• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

which would you prefer?

i am getting a lot of different opinions here. can anyone confirm whether or not i will be much better off with the x1800xt or should i stick with what i have now?
 
Pulse said:
dno if i can post this but have a look at this Tom's Hardware

just flick through the games and you can see how much better the X1800XT performs

Yup, even wallops 2x Ultras. :)

For example COD2, 2x 6800 GT's 1280x1024 = 23fps 2x 6800 Ultras = 26fps

1x single x1800 XT = 37fps, hows it not faster, and thats with 4xAA and 8xAF (and also 4xAA/8xAF on the GT's/Ultras) , and go through the other games as well. :confused:
 
Last edited:
WTF Is wrong with everyone tonight.


X1800 XT is faster. FACT


Check the benchy's...


Get the XT.
 
The speed boost from a pair of 6800gts to a single X1800XT would be fairly minor and in some cases the 6800gts would come out on top. Now if he was going to a X1900XT or if he just wanted to play with some new hardware, that'd be a different story, but the upgrade he's making....will probably be disappointing.
 
Personally I'd stick with the 6800GT-SLI. If you really want to upgrade, at least make it a worthwhile jump, such as the x1900xt or 7950gx2.
 
Going by the benchmarks the x1800xt is 15.6 fps faster over 6 games at 1280x1024, 4xAA, 8xAF. Thats just over 60% faster on average.
 
man_from_uncle said:
The speed boost from a pair of 6800gts to a single X1800XT would be fairly minor and in some cases the 6800gts would come out on top. Now if he was going to a X1900XT or if he just wanted to play with some new hardware, that'd be a different story, but the upgrade he's making....will probably be disappointing.


why would he be? for a start SLI doesnt work on all games, it creates a hell of a lot more heat, its noisy and generally a pain in the arse. then factor in the fact that the X1800XT is a fair ammount faster than the SLI setup he currently has, he cant go wrong...


based on toms hardware benchesHERE , 1280X1024 full AA/AF the following would happen if he got an X1800XT over his two 6800GT`s

Age of empires 3, 100% increase in F.rames P.er S.econd
black and white 2, 27% increase in FPS
Call of Duty 2, 63% increase in FPS
FEAR, 60% increase in FPS
Quake 4, 32% increase in FPS
Serious Sam 2, 100% increase in FPS
78% increase in 3D06 scores.

based on that little lot i would say the X1800XT is very much worth its money...
 
locutus12 said:
why would he be? for a start SLI doesnt work on all games, it creates a hell of a lot more heat, its noisy and generally a pain in the arse.

How do you know?
That isnt how i've seen it or heard about it.
SLI is actually very stable & works with 99% of games. Noise depends on coolers & so does heat!
 
my 2 cards run around 50-70c so do generate a lot of heat but still have only stock coolers on them.
performance wise, i have just benched at everything stock in 3dmark05. i got 7812 points so can anyone confirm whether or not it will be more with an x1800xt or equivanent up to the price range of £200?
 
doran1801 said:
my 2 cards run around 50-70c so do generate a lot of heat but still have only stock coolers on them.
performance wise, i have just benched at everything stock in 3dmark05. i got 7812 points so can anyone confirm whether or not it will be more with an x1800xt or equivanent up to the price range of £200?

Yup single x1800 XT 512mb, on an A64 3500+ all stock 05 score just under 9k. :)
 
Last edited:
locutus12 said:
why would he be? for a start SLI doesnt work on all games, it creates a hell of a lot more heat, its noisy and generally a pain in the arse. then factor in the fact that the X1800XT is a fair ammount faster than the SLI setup he currently has, he cant go wrong...


based on toms hardware benchesHERE , 1280X1024 full AA/AF the following would happen if he got an X1800XT over his two 6800GT`s

Age of empires 3, 100% increase in F.rames P.er S.econd
black and white 2, 27% increase in FPS
Call of Duty 2, 63% increase in FPS
FEAR, 60% increase in FPS
Quake 4, 32% increase in FPS
Serious Sam 2, 100% increase in FPS
78% increase in 3D06 scores.

based on that little lot i would say the X1800XT is very much worth its money...

Yup, I still can't believe ppl won't have it that the x1800 XT is faster than 2x 6800 GT's in SLi. :confused:
 
LoadsaMoney said:
Erm why, x1800 XT is miles faster. :confused:

X1800xt isn't faster than 2x 6800gt's in sli, not normally. I had a x1800xt earlier which was nice and overclocked nicely(from 625/1500 to 780/1720), but I changed to 7800gtx 512mb which sort of is superior :p . Anyhow, 2x 6800gt's would in many situations be faster than x1800xt, but I would do the swap if it wouldn't cost him anything...

EDIT: That benchmark from tomshardware is absolute ********. They state that in fear, x1800xt will beat 7800gtx extreme sli! HAH! :eek:
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom