW2 and Cold war. We won in both and yet it feels like we lost. both.
 
Last edited:
Time before this descends into a Brexit thread...

People have taken their eyes off the ball pure and simple, have forgotten to guard the heart and take what we have for granted and just assume it will continue of its own accord without them having to tend to the source of it.

Too many people that aren't looking at the bigger picture - amongst other things we are witnessing the destruction of some of the biggest assets this country has and many don't even realise it and will wonder in a few years why we are the poorer for it.

Additionally nothing good comes from the erosion of Britain on the world stage - while we don't have the clout we once had and haven't been a paragon by way of example we have none the less been influential globally when it comes to things like human rights and our decline will make way for the expanding influence of those with less regard for such things.
 
Last edited:
I was pro brexit to a degree but I do understand your points and do think they are valid. I don't know if its the right thing to do anymore, the fact we keep on banging on about fishing rights seems laughable, I don't think fishing is going to power our economy.

You talk about power projection but given the way some people think in this country that is a dirty word, we are too concerned about righting the wrongs of hundreds of years ago and peoples feelings.

During this whole covid thing we couldn't even just wear masks and get on with life.

Can anyone name any new and existing companies that we have? Look at Americs with all the tech companies and then look at what we have?
 
Would you rather be born an American or Chinese so you can be a 'world power'? Who really cares in the modern world about power?

Give me a life born in a 'weak' powerless country like New Zealand or Scandinavia any day of the week. Do you think they care about power. In the grand scheme of things it's a pretty peaceful world out there for most countries.

Not sure what this 'power' you want is going to do to improve your life in this day and age. Surely the focus should be on prosperity for a country and its citizens.
 
Would you rather be born an American or Chinese so you can be a 'world power'? Who really cares in the modern world about power?

Give me a life born in a 'weak' powerless country like New Zealand or Scandinavia any day of the week. Do you think they care about power. In the grand scheme of things it's a pretty peaceful world out there for most countries.

Not sure what this 'power' you want is going to do to improve your life in this day and age. Surely the focus should be on prosperity for a country and its citizens.

Then in 50 years when we are fighting over freshwater we can be happily invaded by China knowing that our fathers generation lived "so peacefully."

Unless the whole world plays by the same rules there will always be the strong and the weak.
 
I think the UK needs to retire from its current form of ‘patriotism’.

Things like: we had an empire, we won WW2, we have great music, we have iconic TV, we have a royal family. Wow aren’t we amazing, look at what we’ve done.

It’s just so ****ing passive and lazy!

To be great we need to focus on what we are doing now. As individuals.

Thing like: being courageous, contributing, seeking justice and liberty, wanting to make things better.

Those things above all require effort - a choice to seek out bona fide betterment and feel like it’s an honour to be a part of it.

It’s almost as if we need to look over and be inspired by some of the good parts of US patriotism.
 
Lolwut.

Russia on the road to disaster, what on earth have they got going for them? Oh yeah they are friendly with China Iran Syria and are good at invading neighbors and just been ********* non dictatorship countries.
progress check.

Turkey are regressing into an Islamic backwater and will be holding hands with China Russia etc soon...
progress check

China is expanding its sphere of influence by using backhanded colonial tactics, bullying, and building islands in oceans to claim the seas, oh and mass genocide.
Progress check.

We paid a big price for our part in winning ww2.
Germany came out as a powerhouse because America wanted to keep them on side against the Soviets and so got free money to rebuild.
We had to pay back enormous debts, do some reading on the post war prehaps, ditto Japan .

Maybe we should copy Russia ,China,turkey and start by invading and going full on empire building again?

Not sure how you get the idea of France and Germany being relatively weak and that we could have dominated them.

Also Brexit and we are going to be starving in the same sentence...okay....tin foil hat on time.
 
Is it not a case of who's got the most powerful gang(army). As it became less and less viable to hold onto colonies by force we had to give them up.

Other countries started developing similar ideas to ours and as their infrastructure grew then we were no longer able to dictate by threat of force.

A similar thing happened over the last 30 years or so with China and India, both demandeing to be more and more powerful industrially and militarily.

It's a simple equation, bargaining power. We have little in natural resources so we have to take a back seat unless we want to try and go to war which wouldn't go well.
 
Has anyone wondered just how much the UK as a global power declined in last the 100 years? Are we the new roman empire?

Yes, it was never going to last though. In WW2 it all started falling apart, for example the Japanese wanted their own empire so they decided to kick the British out of Singapore, Hong Kong, Burma, etc. This was the trigger for India to get it's independence.
 
I find it amusing the OP thinks France isn't in decline, most of the west is in fact. Then he mentions Russia :eek:

If most of the west is in decline why would we leave the top seat at the trading table? Because Farage made us fear illegal immigrants...
 
Would you rather be born an American or Chinese so you can be a 'world power'? Who really cares in the modern world about power?

Give me a life born in a 'weak' powerless country like New Zealand or Scandinavia any day of the week. Do you think they care about power. In the grand scheme of things it's a pretty peaceful world out there for most countries.

Not sure what this 'power' you want is going to do to improve your life in this day and age. Surely the focus should be on prosperity for a country and its citizens.

I agree. We did have influence and punched higher than we should have, especially militarily. However the world has changed, we can’t be the worlds policeman anymore because the agitators are rarely state actors and when they are they are just too big. We can’t compete with the natural resources of USA/China/Russia and as seen with Iraq/Afghanistan we can’t end terrorism by invading a country.

We need to realise what we can offer, and we should focus on Liberty, rule of law and decency. The fact we have cut our aid budget shows that our leaders don’t care for this and want to bring up the drawbridge and isolate ourselves from the world.

However instead of accepting our small country status where we could be a successful, decent and admirable country (like NZ) our hangover of power won’t allow us to do so and we are now just a minnow that has little to offer the world and we either accept that or society needs to decide who we want to be. Recent choices seems to favour the isolation model though.
 
Lolwut.

Russia on the road to disaster, what on earth have they got going for them?.
Russia aren't in that bad a shape. Lots of natural resources, especially in respect to their population and one of the least vulnerable countries of climate change. Their issues in the short term are political and what comes after Putin. There's no obvious succession and the struggle for power could be very damaging.
 
Russia aren't in that bad a shape. Lots of natural resources, especially in respect to their population and one of the least vulnerable countries of climate change. Their issues in the short term are political and what comes after Putin. There's no obvious succession and the struggle for power could be very damaging.

They have lists of resources but that's no good with a mad man in charge.
Will be interesting to see which way they go when he finally dies.
 
Back
Top Bottom