• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

will blu ray take off?

Mr-Xoc said:
I know its not exactly 100% acurate, but I still found it funny ;)

Anyway havent Sony lost more format wars then they have won?

Mr-Xoc

But the formats they have been involved either on their own or with others have been somewhat major.

Also am i alone in wondering why people say the memory stick failed? Sure not many if any other companies use it, but Sony still shift plenty. And the thing is we have only had what 2 types of Memory stick, all the other formats have about 18 versions. And the video saying it lost to compact flash? :confused: i know what one you can still buy ;)

As for folk saying BluRay is to expensive, when the PS3 comes out it kinda nullifies thats as the PS3 will be the same price as an HD-DVD player, and a well known competitor has HD-DVD and BluRay disks at the same price?
 
JUMPURS said:
Also am i alone in wondering why people say the memory stick failed? Sure not many if any other companies use it, but Sony still shift plenty. And the thing is we have only had what 2 types of Memory stick, all the other formats have about 18 versions. And the video saying it lost to compact flash? :confused: i know what one you can still buy ;)

nah, i wonder too - seems quite successful in my Sony phone, sony camera, and PSP :D

As good as SD, if a little pricier, only negative was that until the PRO came out it was limited to 128MB
 
JUMPURS said:
As for folk saying BluRay is to expensive, when the PS3 comes out it kinda nullifies thats as the PS3 will be the same price as an HD-DVD player, and a well known competitor has HD-DVD and BluRay disks at the same price?

Maybe in the US. But when the PS3 launches here, which may be later than they have suggested again to further shortages they announced recently. By that time I'm sure the price of HD-DVD players will have come down a little, especially as plenty of HDTVs will be shifted in the January sales, making way for the new models.

The other factor is that the main reason its taking long to get the PS3 out is due to the Blue Ray diode. Is this in all Blueray players? Or is it just a special one for reading all the discs that the PS3 needs to read? If its the same, surely that means Blueray shortages there too.

Unlike DVD which was really a welcome addition to the home video market, the next generation ones don't seem so clear cut. We could end up with one format in one country, another format winning in another. Obviously not everyone has HDTVs yet and I for one don't want to buy all the films I have again in a new format. It was understandable with VHS because it was an outdated format, degraded, and didn't offer the features that DVD does. The new formats will only offer a better picture really.

It's going to be an interesting scrap. But as another poster said, I think HD-DVD will have the advantage in this country because of its name and the PS3 delay.
 
The core problem with sony's formats is that they add so much DRM type security to it as to make it unappealing to joe public. Lets face it if you had 2 mp3 players and one let you put on any mp3/wma/ogg file etc and the other ONLY allowed protected WMA files with digital rights signatures, which one would sell? The cold hard truth of the world ladies and gentlemenn.
 
Isn't it true that current HD-DVD players have no region encoding? Also it doesn't require HDMI port à la 360 HD-DVD?

The reason VHS beat Beta Max, even when it was superior quality was due to the porn industry. It was the choice for pirates hence market domination.

I personally think Blu-ray will just end up as a PC storage media and HD-DVD being the true entertainment format.
 
Last edited:
MS = pc's and if they use hddvd then vista will be on hddvd and everything else we have from
youve got to wonder how its gonnna work on that side of things?
 
The reason Blu-ray is more expensive isn't just down to the amount the players cost, it's also because they are more expensive to make. They need a special scratch-resistant coating because they store data closer to the surface of the disc. It's fairly easy to upgrade a factory to press HD-DVDs but it's harder to set them up for this coating that blu-ray discs need.

The new formats will only offer a better picture really.
There are other things they offer, but that's more down to the set standards rather than the technology itself. For example I think the current standard for blu-ray includes a subset of Java, meaning you can have much more interactive content than the basic menu driven system DVDs have. HD-DVD has something else too but not quite as advanced as Java.
 
Eliot said:
ms = everthing and if they use hddvd then vista will eb on hddvd and evrything else we have
youve got to wonder how its gonnna work]

MS >< everything no matter how much they try tbh
Hence why Zune is gonna fall flat on its big brown butt
I dont think we will see Vista on hd-dvd tbh MS would be commiting suicide if they only released it on that.
 
JUMPURS said:
MS >< everything no matter how much they try tbh
Hence why Zune is gonna fall flat on its big brown butt
I dont think we will see Vista on hd-dvd tbh MS would be commiting suicide if they only released it on that.
well if they support it what does that mean :S i assumed it ment they would be chucking there games and os on hddvd in *** future
im not saying that it wont eb on dvd
but vista wont come on br thats for sure
 
I personally think blue ray will die a death, the only thing it has that may save it is if the PS3 is a huge success, only then will it stand a chance. It has quite a few things going against it.

- The name, i mean if joe public is walking down the street and fancies a bit of HD goodness, whats he gonna buy, HD-DVD or bloody Blue Ray...

- The cost involved in setting up production for the discs is HUGE, relatively cheap to make HD-DVD, everyone knows its a matter of time before dual format players hit the shops, and when they do, what do you think manufactures will make, expensive Blue Ray or cheap as chips HD-DVD ?

