I've owned an extremely similar car to what I recommended for 2 whole years now, I wouldn't recommend it unless I thought it was the best car for the requirements, fact. The only reason you recommended both those random Polos because you got excited over the fact that they were low mileage - you can't dispute that as you made a big point of it. The point I am making is that both of those Polos are getting on a bit, each MOT is going to be a bum clencher, why do that to yourself when you can buy a car that is much newer and better equipped. The only thing so far you've pointed out is that in a head on crash, you *might* fare better, that's not even a given, how many accidents happen to fall into the exact same scenarios that ncap test in? It's just a rough idea and even at that both cars got that SAME rating. I think you've picked a random car and not really thought about it.