Which 120GB SSD?

Soldato
Joined
24 Feb 2004
Posts
3,308
Hi all

Been out of the SSD loop for a while, looking for 120GBSSD HD, but was wondering which is the best to go for, as my previous Vertex 2 drive has given me nothing but problems.

was considering one of the Intel 520 drives or the vertex 4 or anything reliable that anyone can recommend?

why is the write speed of veretx3 much higher then vertex4?

thanks
 
i would personally go for a corsair ssd as their customer after service is brilliant imo. when they had all the problems with the sandforce firmware they bent over backwards to help people. those problems are now well sorted out.
 
Early days but my Vertex 4 experience has been great so far and i think without the Sandfarce controllers it'll stay that way.
 
the only thing about the m4's for me is the slower write speeds. i'm sure they are great drives but surely if you can get faster write speeds then why not. and the sandforce is now 100% sorted so why keep on about it.yes it was a big problem to start with but they are as reliable as the m4's now
 
the only thing about the m4's for me is the slower write speeds. i'm sure they are great drives but surely if you can get faster write speeds then why not. and the sandforce is now 100% sorted so why keep on about it.yes it was a big problem to start with but they are as reliable as the m4's now

Sequential write speed means squat in reality, and most drives can't pull them out on varied data, only on highly compressible data.

The biggest performance bottleneck is 4kb reads, which all the drives you can get are really very close on anyway, which is why benchmark scores are so close and real life performance is so close on drives that claim on certain benchmarks to be a million miles apart.

IE you can have a m4 single drive, with 500mb read, 250mb writes, load windows in 9 seconds, and two m4's in raid, with 1000mb read's and 500mb's writes, and load windows in 8.8seconds, and never, ever notice it.

There is a reason tech sites that get free gear, or so many of them have dropped real world testing, because it shows little to no difference. A benchmark that scores arbitrarily high for minor differences in speed to inflat the difference doesn't make the drives that far apart.

99.9999% of people on this forum would notice a lick of difference between a single M4 and 2 Vertex 3's in raid(vertex 4's seem to suck in raid), and same goes for m4's in raid and a single vertex 3, 4, other marvell based ssd's.

If you've got any up to date SSD, the biggest speed difference you'll get from a new ssd is the fresh install of windows with a clean registry and less garbage running you never use anymore.

No reason not to get them, just don't expect miracles between a drive that claims to "only" have 300mb's reads and one that has 550mb's, they both have 25mb's(ish) random 4kb reads, queue depth testing is a con(for most people), you simply don't get 32, 64 or even 6-7 queue depth usage in normal home use.

I need a little more space for SSD so probably adding another 128gb, or maybe 2, and moving my current 128gb to a dedicated gaming drive or maybe to a laptop. Cheap/reliable is the goal for SSD's now, M4's are the best combination of that at the moment.
 
M4 dont bother with OCZ as there unreliable

Weird how people become so partisan. A lot of products have issues in production or design at varying points. Literally every major global business.

For the record my ocz vertex is fine, literally as good as the day I bought 2 years ago.

I guess a bad tech experience is much like falling to food poisoning.
 
Yea i wonder how many of them actually HAD an OCZ SSD, same with the Hiper people a few yrs back, everyone was defaulting 'Hiper' until they all started to blow up :D Not that the M4 is not a good drive and very dependable but the OCZ, Samsung, Intel etc.. offerings are looking good now.
 
This may muddy the waters slightly (but hopefully not), IMO you should go for a Marvell based SSD because they have generally the best real world performance, and also generally the best read speeds (which is more important than write as mentioned by drunkenmaster)

So your best choices are: crucial m4, corsair performance pro, and ocz vertex 4 (the indilinx controller is based on a marvell controller)

Now as the vertex 4 has no proven track record I would lean towards the other two. And then it comes down to price. The crucial m4 is a fantastic drive and proven track record and cheap. But the corsair is a bit faster, and has trim support in RAID as an in the mix feature (no other SSD I am aware of does this), and also has great general garbage collection.

So in summary crucial m4 < corsair performance pro in absolute terms, but then money. I hope that helps a bit
 
Back
Top Bottom