Which screen recording software?

dacads

dacads

dacads

Soldato
Joined
3 Sep 2012
Posts
11,492
Location
P town
So planning on recording some gameplay, what shall I go for:

Fraps
OBS
??

Suggestions welcome

I remember using fraps back in the day, the files used to be massive i,e gigabytes. I guess this is probably still the same if the files are uncompressed, any software that will record and then compress/encode the files?
 
Last edited:
fraps,dxtory are the main but with nvidia doing shadowplay for free its hard to ignore it.

i personally mainly use fraps. yes the files are big but for top notch quality most are.

best to have a separate drive for recording to the game drive.

there are many guides on youtube for recording with whatever you want to use.

for software sony vegas or adobe products.if its just casual windows movie maker will do .
 
I've been slowly getting my feet wet with this throughout the year, and I have used the free trials of several products, such as D3DGear, Mirillis Action, Dxtory and many others.

I'm still learning, so my understanding may well be flawed, but it seems to be that no matter what one uses, the compression which youtube employs drops the quality of your video considerably. The only thing I can think of to attempt to try and get around it is to either record raw + have a super fast internet connection along with HUGE amounts of disk space,..... or as mentioned, elect for larger file sizes (but not as insanely big as I previously suggested) which is much more practical, of course (e.g. AVI / MKV - the latter which won't work in WMM which is a shame). :/

To give an example : I uploaded a System Shock 2 video last night which I definitely think looks worse in terms of quality compared to the previous one. This is no wonder, as I recorded in MP4 and rendered as M-PEG4 / H.264, thus a very fast upload time : about 7 mins for a 30+ min video, where as rendering in WMV (if my thinking is right) makes it look a little better, but takes longer to upload.....say 15 - 20 mins (hardly a big deal). I also am very limited as I'm still using Windows Movie Maker, but will be switching soon to something much better like, for example, Sony Vegas.
 
Last edited:
Win10 comes with built in recording software but no mic support yet. Afterburner is great for a free package and has customisable options but only records avi and mkv. I also use Movie momaker as its so damn simple and has all I need for captions and music etc but I have to convert the files to MP in order to make it work. Worth it though, works well on Youtube.
 
If your fortunate enough to have a recentish Nvidia GPU then Shadowplay is the best. Virtually no performance hit, and records at 60fps which is fine for youtube. I would say tho that its always a good idea to use a decent editing program to encode with minimal loss.

Its been a few months since I recorded gamplay and uploaded to youtube, but here are two examples recorded with Nvidia Shadowplay, and edited/uploaded with Cyberlink Power Director

Dying Light: https://youtu.be/kWoQSOhVNEs

Witcher 3: https://youtu.be/EqRBEAfMwgM

Both play at 1080 and 60fps :)
 
recording card are like 60-120 quid now! might as well get one of those, no impact on performance etc.
 
Anyone used camtasia for recording games?

we've used it at work for creating instructional videos but not tried it with games. Has mic support too.
 
I usually record AVIs with FRAPS and then render the resultant files with Camtasia Studio 8 down to a few MBs as a resultant MP4-file.

For example, yesterday I had a 9 GB Spelunky AVI-file (just over 7 minutes in length) recorded with FRAPS, and then brought it down to just under 100 MB without any noticeable loss in quality.

If you set FRAPS to record at 50 FPS at 1/2 screen size and then render it in 1280x720 with Camtasia (not forgetting to fit it to size to avoid black borders), you get very good results.

In Camtasia it's mainly noticeable that the file size rockets if you set the quality to over 50%, which is usually quite sufficient.

As I always play un-windowed full screen and don't need to define any borders, FRAPS does a good job, and the file sizes don't matter unless you let them accumulate without rendering them.
 
Last edited:
MSI Afterburner seems an interesting option, didn't know you could record with it.

I think I'll give all 3, (Fraps, OBS & MSI AB) a try and see which I can get best results with.

Sony Vegas is a great, easy to use editing program so will need to get that installed again. I think it will be important to get the rendering settings right in Vegas, unless the recording software can output a ready to upload file.


Edit: Just tried recording with Fraps, forgot about the watermark in the free version. That's put me off from using it, I'll try MSI AB and OBS now assuming they have no watermark in the video.

Thought it would be easier to use Movie Maker for now, so downloaded that and then rendered the recorded clips in mp4 @ 8Mbps

https://youtu.be/1DKW9v4nDEs

https://youtu.be/f0_0rAPsCQ4
 
Last edited:
Does anyone use LoiLo Game Recorder?

Tried it with some Vermintide earlier, seemed to record o.k, though my voice TS3 was very quiet, but everyone else seemed fine.
 
DEL 707 said:
Does anyone use LoiLo Game Recorder?

Tried it with some Vermintide earlier, seemed to record o.k, though my voice TS3 was very quiet, but everyone else seemed fine.
Click to expand...

I briefly used it when I had issues getting Afterburner and some other recording software to do what I wanted. Worked ok, and was easy to set up and get going quickly.
 
Using Raptr with my card; and afterburner at other times. I'm going to be checking OBS soon; and also look at picking up recording card to plug in. I have no performance hit using raptr with my 290.....
 
AHarvey said:
Anyone used camtasia for recording games?

we've used it at work for creating instructional videos but not tried it with games. Has mic support too.
Click to expand...

I used to use it many years ago for the Techsmith codec that was lossless. Allowed for very small files.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom