Which Mitre Saw?

Associate
Joined
31 May 2005
Posts
2,230
Location
Alfreton,Derbyshire
I'm a keen DIY'er and have done lots of work on my current house in the way of rennovation in the last couple of years. I've got a load of garden work to do this year i.e. wooden steps, retaining raised beds and a modest extension for which I'll be doing as much as possible for. I've got a decent circular saw and recip saw which are fine for some jobs but what I've been lacking for some time is the ability to cut down larger material i.e. my next project is 3x8 based and at some point I'll need to cut down sleepers or similar for the raised beds.

My feeling is that a decent mitre saw would have been handy on loads of stuff I've done to date, but I've managed ok with the circular saw and flipping material to a degree. I would however love a bit more precision of cutting lengths, also useful for interior coving, skirting, architrave type jobs. The main issue I have is room for permanent assembly in my garage as they're all pretty deep and I'll need to create a much deeper space for it to be in situ. My gut feel is that rather than take up all that space all the time, I'd probably store it on one of my garage shelves and use it on a mitre saw stand for jobs i,e. https://www.dewalt.co.uk/product/de7023-xj/mitre-saw-workstation . Means I might use it slightly less, but still going to be really useful and maybe at some point I'll get it full time in a space but unlikely for a couple of years.

I like to buy once and use forever rather than buy cheap and twice. I have mostly makita 18v/36v brushless for everything else but I'm not fussed about cordless for something like this which will need repeatable power and I could just run an extension to easily from my outside sockets. I'm just torn on size and what to go for really. I don't want to spend loads and loads but currently I've considered

1. Dewalt DWS780 - Can be picked up with the stand above for < £700 delivered
2. Evolution-r255sms-db - 10 inch circa £400 with stand
3. Makita LS1019 - 10 inch circa £800 with stand

I'm really keen to get a sliding and double bevel where possible, I think 10" would be fine but that DWS780 at 12" would be super useful for certain jobs, has a great reputation and I know would cover any need I possibly have. Anyone gone down this rabbit hole recently and can share any advice? I guess I do need to keep weight and storage space on my garage racking in mind. i.e. need to get it out and onto the stand for it to be useful. I should be able to setup in the middle of the garage when it's reasonably clear so that's also a nice option to have. Also dust extraction is a must, and I like the idea of shadow line for more accurate cutting, but I know that can be fairly easily achieved with 3rd party light add-ons so not 100% essential. I'll keep watching videos and reading up, but any help appreciated as always.
 
Have you considered picking up a decent used flip over table saw with legs?
I've always found that my Makita one which is one 20 years old now has done everything I could ask, even had dust exaction addon. Yes they take up more room, but it's much more versatile IMO.
 
If its for limited use I would hire personally.

I used to be in the toolhire game so got staff discount but the difference from a piece of pro kit (list of like £4k) compared to a diy level one its night and day if you cutting heavier stuff like sleepers.
Really depends if your going to be able to do all the main cutting over say a weekend or short week, or it will drag out over many weeks.
 
If its for limited use I would hire personally.

I used to be in the toolhire game so got staff discount but the difference from a piece of pro kit (list of like £4k) compared to a diy level one its night and day if you cutting heavier stuff like sleepers.
Really depends if your going to be able to do all the main cutting over say a weekend or short week, or it will drag out over many weeks.
Thanks but most jobs are when I get time and usually span several weeks. I do hire other kit when I know it's a short sharp piece of work but it's not going to be cost efficient for what I have planned i.e. quite a few large projects over many months.
 
Have you considered picking up a decent used flip over table saw with legs?
I've always found that my Makita one which is one 20 years old now has done everything I could ask, even had dust exaction addon. Yes they take up more room, but it's much more versatile IMO.
I haven't considered this, so will take a look into it
 
This video I've linked to below shows you much of what you probably already know but serves as a good reminder.


My biggest gripe about my mitre saw is the slide being at the rear. If I was getting a new one I'd only consider a forward slide for using it up against a wall while on the bench and for easier storage.
 
This video I've linked to below shows you much of what you probably already know but serves as a good reminder.


My biggest gripe about my mitre saw is the slide being at the rear. If I was getting a new one I'd only consider a forward slide for using it up against a wall while on the bench and for easier storage.
Yeah front rails or mechanism like the bosch is a must for me too. I've probably watched every video on YouTube at this point but will watch that again as it's always easy to get carried away
 
FWIW the evolution is a great tool I have used and abused one of those a lot but its not big enough to cut sleepers in one go, few are. The others of that size are not worth the extra ££ IMO unless you want the flexibility of cordless. Although with a mitre saw I find im always near to a power source when using it.

I mostly use makita XGT stuff now, great tools but i've not seen the reason yet to upgrade the evolution. I have the smaller evolution as well which is a great size and easy to move about.
 
Back
Top Bottom