Which FTTC / PPPoE router to replace 3 devices?

GeX

GeX

Soldato
Joined
17 Dec 2002
Posts
6,982
Location
Manchester
Hi all.

Have had BT Infinity for ~18months, it's the 38MB service but I'm looking to upgrade that to 76MB (either with BT or Plusnet, not sure yet). Anyways..

I currently have the VDSL modem, which goes into the HomeHub3 and that is linked via it's GbE port to a 5 port gigabit switch. From the switch, it's linked to a HP Microserver which acts as the central NAS. (The HTPC is cabled to the switch as well, but that isn't in the cupboard with the rest of it!).

Using the WiFi there are a couple of Android phones (2.4ghz), a laptop (2.4ghz), a desktop (2.4ghz) and a MacBook (2.4ghz/5.0ghz).

All of the above gear is the cupboard under the stairs, right at the back out of the way - and right near the back of the house.

My main machine is the MacBook, and when being used at my desk it upstairs and toward the front of the house. This result in a less than ideal WiFi connection. I have been alerted to backup verification errors from TimeMachine, and am not sure where the blame for this lies - but I'm sure the poor WiFi signal is not helping.

There are many 2.4ghz networks in range, all the channels are rather congested.

Powerline adaptors are no use in my house, I've had them before and they worked fantastically until we had a new boiler fitted - and since then, the throughput became worse than a WiFi connection.

My goal is to improve WiFi coverage in the house, but ultimately to improve the connection that the MacBook uses; for that, I want to use 5ghz.

I've done some research and was almost ready to order a Draytek 2850n until I spotted it doesn't do simultaneous 2.4ghz/5.0ghz.

What hardware do you suggest that'd suit my uses? If needs be, I'm happy to leave the VDSL modem in place and just replace the HomeHub3 / GbE switch if that's going to be a limiting factor. Key here is decent WiFi coverage.
 
The Apple Airport Extreme will do what you want. It's quite shiny so there's no need for it to go under the stairs. ;)

Apart from that, the Asus RT-N66U / N56U are also great routers for the job.
 
The Asus RT-N66U looks promising. I'm put off by routers that look 'fancy' they just need to be functional, if they've spent time sticking flashing lights and things to them then I wonder what's been cut/skrimped on keep the cost down. Whichever router I get, will go in the cupboard under the stairs - it needs to sit with the server, and I've no desire to listen to the sever droning on in any other room in the house!

Have you used the Asus RT-N66U? I must confess, I've never even considered Asus as a supplier of networking gear.
 
Have you used the Asus RT-N66U? I must confess, I've never even considered Asus as a supplier of networking gear.
I haven't played with the 66U, but I have used the 56U a lot and have lots of nice things to say about it. They are both extremely high throughput routers (at least 700mbit/s) which is great if you're dealing with 2x2 or 3x3 wireless.
 
I wouldn't bother with the Airport extreme, for the price it's lacking some pretty fundemental features for a 'high end' consumer router. Go for the ASUS RT-N56U and put the custom firmware on it. Either that or spend more and get the ASUS RT-N66U which has better wireless over the 56, but that's not to say the 56 is bad.
 
I wouldn't bother with the Airport extreme, for the price it's lacking some pretty fundemental features for a 'high end' consumer router. Go for the ASUS RT-N56U and put the custom firmware on it. Either that or spend more and get the ASUS RT-N66U which has better wireless over the 56, but that's not to say the 56 is bad.

Yeah, as I've said - I don't want the Airport Extreme, I don't care what something that's in the back of the cupboard under the stairs beyond a chest of drawers actually looks like!!

On the N66U from what I've seen, it's default tx power is 40mW but this can be raised to 500mW on 2.4ghz and 250mW on 5.xghz.

This is good news, but need to find some confirmation on the European spec ones as I think our limits are lower here?
 
To be honest, the RT-N56U should do the job fine on the 5GHz band. Do a scan on the Mac to see what's about but I doubt you'll see many networks. Buy it, if it's not perfect, DSR it and get the RT-N66U.
 
The RT-N56U only supports up 300Mbps not 450Mbps like the RT-N66U. This is something swaying me toward the N66U. That and the ability to point the aerials at jaunty angles.
 
Yeah, I'm buying this to last - so don't mind spending a bit more. It's still cheaper than the 2850n!

Something that has just occurred to me; I *might* be able to get a cable into the room where my desk is. I think I can run it up near the central heating pipes. That's going to reduce the need for an amazing WiFi connection.. but I might go for it anyway for those days when connecting a wire is too much like a chore!!
 
If it can perform well on the wireless front, yes. But I don't want to compromise WiFi for the sake of built in VDSL.
 
Back
Top Bottom