The rest of the wall is brick but it looks like concrete or cement here, though it's very soft. I thought it might have been the lintel for the old back door but I'd expect that to be much more solid.
When you say it's soft, do you mean on the surface or when drilling?
If it's the former, that's probably the bonding coat of plaster. If it's soft to drill into, you're probably into mortar... try moving the hole and re-drilling.
You'd certainly know about it if you'd hit a lintel!

