I still have the first one unplayed because of performance issues. Having updated my PC since trying it I should go back to it, but given that I probably won't get around to both games, which of the two would you choose to play through if you were only picking one?
I know this question wasn't aimed at me and I've only just started playing Evil Within 2 - about an hour in - but already it feels much better. The graphics are vastly improved.
Carrion - 7/10
Graphics were really quite good for the style, gameplay was fun but a wee bit frustrating as the controls aren't perfect. Could really do with a map though, I got lost at the end and therefore felt like I didn't want to go around finding the missing secrets.