What portable HD?

Associate
Joined
17 Feb 2006
Posts
1,983
Location
London
Getting a laptop very soon and I'll be wanting a HD for extra space. Definitely want 500GB (which seems to be the biggest for portable?) just unsure which one as their is a fair amount of choices. I guess £80 or under (from whereever) would be nice but I'm willing to pay more as long as it means quality etc.

WD Passports look nice. Any other ideas? Thanks.
 
I just bought the neso 500Gb.

Looks to be pretty small and light. Not much more than the cheapest 500Gb portables. Overclockers have the best price on this drive at the moment (I just checked around).
 
WD will soon be releasing 1TB Passport drives if you want capacity. I have a Passport and a Buffalo Ministation; both fine and they don't get an easy life :p
 
WD will soon be releasing 1TB Passport drives if you want capacity. I have a Passport and a Buffalo Ministation; both fine and they don't get an easy life :p

Hmmm probably will be out of my price range I assume?

What are Lacie drives like? I know they look nice but are they any good?
 
The Passport's a 120GB from a couple of years ago, got it for £50ish at the time. The Buffalo I got a few months ago from somewhere, round about £80, 500GB.

On a side note.. I presume the reason drives come as FAT32 is for compatibility reasons, but what for? Linux? Every now and again if I'm giving someone a large file (ISO, for example) I come across a hard drive formatted as FAT32 because they didn't know to change it to NTFS, which is a pain.. no doubt I'm opening a can of worms here, but surely a universal file system can be devised that's just better than FAT32, even if it doesn't become the de facto standard across the board? Back in the day when even hard drives weren't 4GB I'm sure it was fine, but these days when files can surpass that, it's just dated.

Edit: Just noticed you weren't just talking about 2.5" 'portable' external drives :p I also had a couple of WD MyBooks from a couple of years ago. Worked fine, for the main part, but as often seems to happen with 3.5" externals (not sure if it happens more often than with 2.5") the circuit board or some such thing started acting up on them recently so I had to migrate them internally.
 
Last edited:
The Passport's a 120GB from a couple of years ago, got it for £50ish at the time. The Buffalo I got a few months ago from somewhere, round about £80, 500GB.

On a side note.. I presume the reason drives come as FAT32 is for compatibility reasons, but what for? Linux? Every now and again if I'm giving someone a large file (ISO, for example) I come across a hard drive formatted as FAT32 because they didn't know to change it to NTFS, which is a pain.. no doubt I'm opening a can of worms here, but surely a universal file system can be devised that's just better than FAT32, even if it doesn't become the de facto standard across the board? Back in the day when even hard drives weren't 4GB I'm sure it was fine, but these days when files can surpass that, it's just dated.

Edit: Just noticed you weren't just talking about 2.5" 'portable' external drives :p I also had a couple of WD MyBooks from a couple of years ago. Worked fine, for the main part, but as often seems to happen with 3.5" externals (not sure if it happens more often than with 2.5") the circuit board or some such thing started acting up on them recently so I had to migrate them internally.

Well I'm planning on getting a Mac so it's going to be a pain...

Will there ever be a FAT64? (I'm not really sure what the '16' and '32' mean though, google time!)
 
i personally like the WD passport drives because they are fairly well built and so far (fingers crossed 3 of my 300gb drives have not died yet).
 
On a side note.. I presume the reason drives come as FAT32 is for compatibility reasons, but what for? Linux? Every now and again if I'm giving someone a large file (ISO, for example) I come across a hard drive formatted as FAT32 because they didn't know to change it to NTFS, which is a pain..
I'd guess it's primarily for compatibility with Mac OSes...

Well I'm planning on getting a Mac so it's going to be a pain...
NTFS-3G for Mac OSX :)

I've no idea how well it works, although it seems pretty reliable on Linux these days.
 
Back
Top Bottom