• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Very budget setup, any good?

Associate
Joined
17 Feb 2013
Posts
317
Hey guys, had a look through some setups and they're amazing! I'd love to be able to afford something like that, but I have other things to spend my money on so can't go too crazy with audio.

Basically I'd like to know if there's anything I should upgrade, if I need to.
I've got quite old components but for the prices I payed I couldn't refuse.

I know the cable can be upgraded, it's typical basic cable, and I got the speakers for free so that was a huge bonus.
I'd be happy to chuck £100 into a new amp/equalizer, I know some/most people spend that on cable alone but as I've said, I cannot.

Thanks for any help.

Here's my amp and equalizer...







And my speakers...







 
What to do very much depends on where your priorities lie. The answer could range from "nothing at all" through to "get rid of the graphic EQ, add a CD player, bung up the bass port in the speakers". But without you telling us where you think you have issues, and how you use the system, and what your ultimate aims are then any suggestions would be as pointless as suggesting a £300 graphics card for a PC that's just used for browsing the net and doing the family finances. :D
 
What to do very much depends on where your priorities lie. The answer could range from "nothing at all" through to "get rid of the graphic EQ, add a CD player, bung up the bass port in the speakers". But without you telling us where you think you have issues, and how you use the system, and what your ultimate aims are then any suggestions would be as pointless as suggesting a £300 graphics card for a PC that's just used for browsing the net and doing the family finances. :D

Well my priorities would be to get as much out of what I have ideally. I have it connected to my pc as all my music is on there. What differences would I see from plugging the bass ports?
 
Plunging the bass ports should tighten the bass up but it won't be as pronounced, get some foam and experiment.

I've never been a fan of equalisers, try taking it out for a while and see how it sounds.
 
Plunging the bass ports should tighten the bass up but it won't be as pronounced, get some foam and experiment.

I've never been a fan of equalisers, try taking it out for a while and see how it sounds.

Luckily I can just turn the equaliser off, and It does sound better wit certain types of music so thanks for pointing that out! I'll try plugging the holes up later too.
 
Well my priorities would be to get as much out of what I have ideally. I have it connected to my pc as all my music is on there. What differences would I see from plugging the bass ports?

The speakers you have are a design called Bass Reflex. It refers to that hole in the front. That's the bass reflex port. The idea is to get more bass energy and increased efficiency from a given cabinet size and driver diameter. It's a bit like turbo-charging a car. However, we never get something for nothing and this is no exception. There are two main issues with ported speakers. The first is a similar problem to car turbos. It's lag. Except in a speaker it's not a delay before the reaction but an overhang after the bass notes should have stopped playing.

The second issue is that bass reflex speakers are fussier about their room position than speakers where the cabinet and drivers form a sealed box. Bass reflex speakers need a bit more room between them and the back and side walls to avoid sounding boomy at anything more than very modest listening levels. It even says on the back of your speakers, "Allow at least 30 cm between the speaker and back wall" So if your speaker are tight up against the back wall or, even worse, jammed in the corners of a room then they'll sound bass heavy and that bass won't stop and start as cleanly as it would with some space around the speaker.

Putting something in to block the bass port solves (or at least improves) the positioning issue but at the cost of bass energy. Although there'll be less bass, what you should find is that the bass notes stop and start with greater precision. Listen to a track with bass guitar. You should be able to hear the notes and follow the bass line more easily.


The graphic EQ look impressive but the processing required for all those tone controls messes up the signal. Ditch the graphic. While you're at it, turn the amp's bass and treble controls to the centre positions if they aren't already at that setting.

So far - so cheap - so good :D Now, if you want to improve the sound for your £100 disposable budget then turn your attention to the PC. If it's a laptop and you're still using the headphone jack, or if it's a desktop PC and it has a digital audio output then look in to getting an outboard DAC (Digital to Analogue Converter) This will clean up the source signal going to the amp.
 
The speakers you have are a design called Bass Reflex. It refers to that hole in the front. That's the bass reflex port. The idea is to get more bass energy and increased efficiency from a given cabinet size and driver diameter. It's a bit like turbo-charging a car. However, we never get something for nothing and this is no exception. There are two main issues with ported speakers. The first is a similar problem to car turbos. It's lag. Except in a speaker it's not a delay before the reaction but an overhang after the bass notes should have stopped playing.

The second issue is that bass reflex speakers are fussier about their room position than speakers where the cabinet and drivers form a sealed box. Bass reflex speakers need a bit more room between them and the back and side walls to avoid sounding boomy at anything more than very modest listening levels. It even says on the back of your speakers, "Allow at least 30 cm between the speaker and back wall" So if your speaker are tight up against the back wall or, even worse, jammed in the corners of a room then they'll sound bass heavy and that bass won't stop and start as cleanly as it would with some space around the speaker.

