Whoop's - Dead Cooler?

Soldato
Joined
31 Oct 2007
Posts
2,524
Location
Gods County(Allegedly)
Was running a Q9650 under a Titan Fenrir. Very pleased with low temps.

All housed in a 'substantial' (fortunately) Haf 932 case ; which I decided needed a clean.

Placed on top of desk and cleaned then in an 'inspirational' :( moment decided to clean the case wheels , did ,turned my back to the case to speak to better half and it then fell (wheeled?) itself off the desk and nosedived onto the floor.

Lots of swear words , lump out of carpet , blame better half ,later - checked to find that the case was slightly bent (pushed back into shape very easily :) ) but otherwise all 'looked' o'k.

Got it up and running again and checked temps - now running at 75c at idle rather than the usual 29c :eek:.

Dismantled and realised that the fall had caused the cooler to move/slip - not a problem , just reinstall I thought but then noticed that one of the heatpipes (to the back of the cpu - nearest to rear case fan) was now indented/creased in two places (towards the corners of the cpu) and between the two indents there was a scratch.

On reinstall added a little xtra thermal paste at the points if indent/scratch and it's running pretty well again - 30c at idle.

Just concerned that the indents etc might 'fail' at some indeterminate point so have decided to get a new cooler .

Rushed a bit and have gone ahead and ordered a Megahalems but am now wondering if I'd have been better served being a bit more paitent and waiting for the corsair h50 to come back in stock or going for a different air cooler?

As it's the weekend would hope that if I decided to change and contacted OcUk first thing monday then hopefully 'no problem' if I wished to change.

So summary ?'s from 'idiot' of the week here are :-
1. Am I right 'not' to trust the 'indented' Titan ?
2. Is the Megahalems the 'best' air cooler (intention would be to use push/pull config) ?
3. Does the Megahalems outperform the Corsair - Am looking for 'quiet' but very good cooling ?
4. Best fans - Apache ?
5. Anyone know if I would have any problems fitting either to an asus P5Q-E motherboard ?

Better half has just reminded me that it is essential that I point out that the case falling of the desk had nothing to do with her !! - For myself the jury's still out on that one :D
 
It appears that the temps have increased by approx 5c since rebuilding.

Running @ 4ghz and idle reads 34c as compared to 29c before.(when I read 30c earlier it was , in fact, the temp. after the comp. had reset itself)

At least it seems stable !!
 
Many thanks for the replies.:)

Decided to 'stick' with the Megahalems and 2 Apache fans.

Should be up and running before the end of the week & will advise as to results.
 
The new prolimatech cooler arrived yesterday - excellent service again from OcUk :D

Have today installed it and am currently running with Tuniq Tower fan - exhausting to the rear.

Only managed a quick play but so far am impressed - knocked 2c of idle and ,more importantly, 10c on load (intel burn test standard 5 runs). - Running Q9650 @ 4.05

Will probably have a go with Push and pull Apache fans at the weekend, which may shave a further 2/3 c off :)

Certainly much better build quality than the Fenrir but at 1/2 as much again it's to be expected.
Will probably keep the Fenrir as a spare -cannot see a queue for a slightly creased on one heatpipe cooler ;)

Would not recomend letting comp. drop from desk to floor BUT would recomend both the Fenrir (really cannot blame it for creasing a heatpipe and otherwise it cooled quite well )and the Megahalems as coolers.
 
Back
Top Bottom