Surely, if SD image quality was important to you, you wouldve got a plasma instead? Or do you have other reasons for going for the Samsung LCD?
It doesnt surpise me at all that you wife felt the picture was crap.
Now, this is something I am intrigued about. This "upscalar", tell me more about it please.
I got the Samsung as I'd like to get a PS3 soon for blur ray plus it is rated as a very good TV....
It upscales my current DVD collection I've only just put Matrix on but **** me it looks 10 times better than my old player, plus it can be region hacked with a remote fix that takes 30sec (just about to do this now) plus it plays all sorts of media (below) I also purchased a 24k gold plated HDMI cable for good connection
Playback Media DVD, DVD-R, DVD-RW, DVD+R, DVD+RW, DVD-RAM, CD, CD-R, CD-RW
Playback Formats MP3, WMA, JPEG, MPEG-4, DivX
A/V Quality
Progressive Scan Yes
HD Upconversion 720p/1080i/1080p
Digital-to-Analog Converter 14-Bit/108MHz
DTS Output Yes
Dolby Digital Surround Sound Yes
Connectivity
HDMI CEC Yes
Convenience
Child Protection Parental Control
Physical Features Connectivity
HDMI Output Yes
S-Video Output 1(Rear)
Composite Video Output 1(Rear)
Coaxial Digital Audio Outputs 1(Rear)
Optical Audio Output 1(Rear)
Product Weights & Dimensions
Dimension 16.9" x 8.1" x 9.8"
Weight 4.6 Lbs
Shipment Weights & Dimensions
Dimension 20.4" x 5.2" x 11.4"
Weight 7.1 Lbs