Putting something in to block the bass port solves (or at least improves) the positioning issue but at the cost of bass energy. Although there'll be less bass, what you should find is that the bass notes stop and start with greater precision. Listen to a track with bass guitar. You should be able to hear the notes and follow the bass line more easily.


The graphic EQ look impressive but the processing required for all those tone controls messes up the signal. Ditch the graphic. While you're at it, turn the amp's bass and treble controls to the centre positions if they aren't already at that setting.

So far - so cheap - so good :D Now, if you want to improve the sound for your £100 disposable budget then turn your attention to the PC. If it's a laptop and you're still using the headphone jack, or if it's a desktop PC and it has a digital audio output then look in to getting an outboard DAC (Digital to Analogue Converter) This will clean up the source signal going to the amp.

Very helpful info there! I am VERY limited with room and have chucked some thick socks in the ports to see the difference and couldn't quite figure out how to word the effect and you've got it spot on. Regarding the EQ, it's been off for the past hour or so and the difference is phenomenal! What use do people have for them if it sounds better without? Or is it just that mine's an older, less capable one?
I've got a desktop, and I'll have a look into DAC's now, any brands/models you could recommend?
 
Very helpful info there! I am VERY limited with room and have chucked some thick socks in the ports to see the difference and couldn't quite figure out how to word the effect and you've got it spot on. Regarding the EQ, it's been off for the past hour or so and the difference is phenomenal! What use do people have for them if it sounds better without? Or is it just that mine's an older, less capable one?
I've got a desktop, and I'll have a look into DAC's now, any brands/models you could recommend?
Glad to hear that you're getting good results.

You want to try with the graphic EQ completely unwired from the amp. Even when set to off the signal still travels through unnecessary circuitry. To do that you'll either need the little metal U-shaped links or just a pair of phono cables to restore the connection on the back of the amp after the cables to the EQ are removed. You can use one of the pair of cables connecting the EQ to the amp to do this.

Graphics were a bit of a fad. A little like a go-faster stripe for mass market Hi-Fi. The funny thing is, people wanted them but really didn't understand how to use them. TBH, they're quite a crude tool in any case so the benefits were quite limited. We still have software EQ in iPod and MP3 players. Even some AV amps too. However, trying to fix one broken thing by breaking something else is never really a good plan. Serious Hi-Fi gear never needed a graphic, or even tone controls.

Quality-wise your Technics amp was a big step up from the usual stack systems of the 80's and 90's. There are better products around, especially in the second-hand market. But I would hold off spending any money on an amp until we are sure you are getting the best signal out of the PC. :)

edit: we still aren't clear whether your current motherboard/soundcard includes a digital output. Perhaps you could check that.

DAC-wise, something worth owning and holding on to starts at about £200 new (Cambridge Audio DACmagic and similar). Secondhand prices are holding firm, north of £100 for these and things like the Beresford Caiman (TC-7520SE). However, the older Beresford TC-7510 is a nice little product with two optical digital and two coax digital inputs. There's one on Ebay right now sitting at £10 with 23 hrs to go. There's 13 bids on it, so I expect it will shoot up in price towards the auction end. These were £130 new, and s/h can fetch up to £80 if there's a feeding frenzy.

A cheaper alternative is the USB DAC. As the name suggests, the DAC connects to the PC with a USB cable rather than optical or coax. The reason these type of DACs start at a lower price is because basic USB isn't the best type of digital connection for quality audio. There's lots of timing errors (jitter) that affects the quality. There is a high quality USB connection called Asynchronous USB that gets round these issues. But you'll be looking for a high-end motherboard and an equally high-end Asynchronous DAC (£500+) to take full advantage of the feature.

Back to the DACs that take an optical or coax digital in. If your motherboard supports it then look for this type of product. Keep your eyes peeled in the members market here is if you have access. Also the classifieds at AV Forums too.
 
Last edited:
Unhooked the EQ as soon as I posted last, just in case.

My MB is an Asrock Z75 pro3. I had a look but couldn't get a clear answer as to digital output.
Not too much bother for the EQ then, picked it up for a tenner as the spoons in cash converters or whatever they're called had a tag for a tape deck on it.
Glad to hear about the amp, I've had music on all night and it does sound.....richer? Loving the tighter bass too, really brings certain songs to life.

Completely forgot to look at DAC's but I'll wait to find out about the MB before going on a mad hunt as I can spend hours if not days looking into a product before committing.

EDIT: Would it be a good idea to get a sound card with a built in DAC or is an external going to be the better option?

Also, I keep coming across cheap (£20-£40) DAC's on the rainforest etc... They're obviously built cheaper but what's the overall experience going to be like? I'm not trying to skimp, just like learning.

AND! One more thing... My MB has no optical or co axial output, and have noticed the majority of DAC's only have optical or co axial inputs. How would I get around this without going over budget to get the input needed?
 
