• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Which NAS?

Soldato
Joined
21 Jul 2004
Posts
6,368
Location
Harrow, UK
I currently have 4 x 3TB in RAID 5 using an onboard controller and I am thinking of upgrading to a Gigabit NAS where I can put in 4 x 4TB drives in RAID 5.

I rather not build my own one, so I would like to buy a unit... any recommendations?
 
Personally, I'd just build a low powered server. Much more flexible

It might be more flexible, but I can't really be bothered with the hassle.


Depends on budget.

I'd be looking at an Austor/QNAP or Synology

Synology for an out of the box appliance solution.

The cost is not really an issue, but I don't want to go over the top and pay for something that I will not utilise.

From what you guys have said, Synology is looking to be the best but I was comparing it to the QNAP ones and cannot really figure out what the differences are that actually apply to me. I have paired up the below:

http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=NW-029-SY&groupid=46&catid=2125
http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=NW-008-QN&groupid=46&catid=2125

http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=NW-028-SY&groupid=46&catid=2125
http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=NW-016-QN&groupid=46&catid=2125

I looked at the 8 bay ones as well for future expansion.

I also read that some of these have a maximum 4TB drive capacity... what is the limiting factor for this. When 5TB drives come out, will it definitely not work with this, or will a software upgrade solve that?
 
I still can't seem to decide on the drives to choose. Some people are telling me that normal drives are fine and that it isn't worth paying the premium for NAS/Enterprise drives. What do you guys think?
 
I did have a look at the WD Red drives but they aren't available in 4TB versions.

Sorry, I don't get why I would have a hard time accessing it if it dies. Unless you mean if the actual Synology NAS dies... if that was to happen, could I not get a new one and plug the drives into that and carry on from where I left off?
 
Yeah, I mean the Synology dying. The drawback to proprietary raid is that, well, it's proprietary. So there's no option to plug the drives into a non-synology box to get at your data.

Buying the same model Synology as a replacement would work. A newer one bought in a few years time might, it depends how much value they place on backwards compatibility. It's not a big issue, but it gave me pause when choosing between hardware raid and software.

edit: re red drives - well damn, you're right. I wonder what WD are playing at there.

I never thought that when I was considering NAS there would be so many things to factor in.

The reason I was leaning towards SHR-2 was because I can just whack in another drive when I start running out of space, which I don't believe is possible with a RAID 6 setup.

Western Digital are my preferred make of drives but their Green range doesn't have 4TB ones either. I am a bit wary of venturing to other drive manufacturers but it looks like I don't have much of a choice.

Instead of 5 x 4TB drives, I think I will go for 6 x 3TB WD Red :)


/Edit: According to this I can expand a RAID 6 array with another drive:
http://forum.synology.com/wiki/inde...t-Spare.2FRAID-6_Volume_with_additional_disks
 
Last edited:
I'm also looking at these with the view of 4 x 1TB disks in a RAID config. Multi LUNs for normal PC usage, iTunes (500GB collection) and VMware

Also got a stack of JBOD -
2 x 76GB
2 x 160GB
1 x 250GB
1 x 320GB
1 x 160GB 2.5"

PC and laptop are running off SSD and I also use SkyDrive

Looks like it could be Synology, I was originally leaning towards the QNAP

If it helps, I've had my Synoloy for 1 day now and am not regretting my purchase :cool:
 
Link aggregation is pointless unless you expect to exceed 1Gbit throughput.

Usage scenario in which you would might be multiple clients using the NAS simultaneously (Multiple PCs + media devices) or if your desktop has multiple gigabit NICs you intend to aggregate also.

Throughput is still limited on a single client to NAS basis by the speed of the client...in a typical desktop usage scenario this will be 1Gbit.

When I move house in the next few months, my PC will be connected to the switch with 2 x 1GBit connections paired together. The NAS will also be connected the same way.
 
What model did you get?

I got the DS1813+, but have only filled 6 of the drive bays. This was my order:

goodies.png


I am returning the NetGear switch and am buying the HP ProCurve 1810-24G because I didn't realise that the one I had ordered didn't support LACP.
 
Did you get the SSD for the NAS too mate?
I note that the latest beta firmware (which i'm running at moment) has support for SSD caching - but looking at the forums it seems like you need at least two for it to work...

I didn't bother with the SSDs. My NAS is primarily for storage so need need the speed, but the reason I wanted LACP was to cater for more than one PC copying to/from it on a gigabit connection.
 
Back
Top Bottom