Why do different ISPs make a difference?

mpj88

mpj88

mpj88

Associate
Joined
26 Apr 2008
Posts
1,305
Location
York
We're coming to the end of our BT contract and looking to change for a better deal. We've been considering options from Vodafone and Plusnet.

My question is why would different ISPs provide different levels of service? On a local Facebook group there are quite a few bad reviews of Vodafone.

I thought all providers used the same hardware, so where does the difference in quality come in?
 
mpj88 said:
I thought all providers used the same hardware, so where does the difference in quality come in?
Click to expand...
The physical connection from your house to the exchange is owned and operated by Openreach. Between the exchange and the internet there are many different combinations depending on the ISP.

In addition, different ISPs offer different routers, some of which are much better than others. TalkTalk offer the Eero as an example and they are extremely decent bits of kit for an ISP offering.
 
ChrisD. said:
The physical connection from your house to the exchange is owned and operated by Openreach. Between the exchange and the internet there are many different combinations depending on the ISP.

In addition, different ISPs offer different routers, some of which are much better than others. TalkTalk offer the Eero as an example and they are extremely decent bits of kit for an ISP offering.
Click to expand...

Exactly this. The equipment owned by different ISPs once it hits the exchange will be better or worse, depending on the ISP but not only that, some ISPs will have a contention ratios for their users and if that exchange has everyone using Vodafone then their equipment might be maxed out and not running as well, potentially throttling your connection. Nobody in your area might use TalkTalk so their kit is sat there at full performance waiting for someone to use it.

The reviews aren't always a great guideline because most people don't know what a router is and would just call it an Internet box. :D I feel sorry for the support people when they have to ask them to do anything other than switch it off and on again! I find that most companies are the same to be honest, they always try to get you to do the stupidest things when something's not working but if you have a bit of IT skills you know what to do or know that what they're telling you is BS. Most people don't, unfortunately, and will just leave a bad review because their Internet is broken.
 
Last edited:
I recently moved from BT to EE and haven’t noticed any change except for the £25 cheaper per month. Same speed across the body and the change was seamless.
 
Another thing to consider is how well trained their customer support is too. Some ISPs have useless support strictly following a script which can make troubleshooting hard if a customer does have a problem and need help, while others can catch up what the exact issue is and speedily helps you get it sorted. This can also land a negative review as well.

And in general, when it works well, people won't usually bother leaving a review about their positive experience.
 
@mpj88 Right now is super bad to be changing. You want to get someone who will not raise prices in April. Your best bet is to log into BT, click Broadband tab then Upgrade Broadband. This will give you tailored upgrade offers. If they are still bad, live chat should pop up. Just make sure on the bot you go to "Leaving BT". You'll get through to retentions team in Newcastle who will help you. BT is losing hundreds of thousands of customers each quarter to altnets, they have to stop the bleeding: https://www.ispreview.co.uk/talk/th...-million-broadband-customers-in-a-year.41164/

If BT are stil being awful and you want to switch, make sure that cashback is obtained for whoever you go with.

@Viberious Not surprising, it's the same company and line. Funnily enough if you have EE broadband you can stil login with PPPoE details from BT.
 
Last edited:
ChrisD. said:
The physical connection from your house to the exchange is owned and operated by Openreach. Between the exchange and the internet there are many different combinations depending on the ISP.

In addition, different ISPs offer different routers, some of which are much better than others. TalkTalk offer the Eero as an example and they are extremely decent bits of kit for an ISP offering.
Click to expand...
Thanks, that helps me understand better.

I guessed about the router, but I would just need it to operate in modem only mode as use my own router and wireless access points.
 
Nemiyen said:
Exactly this. The equipment owned by different ISPs once it hits the exchange will be better or worse, depending on the ISP but not only that, some ISPs will have a contention ratios for their users and if that exchange has everyone using Vodafone then their equipment might be maxed out and not running as well, potentially throttling your connection. Nobody in your area might use TalkTalk so their kit is sat there at full performance waiting for someone to use it.

The reviews aren't always a great guideline because most people don't know what a router is and would just call it an Internet box. :D I feel sorry for the support people when they have to ask them to do anything other than switch it off and on again! I find that most companies are the same to be honest, they always try to get you to do the stupidest things when something's not working but if you have a bit of IT skills you know what to do or know that what they're telling you is BS. Most people don't, unfortunately, and will just leave a bad review because their Internet is broken.
Click to expand...
Yes I do try to bear this in mind regarding reviews as its what i think when someone post on a facebook group saying is anyone else's wifi down....
 
Last edited:
Viberious said:
I recently moved from BT to EE and haven’t noticed any change except for the £25 cheaper per month. Same speed across the body and the change was seamless.
Click to expand...
BT own EE anyway so wouldnt the kit/backend from the excahnge be just the same?