Last edited:
Opinions are split about what's best: internal high-end audio card or external DAC.

FWIW, my own view is that PCs are electrically noisy environments (lot's of high frequency signal processing and switch-mode power supplies), so if you have the option to keep the signal in its digital form, and then do the conversion back to analogue using an external box well away from all that PC noise, then the final result will be better.

However, if there's no usable digital audio out either direct from the MB or from a daughter card then arguing about the differences is a bit academic. It has to be a decent internal audio card. Simple as that really. :D

You asked about the cheap DACs on rainforest. I'll answer that by getting you to think about signal processing in general.

Look at the cost of some of the high-end audio cards available http://www.overclockers.co.uk/productlist.php?groupid=701&catid=11 Why do you think it is that people spend good money on an expensive audio card when there's already a set of 5.1/7.1 audio jacks on most motherboards. Could it be that as well as some additional features that the card does a better job of processing the sound? Less noise, better dynamics, cleaner sound. See Top 10 review summary here Part of the reasons for the better performance is the silicon used and the quality- and attention to detail in the design to make sure the audio processing is as clean as possible. So, do you think you'd get the same attention to detail and dynamic range and low distortion from a £30 DAC compared to a £200+ DAC? :D

We all know from the horse meat scandal what happens when quality is cut and cut and cut to bring down prices. What seems like a bargain turns out to be something else entirely ;)
 
Well that was a nice simple read! Thanks for clearing that up for me, I couldn't help but think a sound card was going to be the only way.

Is the Asus Xonar Essence STX going to be my best bet? I don't have a problem going over budget if it means I get a high end card that will last me for years to come.

I've still got a smile every time I listen to music after getting rid of the EQ and plugging the bass ports!
 
IMO you'd be better off spending a little more on a seperate DAC from a hifi brand than a PC soundcard.

I'd look into the M-Audio 2496 if i wanted a stereo card - doesn't have the bells and whistles, but concentrates on the basics and may represent better value.
 
"Is the Asus Xonar Essence STX going to be my best bet?".... That's not easy to answer TBH.

If you were hooked up with a very high-end AV amp and did a lot of gaming and perhaps some music production then the answer might be yes. But for simple 2 channel playback in to a stereo amp it might be a sledgehammer to crack a walnut.

"I don't have a problem going over budget if it means I get a high end card that will last me for years to come."

Who knows what might happen in years to come. I think if you can't make use of all the features now, and that isn't likely to change in the next 18 months, then it's probably a sign that the card is OTT for your needs.

History shows us that there's always something new on the horizon. Also that as technology moves on so prices tend to fall. Depreciation can be savage in PC components. Buying something that does what you need now, and then upgrading later as your needs increase might actually work out better value than sinking loads of cash in to a very high-end card that you'll never fully exploit.

There is something that might change your thinking....

I was dismissive of USB DACs before, and for the record I still hold that view because of the swarms of cheap Chinese rubbish flooding the market. But there was one product that slipped my mind. The Behringer UCA202 is something of an exception. Behringer is a German pro-audio manufacturer. Most of Behringer's product are exceptional value. The UCA202 is just £23 + delivery. Here's quite an indepth review

True, the review does say that the tests were limited to the sort of audio sample rates you'd get from CD. Also, this is still a USB DAC so the jitter from the PC is still an issue as it would be for any USB DAC. However, if your main thing is listening to ripped music, and you read the review and see that he's done A/B measurements against the far more expensive Benchmark DAC, then the UCA202 still comes out very well.

I'd recommend this as a first step and then do some further research on either internal sound cards or options to use the S/PDIF header off your current motherboard. At £23 you can buy, run and sell the UCA202 and it will pay for itself compared to what you'd lose in depreciation with a monster audio card.
 
lucid has some sound info on the speakers, but so much BS as well.

There is not a thing wrong with EQ, whilst a software EQ with many more bands is technically better any will let you adjust things to suit the characteristics of your speakers, environment, and you. If your EQ was flat then I suggest you're just experiencing a placebo effect now, there might be a small volume difference when swapping over too. If it wasn't flat well your sound is now different and you're being told it's meant to be better.
Note the conflict between "EQ's are so bad, they alter the sound" & "This amp is great, sounds very warm." ;) Most equipment is effectively transparent, it tends to only be 'audiophile' kit that alters sound (if it does change it at all) and does so in the same way a graphic EQ would, only you don't have the control yourself.

A DAC is such a simple piece of kit. Open up any and you'll tend to find the same range of components that cost pennies or pounds in one that costs £50 or £1000. I'm not referring to the DAC solely (£2-10), the other parts and their implementation too. And I'm happy to accept that there's more value to something than components and performance data.
Jitter with USB? IIRC the worst measured piece of equipment which had many times the jitter than others was still ridiculously far from ever being audible. Complete and utter rubbish.

