You are partially right, but on the other hand, rubbish.
Confidence does work. Zefan (Rudolph..) saying all you need is confidence is true. Everyone loves confident people. With your football example, only the whingiest whiniest mope would take such a compliment in that way. Maybe you should learn to accept compliments and encouragement too?
Getting confidence is very hard. Personally I go for the 'I'm totally awesome, so if people don't like me its them, not me!' attitude, but it doesn't work for all.
Of course having confidence helps! I'm not saying that confidence isnt a good thing. I'm saying that to get to B you need to go through A.
Both Zefan and JodieG are saying that no you can have confidence by faking it or just pretend to be confident. And by doing that you magically become confident. In other words they can turn someone who is shy, repressed and awkward in social situation into someone who is a confident happy person just by imagining themselves confident? Now i didnt totally discount that. Its a good soundbite...cookie cutter advice if you will. But thats as far as it goes.
Saying all you need is confidence is true is just like these examples are true:
a) Anorexic/Serious weight problem "all you need to do is eat 4 meals a day dear"
b) Alcoholic " just dont drink ok!"
Now in both a and b of course the truth is eat properly and dont drink then because thats the simple solution isnt it. But would you really say that to someone who was Anorexic/Alcoholic?
No you wouldnt because its unbelievably crass and condescending.
Maybe you should learn to accept compliments and encouragement too?
?
I was a support worker working with people with various problems for a charitable organisation
(seeing as you're making this personal)
But you're right i was quite shy maybe about 10 years ago......i have no problems approaching people/women or most type of social situation at all....... but my opinion is at least based upon both my experiences and my direct experience of people with similar problems.