The Holy Quran.

free of original sin, which is transferred to descendant via descendant via the semen which fertilised the egg? i think not, hence why catholics get thier children baptised pronto speed!

free off any sin. they are new people, with no sin. the most pure of all mankind. there are no sins carried on to them, and they have no sins.
 
What about people born blind and deaf who cannot read or hear about needing to have faith in God and live sinlessly?

Why can't God just cut the crap and organise some more divine interventions or something? He's making life boring, forcing us to rely on faith and all that.

When I'm at the pearly gates I think I'll just blag it or something. All this ambiguity makes me think I could probably convince God my sins were by accident.
 
So if your unlucky enough to not have religous carers then your screwed?

That hardly seems fair!

(playing devils advocate - pun intended)
 
no it wouldn't be the deaf dumb blind persons fault

they are physically incapable, it would be the carers fault of not being open minded to let the person make personal decisions for themselves

BUT REmEMBER, i am not a scholar, no am i a imam, nor do i understand the whole of islam. what i am saying is mostly IMO
 
Almost lol

You must admints Gods existance and his prophets. You must have have faith

Using the island example - how can/could you have faith in something that you don't know exists?!

Call me crazy but your life is a gift from Allah and life is but a test. When you are faithful you wil be gifted heavly when you die.

My life is not a gift from Allah. I was born from my mother not by some 'gift' of a (to me) random guy.

I must admit personally I love the small clip from red dwarf stating:

'Archaeologists have discovered a new page from bible which if dated correct would fit at the beginning of the book and read - to my dearest candy, all characters protrated in this book are completely ficticious .....'

Ah that made me laugh.
 
ofcourse not.

As long is that your faithful in your doings and dont sin (eg kill, steal, casue problems etc)

LOL at please God. How you want to please God, perform a dance maybe, sacrofic a virgin etc lol

God is pleased if you Worship him (as long as you thank him for all the good things and bad things) and have faith in his prophets then you will be the first person to go to heaven (theres more to it but its a good start)
Your idea of sin is not really supported by the Bibles(*) of Judaism, Christianity or Islam. Killing is only a sin if it isn't approved of by the religion. For some examples of killing not just being sinless but mandatory, read Leviticus. As for causing problems...does anyone need examples of how all three Abrahamic religions have done that on an appalling scale?

* For anyone who doesn't know: 'bible' simply means 'book' (from the transliterated Greek biblios). Capitalising it implies that it is the book, so it applies equally well to the Torah and the Koran - they are the books for Judaism and Islam.
 
Islam has the same text since day one, hence it is followed, no alteration, no flavours and no preservitives.
Firstly, that is an article of faith. It is not proven and is impossible to prove. You have faith that the Koran has never been altered because it says so, which is not proof of anything.

Secondly, any large body of text is open to numerous interpretations even if it is unaltered, so Islam can change (and has changed) even if the Koran hasn't, and Islam can be (and is) implemented in different ways in different places and at different times.

One of the miracles of Quran is stories of pervious prophets, eg Jesus and the rest. How can possibly Muhammad PBUH know all the stories that the Jews and the Christains also agree on.
He lived 600 years after Jesus, when both Judaism and Christianity had been well established and widespread for a long time. Why would he not know those stories?

Religon is a quide line to life. eg:

Do not kill
Do not take drugs
Do not steal
etc
That doesn't describe the reality of the Abrahamic religions very well.

It is everyones resposibility to understand something before they can jude it.

That requires understanding what really happens, as opposed to an idealised version of it.

Islam means peace and they way it is now followed is not true.

Islam means submission, obedience. It might have been about peace if it was powerless and followed only by gentle people, but it isn't. The same goes for Christianity, a religion that would have a much stronger claim to be about peace if it was also powerless and followed only by gentle people. The teachings of Jesus are almost entirely peace and love to an extreme degree, but does Christianity actually reflect that?

Religion is all very well until people get involved in it.
 
I may be wrong but isn't it considered wrong to have sex with a 9 year old girl? Although perhaps you could correct me as to the age of Aisha when the 'marriage' was consummated!

Are you sure that was when the marriage was consummated in the sense of sex?

In my admittedly cursory reading of translations, all I've seen is that betrothal occured when she was 6 and marriage when she was 9. That can throw many people today, because betrothal is a custom that has fallen into disuse and I've read stuff from people who have obviously read "betrothal" as "marriage" and "marriage" as "sex".

There is also the issue of the word "consummate", which does not mean "have sex". It means "complete".

Betrothal is a binding promise of marriage in the future. It is essentially marriage with a delayed completion. The actual marriage ceremony is therefore a consummation (completion) of the marriage.

This is before the issue of translation - e.g. what does the Arabic word translated as "consummation" actually mean?
 
As Salaam Alaikum,

I was wondering if anybody could suggest any good english translations of Quran. I currently own a Yusuf Ali one but i find the english to be quite old fashioned if you know what i mean. I also own The Qur'an: A Modern English Version (Paperback)
by Majid Fakhry
 
All the OP wanted was a version of the Qu'ran to read out of curiosity, that's it!
Islam has the same text since day one, hence it is followed, no alteration, no flavours and no preservitives.

You don't know that. Unless your 1400 years old.

abz said:
One of the miracles of Quran is stories of pervious prophets, eg Jesus and the rest. How can possibly Muhammad PBUH know all the stories that the Jews and the Christains also agree on.

In western society we call that plagiarism.

abz said:
Religon is a quide line to life. eg:

Do not kill
Do not take drugs
Do not steal
etc

It is everyones resposibility to understand something before they can jude it.

I sure hope English is not your first language, because that ain't the Queen's English.

abz said:
Islam means peace and they way it is now followed is not true.

Pffft. Thats like saying: 'Invading Iraq will bring peace to everyone', I'm sorry I ain't buying.
 
1.Do not judge, or you too will be judged.
2.For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you.

Mattew 7:1-2


:)
 
1. If a religion allows the non-possibility of it's God(s) to exist then it is rendered powerless.

2. If a religion requires it's followers to believe that it's God is the source of everything because of point 1. In essence questioning God(s) existance is not allowed.

3. How can a follower of a religion provide an objective view in an argument unless they break point 1 (and 2) ?
 
free off any sin. they are new people, with no sin. the most pure of all mankind. there are no sins carried on to them, and they have no sins.

not if your a catholic...or believe in catholocism...


but serioualy, can anyone tell me if the books, such as Judges, etc make it into the Torah, and the Quran?

i was reading through last night and managed to find some massive inconsistencies in gods talk and behaviour in the space of 10 pages! its pure maddness.
 
Babies are sin free, and therefore, die sin free, and go to heaven. Infact before a child comes into puberty and sins he/she could have done are on the parents, so if he/she dies, they go to heaven aswell.
Just to stir things up further....whats a baptism then, washing away of sin right ? Whats to wash away if therefor how are babies sin free? For the record, im a christian, but an open minded one.....thus nobody agrees with me in any context lol
 
Back
Top Bottom