"True, the review does say that the tests were limited to the sort of audio sample rates you'd get from CD"
The sample rates that more than cover the range of human hearing?

Honestly I'd go on with a proper tear-apart but he ends with a recommendation for an inexpensive DAC which, if you have really dodgy onboard sound with interference problems, is a fine way to go. Sub £20 I believe, although you may find the same for £10 from a Chinese brand.
Behringer is the same, they just have the German name and history. They're a bit of an embarrassment to some audio folk since they entirely manufacture and assemble in China and copy others, you get the same performance and far lower prices, but the support is poor and assembly quality isn't as good (though honestly everyone compromises now). Yet still £££ more than an equivalent Asian brand.
 
Last edited:
Lucid - any thoughts on the CYP AUD3-192?

http://www.whathifi.com/review/cyp-au-d3-dac

£32 from the rainforest and £40 from Richersounds

Might offer what the OP is looking for?
I'd lump the CYP in with a lot of the other rebranded-from-China DACS. It's cheap enough but I'm just not convinced it's a step up in quality. The reviewer also seems confused about the product and how it would be used.

However, the main problem for l33th3tr33 is there's no dedicated coax or optical output on his PC. There is a header connection on the motherboard. What I don't know is if that can be used directly if wired to a coax socket or if the signal requires processing first.

The Behringer gets round the lack of a digital audio connection because it uses USB. It's also cheaper than the CYP and it has some very indepth reviews.
 
lucid has some sound info on the speakers
Thank you for the acknowledgement

but so much BS as well.
In your opinion. But hey, we are all entitled to an opinion :D

"There is not a thing wrong with EQ - Sure, in the right place it's fine. That place though is rarely in the replay side of a Hi-Fi system.

When was the last time you went to a concert? Have you listened to an orchestra or a choir? Did you have to EQ your ears or ask the conductor to turn up the bass or tweak the midrange. No? You listened to the sound of performance in the way it was as given. That's all that is being suggested here. Take the simplest approach. Get the equipment fundamentals right first. Listen to the sound and learn the sonic characteristics of the system. Understand its strengths and weaknesses.

The problem with applying EQ is that it's a 2D view of a 3D problem. Concentrating on just one aspect of the sound without understanding the effects it has in other areas is a mistake.

Applying EQs to fix one problem can mess up so many other things that the nett result is a sonic step backwards. Without a good mental image of what the system sounds like before, then how can a person gauge (albeit subjectively) the effects of plugging in extra boxes and tweaking? It's easy to make the system sound different. But different doesn't necessarily mean better.

l33th3tr33 came here with a £100 budget and a desire for better sound. Can you honestly argue that the tweaks suggested and a £23 DAC for the PC are bad advice?


A DAC is such a simple piece of kit - On the surface, maybe. But under the bonnet, No.

Open up any and you'll tend to find the same range of components that cost pennies or pounds in one that costs £50 or £1000. - By the same token then look at any car and apply the same logic. Our family car has an engine, wheels, suspension, body etc.... so why doesn't it go like a Ferrari? ;) Your reductionist view is an attention-grabbing banner headline. It's "Freddie Starr Ate My Hamster". Those who care to read a little more in to the story find out it's nothing like that headline suggests. I think we are a bit more sophisticated here and that we search for the some substance to a story rather than taking the headline as gospel.

...the worst measured piece of equipment which had many times the jitter than others was still ridiculously far from ever being audible. Complete and utter rubbish. - Well the guys who make Wolfson DACs would disagree: http://www.wolfsonmicro.com/documents/uploads/misc/en/Specifying_Jitter_Performance.pdf I'd put them pretty much at the top of the pile in terms of industry expertise in DAC design and manufacture.

I'm always open to re-examine my knowledge and I welcome opportunities to improve my understanding. If you can point us to some tests that support your positions then that might be helpful :)
 
Thanks for the arguments guys, it's always good to hear different opinions, and I think I'll let everyone fight to the death and hopefully bring it down to a few choices.

I will argue though that after getting the EQ out of the loop I'm hearing parts of music a lot better than before, mainly midrange, but my Eq was always set with slightly lower mids.
If it helps, I have the EQ setting in itunes on electronic, and found that to be the best overall sound.
Oh, and ALL my music is FLAC converted to apple lossless if that's useful at all.

Thanks for all the replys so far guys!
 
Turn the software EQ off too and see where that leaves you in terms of sound. Any DAC would help your situation. In my experience there's so much noise on motherboard analogue outputs that this is detrimental. Anything to distance the signal from the motherboard is a good idea. You'd be amazed how much improvement you can achieve with free or very cheap tweaks such as speaker positioning and mounting.
 
Back
Top Bottom