• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

Which brands to avoid, which are good?

Soldato
Joined
23 Jul 2009
Posts
14,155
Location
Bath
In the run-up to xmas, I've been researching gfx cards to replace my borrowed x1650 and have settled on a 5770. The question is which one? I've sort of taken it that Sapphire make good shizzle and I'm familiar with them (I had an old AGP HD2400 that they made), and I get the impression that XFX don't really have very good cooling solutions for their cards from reviews I've read (and I want my card to last for quite a while). How do the rest stack up? What is the pecking order as it were? Cheers!
 
They're all the same, best one to go for is which ever one has the best warranty for the best price or the lowest priced one, or whichever one comes with a bundle of stuff you want, ie free games.

Other than those, the cards themselves are all the same, the GPUs are all made in the same place, and the boards should be all identical bar the Sapphire Vapour-x, and I would say the Vapour-X cards are hardly worth the extra money they command.
 
So as far as temps are concerned, the only difference is vapour x, which isn't worth the extra dosh. And what are the pros and cons of exhaust vs egg coolers while I'm here?
(Considering getting the asus one on this week only or going with the sapphire and giving myself an early xmas prezzie)
 
Last edited:
I don't think 5770s produce enough heat for the egg cooler to create any sort of issue.
 
Asus offer their over volt software and the warranty includes moderate overclocks I believe.

Sapphire offer the Vapor-X, which to be fair was great with the 48XX as they were a lot quieter and a lot cooler than the stock, with the 5XXX I'm wondering if there really is any advantage?

Then theres the cooler, most 5XXX offer either the stock or egg coolers, so not much variation, in the past they have offered more variety...

So basically, included items, warranty, free games... Asus is personal choice due to the over volt utility :)
 
Asus offer their over volt software and the warranty includes moderate overclocks I believe.

Sapphire offer the Vapoor-X, which to be fair was great with the 48XX as they were a lot quieter and a lot cooler than the stock, with the 5XXX I'm wondering if there really is any advantage?

Then theres the cooler, most 5XXX offer either the stock or egg coolers, so not much variation, in the past they have offered more variety...

So basically, included items, warranty, free games... Asus is personal choice due to the over volt utility :)

The Asus overvolt utility isn't worth the extra. As long as the card has a volterra chip, then they can be volt modded via software regardless of if they're Asus or not.

MSI Afterburner for example can adjust the voltages of a card regardless of brand, just as long as it has the volterra chip, and all 5XXX cards have these chips.

Rivatuner is also capable of this too.
 
Sapphire offer the Vapor-X, which to be fair was great with the 48XX as they were a lot quieter and a lot cooler than the stock, with the 5XXX I'm wondering if there really is any advantage?

creates less heat, gives more head room to overclocking etc, i can see why they put it on but i'd agree, you won't see much of a difference.
 
MSI Afterburner for example can adjust the voltages of a card regardless of brand, just as long as it has the volterra chip, and all 5XXX cards have these chips.

Rivatuner is also capable of this too.

Ah, I wasn't aware of this, it's good to know :)

What about warranty though? Actually, would any other company know that you had even overclocked your card? This knowledge is suddenly making me consider other card brands :D
 
The Asus overvolt utility isn't worth the extra.

At the moment it's not extra, thanks to thisweekonly, so it's a dead even race between sapphire and asus. Considering that my case temps are fine anyway(so egg cooler should be quieter I hear), the card doesn't produce too much heat, and the warranty is a year longer, Asus does sound like the better deal for me.
 
I've got a gigabyte 5850 versh here installed and haven't a single prob with it so far (fingers crossed). two year warranty I believe, reasonable bundle, same as all the the others I imagine, I usually buy gigabyte where possible, they just appear to have a nice quality feel to their gear, though I suppose its no different to any of the others.:)
 
Back
Top Bottom