• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

ati 5830

Associate
Joined
27 Jan 2010
Posts
998
Location
South Coast
Seems further delays on these boards what with the chinese new year but pricing on websites seem to indicate £170-£190 range. Not sure where that will place them in desireability when you can get a 5770 for £113 and a 5850 for £210.

Surely anyone willing to pay £190 would simply pay the extra £20 and get the 5850
 
I have seen the 5830 for sale (not in stock) for 169.....you are right in that I'd rather spend 30 more for a 5850
 
I have seen the 5830 for sale (not in stock) for 169.....you are right in that I'd rather spend 30 more for a 5850

What if its 10% slower, but £30 cheaper and overclocks the same and is only say 8% slower at the maximum overclocks of both cards.

A LOT of people wouldn't pay £30 or £40 more for a card that wasn't that much faster and the bigger buyers of cards, the Dell type companies, will happily save £5 on a cheaper card for use in the right priced computer.

Just like the 5870 is a completely stupid buy for an enthusiast willing to overclock a 5850, but Dell would happily buy 5870's so they can sell the computer with the "fastest card in the world" in it. AMD, Intel, Nvidia, they produce products at price points their buyers want, we're less than 1% of those guys sales, Dell and the likes are the massive majority, and what they want, they get. The gap between the 5770 and the 5850 is huge and any product at ANY price point between them will make them very happy.

If the 5830 works out as great value for us, whoopdedoo, if it doesn't, well as you've just said, you'd prefer to spend the extra on a 5850, which you have the option of doing. Options, thats what more products give us, some will take that option and some won't want it, just because you won't buy it doesn't mean its a bad choice. Plenty of people won't buy a 5850, that doesn't make it pointless.
 
Well we will have to wait for benchmarks....as most know these cards are mostly ROP limited so we'll have to see what kind of performance hit they take from the approximate 10% drop in ROPs
 
What if its 10% slower, but £30 cheaper and overclocks the same and is only say 8% slower at the maximum overclocks of both cards.

A LOT of people wouldn't pay £30 or £40 more for a card that wasn't that much faster and the bigger buyers of cards, the Dell type companies, will happily save £5 on a cheaper card for use in the right priced computer.

Just like the 5870 is a completely stupid buy for an enthusiast willing to overclock a 5850, but Dell would happily buy 5870's so they can sell the computer with the "fastest card in the world" in it. AMD, Intel, Nvidia, they produce products at price points their buyers want, we're less than 1% of those guys sales, Dell and the likes are the massive majority, and what they want, they get. The gap between the 5770 and the 5850 is huge and any product at ANY price point between them will make them very happy.
This is especially true in this case, since it gives them a cheaper card that still has the magic 58 at the beginning.
 
Plenty of people won't buy a 5850, that doesn't make it pointless.

The pointless slant on my post is more of a question on placement. Like you say many cards can be oc'd by the enthusiast but the 5770-5850-5870 price jumps are pretty stable £100 roughly so the mid price point cards seem a little strange to me. Especially the higher up you go.

But as others have said I guess it will depend upon final price and performance
 
the new Cypress-powered card features 1280 Stream Processors, 60 Texture Units, a 750 MHz core clock, a 256-bit memory interface, 1GB of GDDR5 memory @ 4000 MHz, and dual DVI, HDMI, plus DisplayPort outputs.

Not sure how accurate this is
 
I really want this card to arrive. I'm not prepared to pay £210 on a graphics card that will be worthless in 9 months time, I did all that in my younger years.

I was going to get a HD5770 but from all the reviews I've read it's just not much faster than what I already have at 1680x1050 so I would like a step up. A £170 HD5830 would be ideal and at £40 cheaper than a £210 HD5850, good value if it turns out that way.
 
Last edited:
I really want this card to arrive. I'm not prepared to pay £210 on a graphics card that will be worthless in 9 months time, I did all that in my younger years.

I was going to get a HD5770 but from all the reviews I've read it's just not much faster than what I already have at 1680x1050 so I would like a step up. A £170 HD5830 would be ideal and at £40 cheaper than a £210 HD5850, good value if it turns out that way.

Oh yeah, I hate the way graphics cards just suddenly stop working 9 months after you buy them! :p
 
Back
Top Bottom