Mortgage Rate Rises

Associate
Joined
14 May 2006
Posts
1,285
Many people just can't or don't want to look at it that way I guess.
And just like the tangible simple feeling of overpaying.
People being stung by big jumps in interest rates on their mortgages probably made overpaying more comforting! Or personal savings allowance and getting taxed on interest given that it is much more likely now that savings rates are more appealing (assuming outside of an appropriate tax wrapper)!

Seeing outstanding payment duration on the mortgage drop from 20+ years to much less is always nice too :D
 
Soldato
Joined
21 Sep 2020
Posts
3,564
Right, I’ve looked it up it looks like they don’t really allow it. So £5k over 11.5 years is nothing. Pay as much as you can now and it’ll reduce your overall interest.

Personally I wouldn’t bother as you’ll earn more saving it.

Normally even paying £200 p/m extra over 13 years would say you about £5.5k in interest and would get you finished in 10 years.
 
Caporegime
Joined
13 Jan 2010
Posts
32,586
Location
Llaneirwg
People being stung by big jumps in interest rates on their mortgages probably made overpaying more comforting! Or personal savings allowance and getting taxed on interest given that it is much more likely now that savings rates are more appealing (assuming outside of an appropriate tax wrapper)!

Seeing outstanding payment duration on the mortgage drop from 20+ years to much less is always nice too :D
Personally, if I was keen to pay off my mortgage quickly I'd stick xK into a fixed bond and just dump it into the mortgage at renewal when no ercs are applicable.

Obviously that depends on your mortgage being lower than best fixes around.
 
Soldato
Joined
17 Nov 2003
Posts
5,290
Location
St Breward Cornwall
Why did we overpay


A/ wanted our names on the deeds not the Nationwide

B/ no fees for overpayment

C/ we were on child tax credits Savings would have lost us well in excess of 5k a year add in uni grants, kids ema when it was a thing we are talking a lot more

D/ no temptation to spend as it's locked up in equity

E/ we knew on sale after the 9 years it took to pay it off it was all ours and the plan to move somewhere nice was game on
 
Soldato
Joined
10 Jan 2012
Posts
3,686
Location
UK
I just called them back. I can overpay 10% of the original amount borrowed (£85K so £8,500) each year.
it would be 10% of what is left over come the start of the year. Not 10% of the original amount. Unless they have some weird rule no one else does.

Last year I had £38k at the start of my mortgage. I paid £3800 overpayment.
This year it was down to £32k or so. I could only pay £3200.
 
Last edited:
Soldato
Joined
12 Mar 2006
Posts
22,990
Location
N.E England
25k left here on mine, 4.95% I get charged 5% on over payment amount currently as I'm outside my fee free allowance now which nets saving down to around 4% (equal saver almost)

Hacking at it absolutely wherever possible, mainly because it removes any temptation of cash being sat in savings and buying unnecessary crap, this for me is reason enough now.
 
Last edited:
Soldato
Joined
20 Oct 2002
Posts
17,951
Location
London
If your interested is calculated daily on the mortgage then overpaying every month would be more beneficial than waiting to put a lump sum in, surely.

I still don't buy the idea that saving to pay off in a lump sum is better than overpaying every month. Let's say your mortgage is £300k borrowed, and you're paying say 3% on that. That's 3% on 300k. If you start saving with an interest rate of, say 5% you're not getting 5% interest on 300k are you. You're getting 5% on, say the £2500 you just put in.

Either way I'd prefer to hit it at source and not have to manage another savings account, and not be tempted to spend it at a later date.
 
Soldato
Joined
14 Jan 2018
Posts
14,766
Location
Hampshire
If your interested is calculated daily on the mortgage then overpaying every month would be more beneficial than waiting to put a lump sum in, surely.

I still don't buy the idea that saving to pay off in a lump sum is better than overpaying every month. Let's say your mortgage is £300k borrowed, and you're paying say 3% on that. That's 3% on 300k. If you start saving with an interest rate of, say 5% you're not getting 5% interest on 300k are you. You're getting 5% on, say the £2500 you just put in.

Either way I'd prefer to hit it at source and not have to manage another savings account, and not be tempted to spend it at a later date.
No, it would be better to earn 5% on the overpayment, except in a scenario where you don't have any savings allowances e.g additional rate taxpayers.
 
Soldato
Joined
20 Oct 2002
Posts
17,951
Location
London
No, it would be better to earn 5% on the overpayment, except in a scenario where you don't have any savings allowances e.g additional rate taxpayers.
So you're comparing the percentages only on the overpayment amount? But is interest calculated daily on mortgages and savings? If interest is calculated daily on your mortgage, but only paid yearly one your savings account, what does that mean.
You are arguing maths?
Yup. Somebody needs to do an actual example with some simple numbers. Because I still don't get it.

e.g. 250k mortgage. Can save or overpay £500/month. No existing savings. Savings rate 5%, mortgage rate 2%.

Go nuts.
 
Man of Honour
Joined
11 Dec 2002
Posts
10,817
Location
Darkest Norfolk

with your example (assuming 25 year mortgage & no tax on savings):
"
You would be £32,100 better off if you saved at 5% rather than overpaying the mortgage for the 15 years and 7 months it'd take.

This is because if you saved the money, after this time you would still have £109,620 to pay off to clear the mortgage, but you'd have £141,720 in savings, more than enough to clear the balance and still have £32,100 left over (this doesn't include any early repayment fees charged by your lender). Whereas if you had overpaid the mortgage you'd be mortgage free but wouldn't have anything left over"

It also gives you more flexibility in the future - assuming your not on a 25 year fixed every time your mortgage is up for renewal you can pay off as much as you like without penalty allowing you to make a decision at that point if you want to pay off a lump for a better loan to value rate, or keep saving.
 
Last edited:
Soldato
Joined
10 Jan 2012
Posts
3,686
Location
UK
So you're comparing the percentages only on the overpayment amount? But is interest calculated daily on mortgages and savings? If interest is calculated daily on your mortgage, but only paid yearly one your savings account, what does that mean.

Yup. Somebody needs to do an actual example with some simple numbers. Because I still don't get it.

e.g. 250k mortgage. Can save or overpay £500/month. No existing savings. Savings rate 5%, mortgage rate 2%.

Go nuts.
Interest is always daily. So it's better to do it as close to the start of the year as possible for mortgage if going down that route.

Its 2% on the full amount though not just the overpayment. That's like £5000 (not factoring in the amount lowering over the year) per year interest. No calculator I can find can take into account a consistent 10% overpayment each year.
 
Last edited:
Soldato
Joined
14 Jan 2018
Posts
14,766
Location
Hampshire
So you're comparing the percentages only on the overpayment amount? But is interest calculated daily on mortgages and savings? If interest is calculated daily on your mortgage, but only paid yearly one your savings account, what does that mean.
Interest is usually calculated daily, calculated is not the same as paid.
 
Back
Top Bottom