Edit - had a quick check of EE packages and although better than what I'm on now, still not better than vodafone/plusnet offerings
 
Last edited:
GregI said:
@mpj88 Right now is super bad to be changing. You want to get someone who will not raise prices in April. Your best bet is to log into BT, click Broadband tab then Upgrade Broadband. This will give you tailored upgrade offers. If they are still bad, live chat should pop up. Just make sure on the bot you go to "Leaving BT". You'll get through to retentions team in Newcastle who will help you. BT is losing hundreds of thousands of customers each quarter to altnets, they have to stop the bleeding: https://www.ispreview.co.uk/talk/th...-million-broadband-customers-in-a-year.41164/

If BT are stil being awful and you want to switch, make sure that cashback is obtained for whoever you go with.

@Viberious Not surprising, it's the same company and line. Funnily enough if you have EE broadband you can stil login with PPPoE details from BT.
Click to expand...
I have tried this, the retentions team were hopeless. Didn't put up much of a fight to try and keep me. The £1/month increase in April would still save me over £10/month than what I'm paying now.
 
Last edited:
ChrisD. said:
The physical connection from your house to the exchange is owned and operated by Openreach. Between the exchange and the internet there are many different combinations depending on the ISP.

In addition, different ISPs offer different routers, some of which are much better than others. TalkTalk offer the Eero as an example and they are extremely decent bits of kit for an ISP offering.
Click to expand...

i am on this with talktalk the eero is flawless.
 
mpj88 said:
Edit - had a quick check of EE packages and although better than what I'm on now, still not better than vodafone/plusnet offerings
Click to expand...
PlusNet are perfectly fine, it'll be no different to EE/BT apart from the router. Not sure what their hub is like these days. But from a network and CS perspective they are excellent.
 
mpj88 said:
We're coming to the end of our BT contract and looking to change for a better deal. We've been considering options from Vodafone and Plusnet.

My question is why would different ISPs provide different levels of service? On a local Facebook group there are quite a few bad reviews of Vodafone.

I thought all providers used the same hardware, so where does the difference in quality come in?
Click to expand...

In my humble experience, the real difference is customer support.

You invariably find, with more expensive ISP's, that the customer service is massively improved.

What pushed me to a better ISP where two experiences -

1. Virgin CS - Phoned them up to find out what options were available for the new occupier of my home (who was a friend). Explained it to them that I had sold my house but the new owner wanted to keep my telephone number...was that possible? He clearly did not understand what I was asking for, so the call ended with no conclusion. However, the guy renewed my contract!! And when I moved out a week later, Virgin demanded £180 for terminating the contract early .. and threatened to take me to court if I didn't pay up. This quickly spiralled in to threatening letters from what appeared to be a legal firm, but in fact is just another Virgin department..

2. Talktalk - Changing my contract to include an additional service, Talktalk thought all I wanted was that new service and they cancelled everything else. They disconnected my broadband and it took two weeks to get it reconnected. Once again, a CS department misunderstood what I wanted.

3. The final straw was when my data was stolen in the Talktalk hack. It specifically annoyed me that I incurred additional costs to make things secure again and never received a penny from Talktalk or even a decent apology.

Anyway, I went with Zen after that. Although the service from Zen has declined over the years, they are still a darn sight better than the average supplier.
 
Plusnet are generally the best for CS. In the far past Virgin were extremely helpful, but that could've been 15yrs ago..

Regarding April price rises, i just got Now BB for 12 months with cashback. Doesn't seem many at all are doing 12months. Though any longer and i'd just gone with Plusnet again. But the price hike now shouldn't be like last year. But if you're paying for cheaper BB the ~8% increase won't make much difference.
 
SpellowHouse said:
In my humble experience, the real difference is customer support.

You invariably find, with more expensive ISP's, that the customer service is massively improved.

What pushed me to a better ISP where two experiences -

1. Virgin CS - Phoned them up to find out what options were available for the new occupier of my home (who was a friend). Explained it to them that I had sold my house but the new owner wanted to keep my telephone number...was that possible? He clearly did not understand what I was asking for, so the call ended with no conclusion. However, the guy renewed my contract!! And when I moved out a week later, Virgin demanded £180 for terminating the contract early .. and threatened to take me to court if I didn't pay up. This quickly spiralled in to threatening letters from what appeared to be a legal firm, but in fact is just another Virgin department..

2. Talktalk - Changing my contract to include an additional service, Talktalk thought all I wanted was that new service and they cancelled everything else. They disconnected my broadband and it took two weeks to get it reconnected. Once again, a CS department misunderstood what I wanted.

3. The final straw was when my data was stolen in the Talktalk hack. It specifically annoyed me that I incurred additional costs to make things secure again and never received a penny from Talktalk or even a decent apology.

Anyway, I went with Zen after that. Although the service from Zen has declined over the years, they are still a darn sight better than the average supplier.
Click to expand...
Thanks for input. Had a quick look at zen but seem to be £10/month more than same service from plusnet so will give them a shot.
 
mpj88 said:
Thanks for input. Had a quick look at zen but seem to be £10/month more than same service from plusnet so will give them a shot.
Click to expand...
Honestly you can't go wrong with PN, I've been with them before for years and my mum is currently with them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom