Associate
I used to work in English and Welsh law.Depends how badly you failed surely. What if you tried to poison someone but instead accidentally ended up making them a really nice cup of tea?
There are two factors considered if someone was guilty of a crime: And in true Latin form, they're Mens Rea and Actus Reus. Roughly translated, respectively, means 'Guilty Mind' and 'Guilty Act'. Only one element needs to be proven.
Using your analogy, someone attempting to poison someone but ended up making them a nice cup of rosie lea, would still be guilty of an offence.
Akin to some wannabe dealer buying some inert white powder from another dealer with the intention of selling it on, believing it to be a controlled substance, even if said powder was flour or sherbert, would still be guilty of PWITS.
Likewise, if you tried to sell any white powder, proporting it to be a controlled substance, even if you know it's inert, you're still guilty of PWITS.
Sorry to bust the fun from this thread
Last edited: