Furthermore, I don't understand why when anyone brings this up you seem to go into a defensive stance akin to a child putting their fingers in this ears and screaming "La-La-La, I'M NOT LISTENING!!!".
I'm sorry but when did I do this ? ...I have always as far as I remember argued my case and given reasons for why I do things the way I do, I have never just not listened to what people have to say. I may not take the suggestions and advice but it does not mean I haven't listened/read what you had to say. Some of it is rather good and some of it, not so much ...as you would expect.
I might have been a bit terse with you at times but then your style of posting or perhaps the manner in which you come across does wind me up sometimes ...although that very much depends on what mood I am already in when I read it.
I don't know what Fox was thinking, but my suggestion would be to get the 540i fixed once and for all and then finally enjoy it. You weren't going to get the money back, but you would have at least got some use out of it.
I can understand changing a car just because you want to change, I understand that completely and go through that process myself about every 7 and a half minutes, but that never really seems to be your justification, does it? You seem to be obsessed "reliability" and avoiding problems, which is again something that I can just about understand, but what I do not understand is why someone who feels such a way would chop in an expensive to run barge where you have a fair idea of where the problems lie for yet another expensive to run barge that is completely unknown to you? A dull, dreary hatchback would have made a tiny bit of sense for this purpose, not a Jaguar.
Sorry to seem like a wet blanket. Don't get me wrong, I think that you've brought a lovely car, but I just can't understand why you've brought. If you had said "Because I wanted it", I'd say fair play, but your justification always seems to stem from the fact that you bought a dog on an E39 and refused to maintain/fix it.
Anyway with regards to why I bought the car, yes I wanted it ...really I want my old Jag back but that's not going to happen so I had to find another one. I may not have just said something as simple as 'I feel like it' ..because I had a series of other reasons in this case, but yes, I felt like it. Why I felt like it though is the question ...and would I have felt this way had the 540i worked out the way I wanted? ....mmm maybe, maybe not ...I can't know for sure. I do know that I wouldn't resent the car now, I might still have changed it in a relatively short period ...but I don't think I would have quite so soon as I have. As I said, in the other thread I made, end of the day I want rid of it now, I dislike the car, I don't dislike 540s ...I love them, I just don't like that one very much.
I really did want the 540i to work out, but not at such a high cost, but, as it stands things didn't work out the way I wanted them to. It just had a seemingly colossal list of problems, some of them very expensive to sort out ...and were just going further than I had ever really wanted to go. There does come a point when you have to say enough is enough. I could have carried on I suppose, but at this point I just don't feel like it, I don't want to any-more ...the car isn't the object of my desire now, it's just annoying and expensive. Perhaps it's because I know what it's really like when it's not right, I could have gotten a really good one and had years of relatively trouble free motoring with just the usual E39s issues ...as it happens I got one that it would seem already had some fairly substantial issues, some of them outside of the nrom for well cared for cars. Now this is my fault for buying this one, that's my impatience getting me again though.
The one that really concerns me though it the nasty rattle from the timing-chain I get when I start the car from cold about 60% of the time, and the constant tapping from the engine ...that's not right, I've been saying it all along and it worries me ...the only way to properly sort it out is to have the whole front of the engine apart, if the chain guides and secondary tensioners need replacing then it's a big, big job. To remove the lower timing case covers the main crank bolt has to come off, which is torqued up with some insanely high force. They call it the Jesus bolt on the BMW for a good reason. It's not something most people could remove at home really. Then you need a series of special tools to lock the cams in place etc ...and then there is the issue of VANOS units ...actually they are 'relatively' simple compared the the whole chain job but still £650 each ...that's just for me to buy and fit too. To fix the engine to my satisfaction is no small or cheap task, infact it's pretty massive really. In addition to this and all the smaller niggly issues, the gearbox needs to come out to replace the main shaft seals ...not something I can do and that's an expensive job too, although cheap compared to the engine work.
Would you have carried on trying to make it the way you wanted indefinitely ? I know it could be done, if I sank about £2k into it right now. Which you might say is half what I just laid out anyway ...but I'm more inclined to find the other £2k and go back to a Jag. It wasn't/isn't a particularly exciting car, as in thrill a minute stuff ...but then neither is this 540i ...and I did love driving the Jag, it's just such a nice place to be. Right now my 540i has a varied selection of rattles and squeaks which have come along over the months, it only had one I noticed when I bought it ...and just recently it developed a nice new and very annoying one somewhere around the passenger door or the seatbelt anchor point ...this is not a nice place to be, it's just annoying. The ride isn't very good now either, it jiggles and crashes over our poor roads, which shakes yet more of the car loose. The engine is still leaking air so it doesn't sound right, it's not got the right sharp note to it, it sounds woolly and wooshy ...an M62TU shouldn't actually sound like that, it should be clear and sharp and precise. The idle is not stable with the aircon off and blipping the throttle with it on will still cause the car to stumble about 25% of the time, and the dash lights will flicker, I could go one.
Oh also, I am not "obsessed" with reliability and avoiding potential issues, you see that's part of your posting style that winds me up. I am 'concerned' about it yes, who wouldn't be ? ...you must have a fair idea about the sort of things that can go wrong with cars like these and the potential costs involved. I like big luxury cars yes, and I don't really have big luxury car money ...but thanks to our used car market I can still drive them, but I am acutely aware of the sorts of things that can and do go wrong with older cars of this type and the costs involved. Just because I am eager to avoid an autobox going kaput or an air suspension collapsing does not mean I want to drive a Focus for peace of mind, it just means I'm going to be careful and keep my eyes peeled for any signs of such issues arising.