- Copy protection, most formats are won and lost on this, and sony being sony have gone so OTT that HD-DVD will be the popular choice for the little rascals.



just my 2 cents, personally although very tempted by the HD-DVD addon, the fact that the 360 sounds like a hair dryer has put me off, i am going to wait for a nice dual format player to come out
 
Eliot said:
well if they support it what does that mean :S i assumed it ment they would be chucking there games and os on hddvd in *** future
im not saying that it wont eb on dvd
but vista wont come on br thats for sure

I got no idea what purpose it serves really beyond the xbox.
BD has some big supporters such as Dell (who i think are the worlds largest PC manufacturer) support BD exclusively, along with Apple, who dont forget are the original trend setters really. And apple brings along Disney and Pixar. You have the obvious Sony movies who i think might be the largest studio in the world. Also Sony TV and Sony BMG.
So i think looking at that, although HD-DVD has MS and Intel, both of them dont really have any direct influence on the actual format as far as i can see.

The only feature about HD-DVD i like is the fact it can have (and i dont think its a guarantee) both DVD and HD-DVD versions on the one disc. But once you by a player its kinda pointless really isnt it?
 
JUMPURS said:
I got no idea what purpose it serves really beyond the xbox.
BD has some big supporters such as Dell (who i think are the worlds largest PC manufacturer) support BD exclusively, along with Apple, who dont forget are the original trend setters really. And apple brings along Disney and Pixar. You have the obvious Sony movies who i think might be the largest studio in the world. Also Sony TV and Sony BMG.
So i think looking at that, although HD-DVD has MS and Intel, both of them dont really have any direct influence on the actual format as far as i can see.

The only feature about HD-DVD i like is the fact it can have (and i dont think its a guarantee) both DVD and HD-DVD versions on the one disc. But once you by a player its kinda pointless really isnt it?

Actually it's Disney corp that is the biggest studio, so they do have some heavy hitters on there side. When you look at it that way, HD-DVD does seem to have the odds against it, but I don't think that matters. Whoever wins, the studios will have their movies on the format that sells.

I got a DVD player back when they first came out in the UK and you could only find a handful of films in the shops. Back then only certain studios produced them until it was tested and then they all jumped on the bandwagon.


So next generation DVDs are going to bring Java content? That's hardly revolutionary or really adding anything new is it? Certianly not worth spending money on for most people. Its a battle that has to be won first in the countries who are much further ahead of us with HD in their homes.
 
I think both will not make as big an impact as expected.

Digital distribution will surpass both as home connections get quicker and quicker.

Blu-ray is such a cool name though :)
 
JUMPURS said:
I got no idea what purpose it serves really beyond the xbox.
BD has some big supporters such as Dell (who i think are the worlds largest PC manufacturer) support BD exclusively, along with Apple, who dont forget are the original trend setters really. And apple brings along Disney and Pixar. You have the obvious Sony movies who i think might be the largest studio in the world. Also Sony TV and Sony BMG.
So i think looking at that, although HD-DVD has MS and Intel, both of them dont really have any direct influence on the actual format as far as i can see.

The only feature about HD-DVD i like is the fact it can have (and i dont think its a guarantee) both DVD and HD-DVD versions on the one disc. But once you by a player its kinda pointless really isnt it?

Apple are seen as the first big name player that will fall off blu-ray bandwagon and will support both formats... http://www.thinksecret.com/news/0610brieflyhddvd.html

I've been following this battle on the avsforums and the general consensus is Disney will follow soon after. Fox are a little more stubborn but will support both by end of next year. Sony will only support HD-DVD when there's no other choice.

Whilst HD-DVD is out performing blu-ray http://www.thedvdwars.com/index.cfm I can't see there being a winner for a long time, if at all. Didn't it take 7 years for DVD to start outselling VHS? And that was a much bigger visible jump.
 
So next generation DVDs are going to bring Java content? That's hardly revolutionary or really adding anything new is it? Certianly not worth spending money on for most people. Its a battle that has to be won first in the countries who are much further ahead of us with HD in their homes.
Quite true. They could have put Java into the DVD video standard if they wanted, so I agree that the technology itself isn't anything new.
 
EezerGoode said:
I think both will not make as big an impact as expected.

Digital distribution will surpass both as home connections get quicker and quicker.

It may do eventually, but the world isn't ready for digital distribution yet. A 1080p HD movie is what, >20 GB? That's gonna take a long time to download, and neither the 360 or PS3 has any way of storing something that big. Even if they could save films to external HDs, you're still talking a small number of films in total you could store.

If the PS3 had a blue-ray burner or the 360 had a HD-DVD burner then maybe it could work, but neither of those things are likely. So in the meantime there's no storage space for these movies. I must have about 200 DVDs, a modest collection really, but imagine if those were HD and had to be stored digitally, you're talking 4,000 GB. So for now digital distribution will only work as a rental service, and TBH it's not going to make much impact there until films can be downloaded in about an hour since I'm sure most people want to watch a film the same night they rent it. It's not going to take a significant slice of movie sales anytime soon, and AFAICS it has no way of threatenning BR/HD-DVD sales.

Also I think there's still a lot of people who want to own a real disc in a real box, that doesn't dissapear if some company happens to go bust.
 
Back
Top Bottom