Finished it last night (after rushing through the last section of the game as I was tired of waves upon waves of mobs lol).
The pros:
- character development - for most part I was quite impressed with how it was handled, although getting that one particular character do what he did at the end of the game left me flabbergasted as e was my love interest - needless to say he faced the blade
- the story - once you realise the game is spread over 7 years you will understand why the game doesn't have a defined storyline. The final conflict is there from the very beginning (although at background level), but the game isn't about it - it's about how you rose to the title of Champion of Kirkwall and that it tells impeccably. Some events (related to your mother for example) made me wish my enemies long and painful deaths (lo and behold, being a blood mage I delivered

), others left a really warm feeling inside. If that ain't excellent story telling, I don't know what is
- graphics - bar the annoying dx11 related freeze ups the effects were actually quite good
- boss fights - for a single player game very involving and having a WoW feel to them (a good thing) - granted, I found it ridiculous that the last two bosses were nothing compared to the likes of Pride Demon, High Dragon and Ancient Rock Wraith, but I enjoyed figuring out every fight (played on hard)
- crafting - a vast improvement over DAO's 'I need hundred of this weed and fifty of the other to get enough potions to last me a lifetime'
The cons
- the recycling of maps - Chris Priestly once said that the game takes up less memory than DAO because of better compression - by better compression I guess he meant compressing the number of locations you visit AND recycling the maps in very obvious ways
- I'm openly a blood mage (and nobody seems to mind), fighting other blood mages...what? One bit of the story that really nagged me
- bugs - loads of them, some game breaking (get Vael to friendly the add and remove him from your party and watch your damage resistance go into negatives, same with Isabella and attack speed), some ridiculous (maker's sigh from black emporium giving you nigh on limitless number of ability points)...going to wait until Bioware fixes the game before I try it again
- tedious trash mobs - mainly of the demon kind (cause they were immune to pulling and pushing lol)