Yeah i agree with you completely when i first logged in i was looking for faults such as clunky combat etc but i was quite suprised at how fluent it was.
I played a Zealot for a little while aswell and it seemed fun, but i then tryed a Black Orc and absolutely loved it as i could take on multiple mobs at once without any problems what so ever and i was brilliant in the PQ's as the bosses were smashing others to bits.
I liked the RvR as unlike a warrior in WoW with a shield you don't die in 5-10 seconds, i was smashing the melee keeping them of the healers while i was getting healed and managed to take out a group of 4-5 melee at one point while putting slows on everyone. I actually felt i was useful in pvp as a tank and the only other game that made me feel that way in the last few years was Lineage2 where tanks played a major part in pvp and didn't hinder a pvp group.
I also liked the way when i wasn't being target i could switch to a big two hander and smash order face in, which made me loose a lot of damage reduction but increased by damage by a load so i could crush their healers.
Overall i can't wait to get play from live now, it might not be a WoW killer yet, but i've grown tired of playing the same game on and off the last four years and i think this will replace it nicely. There are a few problems still with the game, but they are not gamebreaking so the game still plays really well compared to some other games.
If anyone would like to party up and do some of the harder quests im on
Ellyrion server as Destruction and i am a Black Orc name
Kaiez.